The Osaka District Court on Friday sentenced a 33-year-old man to nine years in prison for fatally abusing his 3-year-old stepson at their home in Sakai in 2015.
According to the verdict, Wataru Tsunemine and his wife Mika, 23, kept their son Eichi in captivity in a bathtub, after which he was found dead in June 2015, Fuji TV reported.
Following the boy’s death, the couple contacted emergency services, and the two were continuously questioned by police on suspicion of domestic abuse. The couple had continued denying any involvement, saying that they found the boy drowned in the bathtub when they checked on him.
The court heard that at the time of his death, Eichi had nearly 40 bruises and other wounds on his body, including cigarette burns.
The case took a different turn last year after Tsunemine changed his story and confessed that he intentionally murdered his stepson.
Police said he told them that Eichi was nothing but an obstacle in the couple's lives. He said he became stressed out and killed Eichi by drowning him in the bathtub.
Mika, who has denied any involvement in her son's death, has yet to stand trial.
© Japan Today
34 Comments
Login to comment
sensei258
So sad. Only nine years for murder? Guess he didn't mean much to the court either.
DaDude
2 things he had going for him for getting only 9 years: Only one person was killed and the person killed was a child. Children have low priority here. If it was a baby though, it would have been half the sentence.
SenseNotSoCommon
At least it's a custodial and not a suspended sentence. Poor child.
Aly Rustom
poor child. he only got to live 3 years and by and large they were hell. -40 bruises and other wounds on his body, including cigarette burns- I'm speechless. I hug and kiss my toddler son every day to show him how much I love him. This little guy got nothing of the love he should have. and the bastard who made his life both short and hell only gets 9 years.
and YOU are nothing but an obstacle for decent hardworking people. They should have given you the electric chair you son of a B. You deserve nothing less.
BertieWooster
Tortured to death and he only gets NINE YEARS?
sensei258
@ Aly - I'm with you 100% about this guy.
Don't ever stop.
smithinjapan
Ah, the belljar verdict is in. A woman in the US got 40 years the other day for the murder of her child. In Japan we're seeing a higher than normal sentence at NINE years. That's how much a human family member's life is worth here.
Ah_so
Where I am from, the murder of a child is considered worse than the murder of an adult. This may be a cultural thing, but sadistic murders are always considered utterly evil.
What I cannot understand in any sense is how the murder of a child, paticularly a sadistic one, could be considered less than the murder of a child.
It is usually through the law that I appreciate that Japan is a very foreign country, which has very different cultural assumptions at its core. Ones which I will never understand and never like.
canadianbento
This Creep only gets 9 years for killing his own Son, something wrong with this Justice System, he should have got LIFE!
Aly Rustom
Thanks brother
Not a chance in hell
sensei258
Why do they say it like that? Just call it what it is, murder most foul.
Tokyo-Engr
The guy admitted killing the stepson and also said the stepson was nothing but an obstacle in their lives.....and gets only 9 years?!?! You've got to be kidding!!! What was the rationale for such a short sentence!?!? Unreal
NZ2011
having some trouble conceiving, this stuff breaks my heart.. what is so terribly broken in these people to have them treat children in these ways.
Mirai Hayashi
Only 9 years? Where is the justice?!?!?
smithinjapan
Tokyo-Engr: "and gets only 9 years?!?! You've got to be kidding!!! What was the rationale for such a short sentence!?!?"
TIJ
TheGodfather
"Japanese media reports that Eichi was Mika's child and that he was living in an institution before Mika married Wataru. The couple declared they wanted to raise him and poor little Eichi went to live with his mother and stepfather only three months before he died"
So it appears that the marriage was a sham and the only reason was so that the man who was ten years older than the mother could take the boy from the institution to abuse and murder him, while pocketing the child support payments.
Strangerland
Where are you getting that from?
bones
Maybe just maybe if they actually gave lengthy prison sentences to convicted people it would deter others from committing serious crimes! It seems like you can commit almost any crime in Japan and all you have to do is show remorse and pretend to be sorry and get a short or suspended sentence.
zones2surf
The common theme in all of these cases involving parents / guardians and children is that it is a family matter involving minors.
I cannot explain it, but Japanese courts will give stiffer but still lenient sentences to those that kill an adult in a one time event, than they do to those that kill minors, even those that they have repeatedly abused.
Japanese courts have very little regard for the murder of minors, it would seem.
Ah_so
No, it wouldn't. But better justice would be done.
samwatters
Can't read anymore. I have to go and hug my son now......
Speed
This is probably the thing I hate the most about this country. The light sentences given to child murderers.
Twenty years of this and I've stopped being shocked. But the feeling of disgust continues.
Kobe White Bar Owner
An eye for an eye, if only his punishment could be the same as what he/it dished out. May karma be real!!!
mtuffizi
poor sentence. 9 years for abuse and killing a life. death penalty more fitted in
rocketpanda
So this scum will be out in his early 40s. Should have made it 90 years in a 2mx2m cell.
sensei258
9 years is a joke, and the court should be ashamed
sir_bentley28
That poor baby. He did nothing to this fiend. His excuse for doing it just sickens me.
John Beara
That's the age of my son... evil parents
peterl
Unfortunately, in most parts of the world, it is true. In the U.S., people who cause the death of a child through abuse and/or neglect receive up to 40% shorter sentences than if an adult was killed. There are even cases where such abuse and death cases go unreported:
http://projects.statesman.com/news/cps-missed-signs/undercounting.html
nath
9 years? Only 9 years? Wow!
Takuma7
Why only 9 years? Why not death like he did to his stepson?