Photo: YouTube/Netflix
entertainment

How do fans in Japan feel about the new 'One Piece' Netflix live-action trailer?

12 Comments
By Casey Baseel, SoraNews24

It’s been more than six years since "One Piece" creator Eiichiro Oda announced that his smash hit pirate manga/anime franchise was getting a produced-in-America live-action adaptation, and more than three years since Netflix publicly became the company making it happen.

Screen-Shot-2023-07-27-at-13.27.38.png

Now that we’re less than two months away from the premiere of the Netflix "One Piece," the streaming giant is releasing the last sneak peeks at the series, with the latest trailer revealed just a few days ago.

"One Piece" is a series with fans around the world, but it’s in its home country of Japan that it’s been a bona fide pop cultural juggernaut for the last two decades-plus. The previous Netflix "One Piece" trailer, from back in May, had many fans in Japan disappointed with how the live-action version of the Straw Hat Pirates’ ship looked, but how’s the reaction been to the new trailer?

Extremely positive, at least as far as YouTube comments go.

Sifting though the comments for the Japanese-subtitled version of the trailer (no dubbed-into-Japanese version currently exists), it’s hard to find any unhappy reactions, even if not everyone is 100-percent on board quite yet

“I had so many worries about the adaptation, but after watching this, I can’t wait to see it!”

“I like how they’re balancing loyalty to the source material and creating a natural, realistic atmosphere.”

“I really like how it looks like instead of being a live-action anime, it’s like they’re going for what it’d be like if the world of One Piece existed in our reality.”

“They aren’t going overboard on the setting or characterizations, but they’ve got a firm grasp on what makes them special, It’s a good balance for a fantasy story.”

“When you adapt anime to live-action, it’s always going to feel at least a little like cosplay, but I think they’ve done an incredible job making it look this polished, so I’m looking forward to watching this.”

“At first, I thought that Luffy felt like a totally different character, but watching this trailer, he’s won me over.”

“I totally like how it doesn’t feel like a shonen manga, but a pirate series for adults.”

“I’ve seen a lot of live-action adaptations of anime, but this is the first time a trailer has me this excited about watching one.”

Screen-Shot-2023-07-27-at-13.28.01.png

About as negative as things have gotten is:

“My initial impression is that I don’t hate it, so that’s a big win for it so far.”

“I’m worried about some of what I see in the acting and fight choreography, but this video still has me wanting to check the series out.”

Screen-Shot-2023-07-27-at-13.28.08.png

Perhaps part of the open-minded attitude comes from the fact that, at least within Japan, there’s zero chance of Netflix’s "One Piece" hurting the reputation of the "One Piece" anime/manga or replacing them in people’s as the minds as the primary image of what the story and characters are, considering how "One Piece" has been a pop culture institution for so many years here.

That might be making it easier for even hardcore fans to think a little more flexibly about the adaptation and see it as an alternative take on what Oda created, especially with reactions like “This is exactly how a live-action adaptation should be. You can really feel the love that everyone involved has for the original series” and “Can’t say if it’s going to turn out well or not, but you can feel the love for the source material” showing that people appreciate that the changes that have been made don’t seem to be full-on subversions of what they love about "One Piece."

Screen-Shot-2023-07-27-at-13.28.16.png

Netflix’s "One Piece" comes out on August 31.

Source: YouTube/Netflix Japan

Images: YouTube/Netflix

Read more stories from SoraNews24.

-- Netflix’s live-action One Piece shows off massive ships and sets in preview video【Video】

-- Sanrio’s Gudetama is getting a Netflix series…that’s live-action??

-- Live-action Cowboy Bebop cast revealed by Netflix, but there’s someone missing from the crew

© SoraNews24

©2024 GPlusMedia Inc.

12 Comments
Login to comment

Extremely positive, at least as far as YouTube comments go.

The English language comments are somewhat different.

A fair amount of criticism of the costume play level of some of the sets and costumes and performances.

I'm slightly interested. Anime is difficult to translate to live action. Best I have seen so far is with some of the AI tools.

4 ( +4 / -0 )

Seems nice... for the cast of an attraction in Huis Ten Bosch.

-2 ( +2 / -4 )

Ah more woke garbage, I forsee another massive money loss and no second season. Yet to see a good adoption of an anime to film, maybe that's a sign that they should just leave it alone.

-1 ( +4 / -5 )

Looks kind of fun. Never followed ONE PIECE so I don’t have any particular expectations or anything to compare this adaptation with.

Ah more woke garbage

There’s that word “woke” again. What is this wokeness your keen eyes have spotted in the trailer?

6 ( +8 / -2 )

At least way better than a Japanese live action

1 ( +3 / -2 )

Well, I have never watched the anime so I can go into this with an open mind. So I'm looking forward to it, especially since the anime in Japan doesn't have English at all.

4 ( +4 / -0 )

Honestly looks good to me as a trailer. Going still temper my expectations though.

4 ( +4 / -0 )

After watching the first episode of the live-action version of Cowboy Bebop on Netflix which was awful, I'm not expecting anything special from this. Looks lame to me.

1 ( +4 / -3 )

What a pathetic piece of garbage...

Netflix, stop ruining anime!!..

-3 ( +3 / -6 )

my wife watches ONE PIECE most Sunday mornings at 9:30 so I tend to watch it out of the corner of my eye, there is no way you can do a live action adaptation of this program just on Netflix. Maybe a big budget film using a hell of a ton of cgi then maybe and that’s a big maybe

0 ( +0 / -0 )

Silly looking sail on that boat, but what the heck, it's live anime. Not my bag, but there are obviously fans of it so let them drool.

-1 ( +0 / -1 )

there is no way you can do a live action adaptation of this program just on Netflix. Maybe a big budget film using a hell of a ton of cgi then maybe and that’s a big maybe

Netflix live-action One Piece has a budget of US$18 million per episode! Do ya want even more money?!

https://collider.com/one-piece-netflix-live-action-budget/

Netflix's live-action One Piece adaptation reportedly boasts a budget of $18 million per episode, making it one of the most expensive shows ever made. To put into context how much that is compared to other massive shows, One Piece has a bigger per-episode budget than The Sandman, See, Game of Thrones, and The Mandalorian, all of which cost $15 million per episode.

1 ( +2 / -1 )

Login to leave a comment

Facebook users

Use your Facebook account to login or register with JapanToday. By doing so, you will also receive an email inviting you to receive our news alerts.

Facebook Connect

Login with your JapanToday account

User registration

Articles, Offers & Useful Resources

A mix of what's trending on our other sites