Police said Monday that a comatose hospital patient was suffocated with a wet towel at a hospital in Yokkaichi City, Mie Prefecture.
A nurse discovered the 35-year-old patient dead at about 8 p.m. on Sunday, TBS reported. Hospital staff say the victim, who was brain dead before the incident, had been at the hospital for seven years.
Police say the 69-year-old father of the victim had visited about an hour before the man was discovered dead. The father's body was discovered in a car not too far from the hospital on Monday morning. Police believe he committed suicide and said a suicide note was left at his home, TBS reported.
© Japan Today
30 Comments
Login to comment
some14some
"Kizuna."
bonword
Brain dead for seven years. Poor family. I wonder who made the decision to keep him on life support for the seven years? I am assuming it is a family decision in Japan but I really don't know. Anyone?
Mirai Hayashi
Mercy killing...let him go! Let him go!
DenTok2009
Suffocating is a terrible way to go. Don't get me wrong. I am in favor of mercy killing. If I am diagnosed with a terminal illness, I don't want to hang on till my organs shut down. I want painkillers galore.
I wonder the same thing as bonword plus the insurance. If the 35 year old patient was a company employee before his injury, was his company insurance paying for his care? If not, was he under his father's insurance? Maybe paying his son's hospital bills finally drove the father over the edge. The father may have gone through his savings and retirement nowadays is bleak.
CrazyJoe
I suspect the father killed his son and then commited suicide.
Yubaru
Japan has some archaic laws regarding the definition of life and what is allowable in death. My family here had to sign quite a bit of legal paperwork telling the hospital not to use a respirator when my mother in law was ill, her life could have been prolonged by using one, but it would have been a hellish one at best. In the case of my father in law, we were getting to the stage where we were discussing the issue with the doctors and he had an arrest and the hospital inserted the tube and connected the respirator because we did not tell them otherwise, they were doing what they had to do, but it just extended his already brain dead life. It was hell.
If a person's heart is still beating they are considered alive. Also once a respirator has been put into use with the patient it is extremely difficult to have it removed. Many brain dead people in prolonged vegetative states do and have survived for decades with the assist of the respirator.
nath
Respirators can be turned off. After the patient passes, you plug it back in again.
wontond
Poor father. The decision must have been agonizing for him.
LFRAgain
The father committed suicide later, according to the article.
kurisupisu
The function of a hospital is what exactly?
As a business it is to make money.
Does it matter that a patient will never be cured?
No
The prolongation of life even in a vegetative state is the norm in many countries.
For whose benefit?
Ranger_Miffy2
So what did the father's suicide note back home have to say?
Ranger_Miffy2
And...what was the "incident" that destroyed this young man? Too much left out of this story!
cleo
If the man had been brain-dead for 7 years, then it's the father and other family members that suffered. I cannot imagine how I would feel if it were one of mine in that situation. It's hard enough to accept a loss when the loved one is obviously dead, but when the heart is still beating and the body still warm......hell for all concerned.
But is it legally possible to murder a person who is brain-dead?
Yubaru
Yes it is, if their heart is still beating.
Mirai Hayashi
Poor guy...he was probably living in hell with his son in that state.
cleo
That makes organ transplants impossible, then. Or at least illegal?
The Munya Times
Yes, but it lasts only a few minutes and safe, more and more suicidal chooses this cruel way. Otherwise, almost every kind of death is suffocation, as in most cases the breathing stops before the final heart or brain failure or finally losing consciousness.
It's been going on is hospitals in many countries of the world secretly for long time, but in most cases only for the rich who can afford paying for mercy killing, although it's a mistake to think it is painless. They go through the same horror of suffocation, just without towel.
Yet, it would be civil in the 21st century to find a legal solution for this issue and not letting people living in desperate fear and suffering for prolong time, not letting them commit suicide or not letting unscrupulous quacks black marketeering with death.
cleo
But surely the brain-dead would feel nothing? Isn't that what brain-dead means? That to all intents and purposes they're already dead?
bonword
Thank you Yubaru for the informative and also personal information in regards to respirators and QL decisions.
I greatly appreciate these types of comments.
Nessie
Yes, Yubaru. Great posts. Thank you.
@JapanGal
I see we have some readers with a pragmatic bent.
In any case, it's too bad this mercy killing made the father take his own life. I think the court would have shown some sympathy for these circumstances.
m5c32
I'd imagine these devices would have an activity log which would record anomalies --if not actively monitored itself (i.e. monitored remotely for mechano-electrical failure) whereby any interruption would result in staff being alerted within seconds of an unexpected event.
LH10
RIP U__U
FightingViking
Brought back some extremely painful and terrible memories although 2 years and 3 months doesn't compare to seven years...
No mention if the poor wife/mother is still alive ? Losing a son and a husband at the same time - how much worse could it get ?
Geoff Gillespie
Do you really think so? You could be right there...
nandakandamanda
A wet towel. This is one of the central techniques of waterboarding. To experience the sensation of drowning. One of the most horrible tortures, apparently.
With waterboarding though, you have to learn to stop each time before the prisoner dies.
If the son was braindead though, who knows?
Allison Honig
Sad.... just sad. But think about it, mabey he loved his son so much he didn't want him to be so confuesed and scared when he woke up? That's why he killed him. "Love hurts a whole lot but how I feel now makes it hurt more"
dolphingirl
This man was comatose and it is not clear whether he was brain dead or not. Either way, it is sad that in this day and age there are not better options for people who have a loved one in these states. It's just suffering for everyone. Why not let the person die with at least a little dignity?
Elbuda Mexicano
Mercy KILLINGS?? They should not be called KILLINGS, they should be called something else, mercy hand or something, this old dude did they right thing, no one can just stand around and see their son lay their like a vegetable. RIP
Hide Suzuki
@dolphingirl
"the victim, who was brain dead before the incident"
Nessie
Mercy picnics? Pity parties?