entertainment

The top 10 manga to live-action adaptations

15 Comments
By Krista Rogers

Sometimes fans groan when they hear that their beloved book is going to be made into a movie. Manga fans often have the same reaction when they learn that their favorite manga will be turned into a live-action film or drama adaptation. But not all of these adaptations turn out to be cringeworthy. Readers on one Japanese website chose the best live-action adaptations of popular manga. Do you agree with their ranking?

The ranking was the result of 906 eligible responses to a survey on Japanese website, MyNavi Woman, conducted from Nov 16 to Nov 23 last year. Here are the top 10 picks:

1st place: "Hana Yori Dango" (drama & movie) Original author: Yoko Kamio; Publisher: Shueisha

2nd place: "Nodame Cantabile" (drama & movies) Original author: Tomoko Ninomiya; Publisher: Kodansha

3rd place: "Death Note" (movies) Original author: Tsugumi Ohba; Original illustrator: Takeshi Obata; Publisher: Shueisha

4th place (tie): "Kimi ni Todoke" (movie) Original author: Karuho Shiina; Publisher: Shueisha

4th place (tie): "Rurouni Kenshin" (movie) Original author: Nobuhiro Watsuki; Publisher: Shueisha

6th place (tie): "20th Century Boys" (movie) Original author: Naoki Urasawa; Publisher: Shogakukan

6th place (tie): "NANA" (movie) Original author: Ai Yazawa; Publisher: Shueisha

8th place (tie): "Ping Pong" (movie) Original author: Taiyo Matsumoto; Publisher: Shogakukan

8th (tie): "Thermae Romae" (movie) Original author: Mari Yamazaki; Publisher: Enterbrain

8th (tie): "Kindaichi Case Files" (dramas & movie) Original authors: Yozaburo Kanari & Seimaru Amagi; Original illustrator: Fumiya Sato; Publisher: Kodansha

Let’s take a closer look at some of the comments for the top picks.

1st place: "Hana Yori Dango"

-- “The F4 members were all well-suited for their roles. Tsukushi-chan was also portrayed perfectly!” (29-year-old, female)

-- “The cast and soundtracks in the dramas and movie were great, and I was drawn in as much as in the original manga!” (29-year-old, female)

-- “It was cool to see the wealthy world of the F4 transformed into real life.” (27-year-old, female)

Almost all of the comments praised the superb casting. The real-life F4 beautiful boys all had to overcome the tough hurdle of living up to the fans’ expectations, after all. Also, theme songs like Arashi’s “Love so Sweet” and Ai Otsuka’s “Planetarium” contributed to the popularity.

"Hana Yori Dango" is such a loved story that it has already been adapted into live-action dramas in three different countries, with a fourth American version confirmed! It’s fun to check out the differences between the Japanese, Korean, and Taiwanese versions.

2nd place: "Nodame Cantabile"

-- “A big reason why I liked this drama was because I could actually hear the classical music played in the original manga. The casting was also great.” (23-year-old, female)

-- “Juri Ueno really captured the character of Megumi Noda. I think the drama successfully expanded on the world of the manga!” (25-year-old, female)

-- “It was a great choice for Hiroshi Tamaki to star as Shinichi Chiaki.” (34-year-old,female)

Many voiced their excitement about hearing the compositions that music university students performed in the manga in the drama as well. There were also many comments about Juri Ueno’s talent at playing the messy but loveable Megumi Noda. And looking back at it, casting was amazing for Masumi Okuyama (the afro guy with a maiden’s heart), played by Keisuke Koide.

3rd place: "Death Note"

-- “I loved the depiction of Light Yagami/Kira by Tatsuya Fujiwara. His shouting was impressive.” (23-year-old, male)

-- “Kenichi Matsuyama played the part of L perfectly.” (24-year-old, male)

The casting for main characters Kira and L were great. Some participants also commented positively about the movie’s different conclusion from the original manga.

4th place (tie): "Kimi ni Todoke"

-- “Mikako Tabe starring as Sawako and Haruma Miura as Kazehaya were perfect for their roles. I was even more moved by the movie than by the manga!” (27-year-old, female)

-- “My first reaction was, ‘Mikako Tabe’s going to play Sawako?! But she did a really great job.’” (24-year-old, female)

Great acting was acknowledged here, too. The actresses of Sawako’s friends, Natsuna Watanabe and Misako Renbutsu, also proved popular with participants.

4th place (tie): "Rurouni Kenshin"

-- “Takeru Satoh’s performance as Kenshin Himura was consistent with the atmosphere of the original.” (21-year-old, female)

-- “I got a better opinion of Takeru Satoh.” (28-year-old, male)

Many people agreed with the choice of Takeru Sato as Kenshin. Even though the original manga featured many amazing battle scenes, the live-action film’s action scenes were not unrealistic.

Author’s note: I was a bit disappointed that my two favorite Japanese dramas of all time didn’t make the top ten. First, I have watched 1998′s inspirational "Great Teacher Onizuka" [GTO], adapted from Tohru Fujisawa’s eponymous manga, countless times. Takashi Sorimachi really nailed the role of tough-guy but aspiring teacher Onizuka. And isn’t it adorable that he and co-star/on-screen love interest Nanako Matsushima ended up getting married in real life? Last year’s drama remake starring EXILE’s Akira was also entertaining, but the original live-action version will forever be my favorite.

Second, 2007′s live-action drama of Hisaya Nakajo’s manga "Hanazakari no Kimitachi e" never fails to make me laugh. The quirky characters (especially Toma Ikuta doing Nakatsu’s hilarious internal dialogues), gender-bending trials of girl-secretly-disguised-as-boy Mizuki, and music combine to make a light atmosphere with occasional touching moments.

I have also enjoyed "Gokusen," "Kimi wa Petto," and numerous others. It’s a pleasant feeling to see a beloved manga reproduced in live-action so faithfully.

Sources: My Game News Flash, Mynavi Woman

Read more stories from RocketNews24. -- 16 films based on popular manga series hitting Japanese cinemas in 2014 -- New live-action Sailor Moon stage musical cast revealed -- American casting for Hana Yori Dango TV series receives harsh Japanese criticism

© RocketNews24

©2019 GPlusMedia Inc.

15 Comments
Login to comment

Cutie honey not in the top 10? Bummer.

3 ( +3 / -0 )

I wonder how the US version of Hana Yori Dango will pull off the scene where Tsukushi is almost mugged in NYC. I'm also not convinced that US actors will be able to convey the same emotional maturity of Matsumoto Jun and Inoue Mao.

-3 ( +1 / -4 )

Todd, that's exactly what I was thinking. Hedeki Anno perfectly captured the feeling of anime as a live action in his adaptation. 20th Century Boys is also very good as a film, but really, most modern Japanese cinema comes off as TV movie-of-the-week amature hour. Bad acting coupled with a "we filmed this on DV"... yuck.

Cutie Honey, though... I don't believe anyone could actually top it as a faithful adaptation.

0 ( +0 / -0 )

It's too bad the 1974 Lupin III adaptation has been all but forgotten, even here in Japan. It's a lot of fun.

3 ( +3 / -0 )

Shinhiyata.

Another one is in the making. Also no mention of BlackJack, etc. Lots of life-action adaptations coming up this year, looking forward to Patlabor as the trailer rocks.

-1 ( +0 / -1 )

sorry. How can their be a top ten when their isnt even ONE decent one.

-7 ( +1 / -8 )

death note and nana are unwatchable. the first destroys the manga and the character, the second's casting looks like it was done by someone high on psychedelic drugs.

-3 ( +0 / -3 )

I thought "Uchuu Senkan Yamato" was a beautifully made film, same with the "Always Sunset on Third Street" series of films. I also enjoy the "Death Note" films, which are wonderfully quirky. I'm really looking forward to the "Patlabor" film... it might lead to a decent "Gundam" or "Macross" film.

0 ( +0 / -0 )

Agreed with Death Note, and Kenshin, but I did miss Yamato and what about Itazura na kiss?. I haven't seen Hana Yori Dango, but I do love the story and the Korean adaptation was a success in my country...

0 ( +0 / -0 )

Let me know when there is a live action Hellsing.

0 ( +1 / -1 )

I can see you don't read manga XDDDD

-1 ( +0 / -1 )

I am not expert of this matter, but I think most of the top live action adoptions come from the US ;-|

0 ( +0 / -0 )

No "Tokyo Love Story"?

1 ( +1 / -0 )

So many to choose from, must have been hard finding someone who has seen them all so they could choose the top 10. Gantz, The Guyver, Old Boy (loosely based), Blood: The Last Vampire.

0 ( +0 / -0 )

Agree with the top choice, based simply on the fact that so many countries have made their own versions (I believe Taiwan was the first, before Japan, though it is of course a Japanese comic). I saw the Korean version and it was not as good, though less mellow-dramatic at times. I also think NANA deserves to be up there, as does 20th Century Boy (although in actuality the ending of the first movie and the sequels were horrible). I really don't know how Death Note got up there, unless it was simply sales; the movie was gawd-awful and the CJ absolutely ridiculous. The rest I don't know.... I think.

-1 ( +0 / -1 )

Login to leave a comment

Facebook users

Use your Facebook account to login or register with JapanToday. By doing so, you will also receive an email inviting you to receive our news alerts.

Facebook Connect

Login with your JapanToday account

User registration

Articles, Offers & Useful Resources

A mix of what's trending on our other sites