The requested article has expired, and is no longer available. Any related articles, and user comments are shown below.
© (c) Copyright Thomson Reuters 2020.Led Zeppelin wins 'Stairway to Heaven' copyright case
By Jonathan Stempel SAN FRANCISCO©2024 GPlusMedia Inc.
18 Comments
Login to comment
BakabonPapa
It's a fine line between influence and copying. Both bands were great, anyway.
Mr Kipling
Listen to both songs.... I think the judge called this one wrong.
commanteer
The judge was right. Spirit was by far one of the most creative bands of the era, sadly forgotten. But Taurus was not even a song, just a common chord progression. It's like Randy California had an idea for a song but put it on the record without finishing it. Jimmy Page took a similar progression but built a masterpiece on top of it. Pop and fold music has always been building on the work of others, and flourished until the lawyers got involved. Musicians use to openly acknowledge this. But in this case, it's not even that. This is like someone claiming Beethoven's 5th was stolen because another composer wrote a tavern song with the same 4 notes. Worth noting that Randy California, the guy who actually wrote Taurus, never pursued legal action while he was alive, though he was fully aware of the similarities.
commanteer
Arrgg... "pop and folk" music.
Jimizo
Clapton’s ‘Let it Grow’ sounds similar to ‘Stairway to Heaven/Taurus”.
As Commanteer posted, it is a common chord progression.
commanteer
Agreed. He is one of the very few rock stars that didn't just rest on his laurels raking in money repeating the same formula. A true musician.
Wakarimasen
I think all these "they stole my song" lawsuits are ludicrous. So much music builds on what went before. and the success of a song is not just down to what is on the page. it is image and presentation and a whole raft of other things.
browny1
Lots of circumstantial evidence -
Spirit toured with LZep in USA.
Robert Plant had a copy of Spirit's debut album ( a big hit) with Taurus on.
2 important video commentaries by TJR worth listening to.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PCEg9gMJakU
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DgIL8yBWE_w
commanteer
I agree. These laws are basically killing music and culture. The exact opposite of what copyright laws were originally supposed to do.
plasticmonkey
Funky Town is a ripoff of Sunshine of Your Love.
Owner of a Lonely Heart is a ripoff of Dance of the Sugar Plum Fairies.
Blattamexiguus
Both are clearly influenced by Giovanni Battista's Sonatta di Chittarra, e violinio, con
kohakuebisu
This is kind of ironic because Zeppelin clearly ripped off loads of bluesmen, the Small Faces, and the Dazed and Confused guy, not even giving them writing credits for big chunks of lyrics, but this Stairway to Heaven claim is really tame and should not have made it to court. There is a similar Davy Graham riff that predates Taurus anyway.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tWeejHJxGjs
Blattamexiguus
...il suo basso continuo.
Baroque is pop and rock.
Toasted Heretic
Nice to see fans of both Zep and Spirit.
To be fair, "borrowing" from other artists has been going on since a human first picked up an instrument.
Call it sampling, inspiration, hommage, call it what you will but it's a constant in music. Even the great composers were known to be inspired (and parodied) by other great composers.