Here
and
Now

kuchikomi

Internet buzzes with sympathy, support, understanding for Abe's accused killer

17 Comments
By Michael Hoffman

Spa (Aug 30 – Sept 6) begins with a disclaimer: “There is no justification for Yamagami’s heinous crime – but,” it adds,  “as details of the suspect’s past emerge, an outpouring of sympathy” has overwhelmed revulsion.

Misfortune dogged Tetsuya Yamagami. Born in 1980, he came of age as the bubble economy burst, condemning him and so many others of his generation to a life of poorly-paid, insecure menial labor.

He was four when his father committed suicide. That same year his elder brother lost an eye while in treatment for cancer.

Perhaps it was despair that drew his mother to the Unification Church in 1991. Formally known as the Family Federation for World Peace and Unification, it was founded in South Korea in 1954 and preaches a mystic salvationist messianic fringe Christianity that may well appeal to people at the end of their tether. Upon joining, Yamagami’s mother turned over to the church the 60 million yen she’d received from her late husband’s life insurance policy.

Subsequent donations seem to have drained the family’s once ample resources, dragging it into deep poverty. Yamagami’s hatred of the church, sown in childhood, festered as he matured. A promising student with no money for college, he thought of being a firefighter instead, only to be disqualified by short sight. What next? A stint in the Maritime Self-Defense Forces. In 2005, age 25, he attempted suicide. Discharged from the MSDF, he qualified as a surveyor but nothing came of it. He drifted from job to job. In 2013 his brother killed himself.

On July 8, he was arrested as a suspect in the murder of former Prime Minister Shinzo Abe. Abe, he alleged, had political ties with the Unification Church.

A “dark hero,” novelist Akira Tachibana calls him, writing in Spa. Very dark indeed. And yet the internet grapevine buzzes with sympathy, support, understanding and similar tales of the extremes of misery that push many to the very brink of crime, and some past it – a few very far past it.

Yamagami, as Spa notes, seems the victim of just about every social ill there is. There are many. His strongest sympathizers see themselves as fellow victims – of “poison parents;” of religious enthusiasms that deplete family fortunes and leave children of believers penniless; most numerously, of the hiring freeze of the 1990s that spawned a “lost generation” of economic ghosts unable to latch onto anything solid or stable.

“My father became a believer (in New Age Christianity) and quit his job in the civil service,” wrote a man in his 30s in one of various net posts Spa collects. “We had no money. I  grew up watching my mother weep helplessly as we sank deeper and deeper into debt.” Counseling, he says, helped him control his rage as he grew older. “I didn’t commit a crime, but if I’d been Yamagami, the need for vengeance might have been too much for me.”

What might he have done? There’s no telling. In 1997 two children were murdered in Kobe. One, a 10-year-old boy, had been beheaded with a chainsaw. An early morning jogger found the head on a sidewalk. In its mouth was a scrawled note that read, “This is the beginning of the game.” The player turned out to be a 14-year-old boy. “A bloody judgment is needed for my years of great bitterness,” he wrote. He signed his name “Seito Sakakibara.”

The source of his bitterness is obscure. Not so that of Tomohiro Kato, executed in July, age 39, for the 2008  “Akihabara Massacre” – seven killed, 10 seriously wounded, the rampage an apparent eruption of rage and frustration over years of social isolation and half-life in the part-time economy.

Kato, “Seito” and Yamagami have points in common – notably keen intelligence thwarted or warped, and birth in the early 1980s. Statistically, Spa observes, their generation is no more crime-prone than any other – but the rage that knows no bounds does seem a distinguishing feature.  

The men and women whose online postings Spa passes on are all in their 30s and 40s. They express the agony and anger that seethes beneath the placid surface of everyday life in a modern and wealthy country.

“After graduating I applied to over 50 companies,” wrote a woman in her 40s. “Nothing – I heard back from none of them. Finally I found a job –  with a ‘black company,’ take-home pay 150,000 a month. I quit after a few years and went on to day jobs and part-time jobs, constantly struggling to make ends meet. I’m married now, and things are at least stable, if not prosperous. But Yamagami had to struggle alone. It seems to me that the political establishment that abandons people like him, and the society that is indifferent to them – don’t they deserve some of the blame?”

A woman in her 30s wrote: “My family was poor. I started working part-time at 16. Every month my father would snatch my pay and gamble it away. I hated him so much I wanted to kill him. With my family it was gambling, with Yamagami’s it was religion. It’s not the same, but the more we learn about Yamagami’s home environment, the more sympathy I feel for him.”

Like Kato before him, Yamagami posted his angst copiously online. Kato wrote of being friendless and “ugly;” Yamagami of blaming himself for his father’s death. Kato is said to have written (anonymously), “If I only had a girlfriend, I wouldn’t have quit work,” and “I’m lower than trash because at least trash gets recycled.” And Yamagami: “I was four when my father on his hospital bed appealed to me for help and I refused to please my mother. That’s why my father jumped off the hospital roof. I killed my father.”

That’s a heavy burden for a 4-year-old to bear. “Communication strategist” Junko Okamoto, writing in Spa, identifies five “isolations,” and says Yamagami suffered them all –  loveless childhood, poverty unrelieved by the social safety net, the hiring freeze that blighted the “lost generation,” and the final two, which more or less merge: the isolation of being a man and the isolation of being Japanese. A Japanese man in trouble, Okamoto says, is supposed to be tough and self-reliant; to swallow his pain and solve his own problems.

One calls for help and no one answers. Perhaps the call is not heard, perhaps heard but not understood, perhaps heard and understood but disdained. There is a breaking point. Few reach it. Some do. Weakness becomes power, and there’s hell to pay.

Michael Hoffman is the author of “Cipangu, Golden Cipangu.”

© Japan Today

©2022 GPlusMedia Inc.

17 Comments
Login to comment

Sure, the various murderers mentioned in the article had sad, stressful lives. That still doesn't excuse their horrendous acts of murder.

0 ( +5 / -5 )

A very good essay, Michael. This is all about unbearable psychological (and political) pain and how society's victims stoically go off the deep end. Japan is not what many assume to be the fantastic land of Wa.

8 ( +10 / -2 )

Seriously? We are expected to show this 'man' sympathy because he's had a tough life and then allow that sympathy to excuse him murdering another human being? This could be very useful if true, I too have had a pretty difficult life, will I be entitled to the same consideration should I kill a public figure? Is everyone who has been dealt a poor hand in life going to be shown the same consideration...?

Yamagami is a cold, calculating murderer guilty of the predetermined assassination of another person. That the person in question was as high profile an individual as Abe is largely irrelevant. Murder is murder is murder and there can be NO justification for it and certainly no excusing it.

0 ( +7 / -7 )

I can have sympathy for Yamagami’s suffering but not the taking of another life.

1 ( +6 / -5 )

Perhaps the chap has a severe mental illness, we don’t know until the evidence is provided. What is for sure, is that the Moonies and many others like them are scam artists who rob naive people and leave them and their families in terrible situations.

0 ( +7 / -7 )

His actions have had a positive result. The evil cult and their links to leading politicians has been brought to the public attention. This link will be cut if the LDP is to be believed.

8 ( +10 / -2 )

Parents who are compos mentis have the right to do what they wish with their loot. Go on a cruise, blow it all on coke and hookers on a massive bender in Vegas or donate it to a home for elderly felines. If you want them to save it for you, you may need to convince them, and be lucky. Whilst they are alive, it is their cash, not yours.

As all religious groups, big, small, mainstream and fringe, are in the manipulation game, offering uncertifiable intangibles like a happy ever afterlife, governments might pass legislation banning such organisations from taking more than the traditional tithe (10%) from marks, er, worshippers. So no more than 10% of their annual net earnings and no more than 10% of their total assets can be passed across to any belief-based entity. Beyond that level, it would be a crime to ask for it or accept it, directly or indirectly. This would protect the vulnerable from being shaken down for all of their cash.

-2 ( +3 / -5 )

Religious Freedom stated in the Constitution allows any citizen to practice or join any religion or religious group they want to. Cannot be prevented without a change to the constitution which has never happened.

-2 ( +2 / -4 )

@GBR48:

"Parents who are compos mentis have the right to do what they wish with their loot. Go on a cruise, blow it all on coke and hookers on a massive bender in Vegas or donate it to a home for elderly felines. 

You are talking of a legal right; there is certainly no moral right to behave that way, and moral rights and duties are far more important than legal ones.

-2 ( +1 / -3 )

No, there’s no reason for sympathy, support or understanding. We all had, have or will have a bigger problem caused by others one day or longer, sooner or later, no one has a whole life with only happiness and never any problems, and if then in all those cases everyone develops into a killer and kills the persons he thinks who could be responsible, (which in this case not even was the case, when that sect is correctly identified and considered as bad but instead exPM Abe was killed), then that planet would be empty very quickly. In fact it would already have completely emptied for thousands of years.

-2 ( +2 / -4 )

Yeah, sad that the guy had to go through life like that, but that has nothing to do with what he has done and these are two entirely different subjects. He went with the intent to kill Abe, it wasn't an accident and there is no excuse, so he is definitely in the right place and he has no business being and walking around us. Let's hope through the years he will take the time and contemplate his actions and whether they were justified or worth it.

-4 ( +1 / -5 )

Does the end justify the means?

0 ( +3 / -3 )

the bum wasted his life doing nothing, banking on an expected windfall inheritance which the unification church scammed from his mother first.

There are no participants here who deserve sympathy. Certainly not the psychotic murderer.

But similar sociopaths will sympathize for one reason or another.

-4 ( +4 / -8 )

Yes yes blah blah blah a sad story indeed and the unification church is aweful

However it still doesn't justify committing murder of Abe.

I wasn't very fond of Abe and his way of doing things but killing him wasn't the only way to bring the unification church under scrutiny or the only way for the killer to deal with his issues.

-2 ( +4 / -6 )

Awa no Gaijin...

I wasn't very fond of Abe and his way of doing things but killing him wasn't the only way to bring the unification church under scrutiny or the only way for the killer to deal with his issues.

Sorry to disagree but the only reason the Unification Church, its shady practices and links to politicians has come to light is because he killed Abe. If you remember, it took the media almost a week to slowly leak out the reason for the killing. The LDP and its support media were going full out to keep it under wraps.

6 ( +6 / -0 )

If the Unification Church caused him so much pain, he could have attacked them rather than Mr. Abe, and the resulting news would have generated the same level of news attention.

The cults have brought nothing but pain to many people because they do not have the right answers to people's problems, and in fact cause additional ones.

0 ( +1 / -1 )

Yamagami was put to the edge, he had nothing to lose because no one listened, heard, understood and accepted his real suffering and s... happened.

He is referred to as 無敵の人 here in Japan. 

An "invincible person".

1 ( +1 / -0 )

Login to leave a comment

Facebook users

Use your Facebook account to login or register with JapanToday. By doing so, you will also receive an email inviting you to receive our news alerts.

Facebook Connect

Login with your JapanToday account

User registration

Articles, Offers & Useful Resources

A mix of what's trending on our other sites