Photo: pixabay.com
lifestyle

The lie of the land: How topography made Tokyo the city it is today

10 Comments
By George Lloyd, grape Japan

You might not think so looking out over Tokyo from one of its giant skyscrapers, but the modern city owes its chaotic appearance to the layout of old Edo, which was in turn based on height differences in the natural landscape.

Tokyo sprawls across the Musashino Plain and the lower coastal plain on the west side of Tokyo Bay. The eastern part of the plain is called Yamanote (the highlands) and is 10-20 meters higher than the strip of land that runs along the coast.

West of Shinjuku, the plain is pretty flat, but as you head east towards Tokyo Bay, meandering rivers - the Shakujii, Shibuya and Meguro River - start cutting channels into the plain. Aside from the rivers, there are also lots of brooks and streams that bubble up from springs on the plain. These springs create basins, which are usually surrounded by hills on three sides.

C5120B0F-97F3-4DEA-808B-AB9DD2D3F413-e1605616730313.jpg
Photo: 1500年前の古墳, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

The higgledy-piggledy topography of the eastern edge of the Musashino Plain explains why there are so many hills and gullies in central Tokyo. It comes to an end at a ridge, which runs from Yanaka in the north to Shinagawa in the south. East of the ridge, the land is flat as far as the bay.

In the Edo period, the feudal lords and samurai built their homes on the higher ground and had gardens laid out on the slopes around their properties. The peasants lived in the low-lying basins and on the coastal plain, amid the fields and rice paddies where they worked. As the settlement around Edo castle grew, these low-lying areas became residential neighborhoods for commoners and townspeople. The low ground east of the castle became known as shitamachi 下町 – downtown.

Because the basins to the west of the castle were often surrounded on three sides by cliffs, it was hard to move between the high ground and the low ground. This suited the feudal lords and samurai well, for it allowed them to keep the lower ranks out of sight and out of mind. They built few streets connecting their neighborhoods with the low ground, which is why you see so many flights of stone steps in the centre of the city.

In the Edo period, cemeteries tended to be on the valley floor, which only reinforced the impression that these stone stairs connected the divine world of the uplands to the worldlier realm of shitamachi.

E26311F4-E741-4035-AD50-702B7DA67937_1_201_a.jpg
This cemetery in Roppongi was built on low ground surrounded by hills, where the samurai had their homes. Photo: Peter Kaminski / © Flickr.com CC by SA 2.0

To ensure a tight grip on the commoner population, the samurai built high wooden gates to separate one neighborhood from another. These gates were locked at night. Shitamachi neighborhoods were at risk of flooding, and because the houses were made of wood and closely packed together, they were also prone to fire.

You might think that strict control, close proximity and ever-present danger would lead people to turn on one another. But in Edo, they had the opposite effect, binding the residents of each neighborhood into remarkably coherent and effective social organizations.

When the feudal era came to an end in 1868, the new Meiji government confiscated the feudal lords’ estates and repurposed them as government institutions, parks, hotels and embassies. Over the course of the next hundred years, other large institutions and corporations, which also needed big plots, bought up the land that used to belong to the samurai on the higher ground.

6EBD861A-3C2F-4F4C-9C25-C26F9BBFD8F8_1_201_a.jpg
The neighborhoods of central Tokyo are characterised by staircases that connect poorer low-lying neighborhoods with wealthier "highland" neighborhoods. | Photo: Hisagi, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

The division between highland and lowland, uptown and downtown, rich and poor can still be seen in the layout of modern-day Tokyo. Look down into one of the basins of central Tokyo, and you’ll see that the plots tend to be smaller than those you find on the higher ground.

That’s because, having been subdivided countless times, property developers found it hard to consolidate these little plots into larger plots. So they built few large buildings on the lower ground and instead turned their attention to the higher ground.

As a result, neighborhoods on higher ground tend to be more spacious, more commercial and wealthier, while most of central Tokyo’s machiya 町屋 – the small townhouses that make up most residential neighborhoods – are either in basins or further east in shitamachi.

The layout of old Edo has also determined the layout of the city’s biggest streets, which tend to follow the ridges between valleys. These roads are often lined with tall buildings, which form a kind of shell around the low-lying, cozier neighborhood inside.

This is called the ‘egg and shell’ pattern. Low-rise residential areas – the eggs – are surrounded by a shell of high-rise office buildings that face the larger streets that run around the border of the neighborhood. Thanks to these protective ‘shells’, Tokyo remains, despite its gargantuan size, a city of pedestrians, bicycles and surprisingly quiet residential neighborhoods.

It’s not always easy to see traces of old Edo in modern Tokyo. After the disaster of the Great Kanto Earthquake of 1923, and the firebombing of Tokyo at the end of World War Two, wholesale changes were made. The many small waterways that used to run through the low city were filled in with the rubble of the ruined city and many of the basins and gullies in the centre of the city were leveled to make way for bigger neighborhoods. Yet, in spite of these dramatic changes to the layout of central Tokyo, the essential character of its neighborhoods remains remarkably unchanged from the Edo period.

Read more stories from grape Japan.

-- Saunachelin 2020 ranks Japan’s best sauna facilities and best sauna lifestyle promoters

-- A Guide to Japanese Banks for foreigners living in Japan

-- Shiretoko World Heritage site staff chide litterbugs after an increase in discarded waste

© grape Japan

©2020 GPlusMedia Inc.

10 Comments
Login to comment

Its nice to read something positive about Tokyo for a change.

0 ( +0 / -0 )

It's 'Lay of the land', not 'lie of the land'.

There is apparently a US-UK difference on this one. (Wars have been fought over less. Be careful.)

1 ( +1 / -0 )

Ley lines flaky or fact?

0 ( +0 / -0 )

It's 'Lay of the land', not 'lie of the land'.

why

0 ( +0 / -0 )

Tokyo lay lines play a part too.

1 ( +1 / -0 )

It's 'Lay of the land', not 'lie of the land'.

1 ( +1 / -0 )

Tokyo was also built as a castle town, which means that it's layout was like a labyrinth, so that an attacking enemy got lost during his attempt to get to the central castle.

2 ( +2 / -0 )

This history is laid out in the book "Low City, High City" by Edward Seidensticker

5 ( +5 / -0 )

Agreed. For me it’s probably more about the history that these articles bring out.

5 ( +5 / -0 )

Articles on how topography shapes and defines cities is always interesting.

9 ( +9 / -0 )

Login to leave a comment

Facebook users

Use your Facebook account to login or register with JapanToday. By doing so, you will also receive an email inviting you to receive our news alerts.

Facebook Connect

Login with your JapanToday account

User registration

Articles, Offers & Useful Resources

A mix of what's trending on our other sites