The requested article has expired, and is no longer available. Any related articles, and user comments are shown below.
© 2020 AFPN-word dropped from French edition of Agatha Christie novel
By JACK TAYLOR PARIS©2024 GPlusMedia Inc.
Video promotion
The requested article has expired, and is no longer available. Any related articles, and user comments are shown below.
© 2020 AFP
36 Comments
Login to comment
Billy B
Next up; a complete rewrite of Hollywood classic Boyz in the hood.
divinda
And every Quinten Tarentino film.
Tom Jj
“Every record has been destroyed or falsified, every book rewritten, every picture has been repainted, every statue and street building has been renamed, every date has been altered. And the process is continuing day by day and minute by minute. History has stopped. Nothing exists except an endless present in which the Party is always right.”
Pukey2
I remember reading her book when I was very young. It was my sister's copy and she used to read a lot of her books. I still remember it had the N* word and the front cover had a hanging golliwog. I was only a kid, so it didn't ring any alarm bells, but looking back - totally shocking.
ohara
Pathetique.
Hervé L'Eisa
Then also rewrite every rap song.
Vince Black
What a farce.
Numan
Yeah!!!! It is good to see all the racists and racist apologists coming out of the wood works!
Toasted Heretic
Why people getting offended 'cos they can't use the N-word.
Poor why people.
noriahojanen
Shakespeare's work could be a next target...
quercetum
One example of the view at the time was the dialogue between Emily and Vera Claiborne where Vera listened aghast to Emily referring to Africans as “our brothers.” Another was Lombard dismissing abandoning the 20 East African men to die for they were just natives.
Silvafan
Some people mostly of European descent debating the right to call Africans the "n-word," yet they get made for being called racist!
Go figure!
Toasted Heretic
Context. It's all about context.
bass4funk
Don't forget Spike Lee movies as well.
bass4funk
I hate the word, never liked it, but why is it ok when blacks use it and others can't? Nowadays when you watch every Youtube video of these riots and protests it seems everyone is using the word so why change these books and movies. PC hypocrisy at its worst.
Numan
@P.Smith
I did not know Agatha Christie books were history. I thought it was fiction writing.
People should not be offended by obscene words regardless of is using it or for what reason?
@Bass
After White people used it as derogatory term for people of African descent, the reclamation of the word as a neutral or positive term in black culture (not universally regarded as a worthwhile enterprise), often with a suggestion of "soul" or "style," started first in the U.S. South, later (1968) in the Northern, urban-based Black Power movement.
White people created the problem, so they needed to face the consequences of their actions. Is that not the definition of responsibility?
bass4funk
Ok, so then why blacks can use it? Whites created the problem, No one else can say it, but blacks can say a word that the whites created? Why?
Seems very hypocritical to me.
Numan
@Bass
LOL! You should read more!
bass4funk
I do, too much! That's why never ask me about gaming.
bass4funk
And who made this determination?
But a lot of them do, I see it on videos everyday. So if you make that argument then the “S or F” can be claimed as words created by whites and no one can use them either because of the connotation behind them. All I’m saying, it’s a weak and flawed argument, if blacks don’t want whites to use a word they despise, then they shouldn’t use such a vile word as well, but they have a double standard and say it’s ok if they use it, but anyone else, sorry. Ludicrous.
englisc aspyrgend
Rampant cancel culture. Pathetic.
fxgai
Personally, I think I only ever read the plot summary of the book before - great story too - but I’d rather read a version without the N bomb littered throughout.
ohara
Personally, I think I only ever read the plot summary of the book before - great story too - but I’d rather read a version without the N bomb littered throughout.
But I have read it and the “N bomb” ISNT littered throughout.
Its used in the title and thats about it.
If you want “littered throughout” go to absolutely any Tarantino movie. Logically, I assume his films will be next on the cancel list.
I wonder.
ohara
The word is spoken over 100 times in Django Unchained, for example.
ohara
And yes, then theres Spike Lee - but he probably gets a pass, right Toasted Heretic?
Jimizo
Poor old William has long been attacked as a dead, white European male.
I still rate the texts of the monotheisms as the least PC books I’ve read.
Anyone going to try playing around with their more problematic ideas?
Paul
Here we go! Let's rewrite everything to make it socially correct even if it was written 1000 years ago.... Wait, Einstein made some racially derogatory statements about Chinese, lets edit all that out!!! And Julius Caesar made some statements about the Jews and so did the Egyptian Pharaoh, we must rewrite all history!!!
How more stupid can this get???
oldman_13
I applaud this long due decision, done by a direct descendant of Christie herself.
The ones here complaining about this action (cancel culture, excessive political correctness, so on) would be the very same ones applauding if bigoted slurs and statements in Japan (against non-Japanese) were to be dropped and censored out.
starpunk
These dirty words are reflections of what people were in the past and it should be taken that way. Also in modern lit, characters who use such ugly language are written in by the author to show the reader what type of ignorant buttheads those characters are. Ugly and racist words should not be used by sensible people in their everyday speech and having these obnoxious characters in novels should show the reader what not to be, it shows how stupid some people are.
In the 5th grade my teacher who was married to a Ukrainian Holocaust survivor wrote many ethnic slurs (incl. white-bashing) on the board, explained what they mean and why we shouldn't refer to others by those words. She was smart.
Ah_so
I've ticked the "slippery slope" fallacy in today's angry white male bingo.
What what's next?
Of course, the old, "blacks say it so why can't I?" nonsense. If you don't understand why black people use it, perhaps you should find out.
I expect you want to demand that gay people stop using "queer" and also demand back the original use of "gay" before it was appropriated.
Ah_so
The title of this book was offensive enough at the time not to be published with the English title in America.
The title adds nothing to the story and only refers to a song that most will never have heard. The new title is fine. Or "ten green bottles" would be fine too.
By contrast, the idea of removing Gone with the Wind seems absurd - a step too far. Thankfully it wasn't.
Ah_so
I think dropping it from a required reading list was rather silly, but the book has not been banned or refuted and it is still available in the library for those that want to read it.
fxgai
ohara,
But according to the article, “The word "negre" appeared 74 times in the French version of the book”.
That’s my idea of “littered throughout”!