The requested article has expired, and is no longer available. Any related articles, and user comments are shown below.
© KYODOChina hands Japanese man 5 1/2 years in prison for state secret theft
BEIJING©2024 GPlusMedia Inc.
The requested article has expired, and is no longer available. Any related articles, and user comments are shown below.
© KYODO
29 Comments
Login to comment
Fendy
The man imprisoned without knowing why - “geological survey.” ... “no concrete actions” - perhaps he mistakenly came across their underground nuclear missile testing facility?
extanker
@akie
I always have to stop and make sure what I'm reading isn't sarcasm with these comments...
Chip Star
Still holding o. To your belief that this guy was a spy?
Aly Rustom
Exactly! Well said Smith!
smithinjapan
Chip Star: "China is such a peaceful and open society, isn't it?"
We're not terribly far off here, frankly, and as more time passes Japan is becoming more like it's neighbour.
Ganbare Japan: "Because there is no evidence produced that he is a spy."
Wow, you've seen all the evidence or the lack thereof? None of the rest of us have.
TorafusuTorasan
@dark--"a bit old for being a spy"--yeah, even spies need to retire and collect their pensions sometime. Otherwise countries would often hire retirement-age spies to do their dirty work. One plus for aged spies is they would be doing less time in prison. In this case, a 5 1/2 sentence could be more a symbolic warning to other careless contractors than their legal code's recommended punishment for a serious spying violation.
David Van Cleef
Mapping data in general is considered state-secret level in China.
See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Restrictions_on_geographic_data_in_China
Akie
darknuts, the best spy is unthinkable spy, Japan knows that very well.
darknuts
Isn't that a bit old for being a spy?
BeerDeliveryGuy
It depends. The Navy docks at Hainan are in plain view, and tourists are generally tolerated to photograph them. I think some overzealous cop saw them and their equipment, and made the wrong conclusion.
darknuts
Isn't that a bit for being a spy?
BeerDeliveryGuy
This man is part of a geological survey team that was hired by a Chinese corporation to search for thermal vents for a hot spring resort.
As I speculated when they were first arrested, their equipment was probably mistaken for spy equipment (ground penetrating radars, acoustic resonance scanners, etc), and China is trying to save face, or they were photographing submarines and warships, esp the new aircraft carrier under construction at Hainan island (that are in plain view).
Sh1mon M4sada
@Akie
I believe you, there are many state secrets hidden in the grounds, 15 millions Chinese that died during the Great Leap Forward for instance. All buried in the ground?
Sh1mon M4sada
This is how the CCP treats its friends people, the geologist is lucky he didn't get charged for 'unspecified' act against China.
Akie, perhaps you could make a few calls...
John Beara
70 years old... and still working, damn..
Aly Rustom
Chip Star- 100% on the money! As usual. Regardless of whether or not he is a spy, China is a beligerent country that needs to be sanctioned, ostracized and condemned
Strangerland
Heh, it's cute watching Chinese try to pretend like their system of oppression of the people can be justified.
They think we're going to be as easy to brainwash as they were1
Chip Star
The verdicts are announced, but the procedures, evidence, and trial are all kept secret. It's an insult to justice. Absolutely repugnant in this day and age.
Akie
Chip Star, if the court is not open to the public, how do you know he was sentenced to 5 years and half ?
Chip Star
There is no way you can know he was a spy because courts in China are not open to the public, unlike in truly open countries where justice matters.
Chip Star
Chinese courts don't release evidence to the public. This means we are correct to be skeptical of the conviction, it does not mean we can know there was no evidence.
More speculation.
Ganbare Japan!
Because there is no evidence produced that he is a spy.
He is political pawn used by Communists.
Akie
Use a 70 year old man as a spy, what is Japan doing ?
Chip Star
How can you know this?
WA4TKG
This is because someone didn't get paid off.
Ganbare Japan!
Outrageous. This old man is not a spy, he is just being punished because he is Japanese. Summon the Chinese Ambassador in Tokyo immediately to lodge official protest.
Chip Star
Closed courts = shams, which means we can safely dountbthe veracity of the conviction. China is such a peaceful and open society, isn't it?