Here
and
Now

opinions

In Syria, the joke's on Washington

12 Comments

When Russia began its military campaign in Syria, the Obama administration and its allies quickly claimed it was a disaster in the making. Director of National Intelligence James Clapper called Russian President Vladimir Putin "impulsive" and said he was "winging it" in Syria with no long-term strategy. Former United States Ambassador to Russia Michael McFaul ridiculed Putin's "supposed strategic genius," arguing the Russian leader "cannot restore Assad's authority over the whole country." Even President Barack Obama joined the chorus, publicly warning Putin that he risked an Afghanistan-style Russian "quagmire" in Syria.

It turns out, though, that the joke's on Washington: Thanks to shrewd tactics plus tailwinds from the Paris attacks, Syria is turning into a major strategic victory for Putin. Here's what he's accomplished and how he did it.

For starters, as Putin explained in both 2013 and during his recent United Nations speech, what he fears most is power vacuums filled by extremists. As Putin stated early in Russia's bombing campaign, Russia did not plan major ground operations, since its goal was simply "to stabilize the legitimate government" to prevent its immediate overthrow. For this reason, as director of the Carnegie Moscow Center Dimitri Trenin argues, Putin never meant to help Bashar al-Assad achieve complete military victory, but rather to stave off Syria's collapse.

Putin has already met this first objective. The Assad regime is no longer in imminent danger, and with Russian air support it has actually re-taken key areas in central Syria and Aleppo. As a result, the regime's key territory in its Alawite heartland no longer faces the risk of being overrun.

Putin's second achievement has been to expand Russian military and political influence throughout the Middle East. Russia established a number of bases in the west of Syria while also expanding its naval base at Tartus - Moscow's only permanent naval presence outside Russia and a key refueling depot for Russia's Black Sea Fleet. Putin can now project Russian military strength throughout the Levant and eastern Mediterranean.

Putin has also succeeded in making himself indispensable to each of the three major power centers in the Middle East. In a move that caught the United States off-guard, Putin established a de facto alliance with the leading Shi'ite powers in the region, including Iran, Iraq, Hezbollah and Syria. The five powers set up joint operation centers in Baghdad and Damascus to share intelligence and coordinate military actions. Iraq also surprised Washington when it allowed Russian planes to transport military gear through its airspace on the way to Syria after NATO member Bulgaria refused Russia entrance to its airspace. On the frontlines, Russia provides aerial cover while the Shi'ite powers focus on the ground war, and the alliance has advanced to the point where Russia even transports Iraqi Shi'ite militias to the fighting in Syria.

Perhaps counterintuitively, Russia's decision to align itself with the Middle East's Shi'ite powers has actually increased Moscow's influence with the Sunnis and Israelis. A number of key figures from the Sunni states recently visited Moscow, and the most powerful man in the Sunni world - Saudi King Salman bin Abdulaziz Al Saud - will likely make the pilgrimage to the Kremlin soon to discuss a solution to the Syrian war.

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu quickly read the tea leaves, too. Alarmed by Russia's burgeoning alliance with its archenemies Iran and Hezbollah, Netanyahu immediately hopped on a plane to Moscow to meet Putin. Netanyahu's immediate concern was to ask Putin to respect Israel's "red lines" on the transfer of advanced arms to Hezbollah - a request to which Putin agreed. While Netanyahu appeared reassured in Moscow, a leading Israeli commentator described Netanyahu's visit as signaling the start of a "post-American Middle East."

Putin has also broken through the ring of diplomatic isolation imposed on him by the West after Russia's annexation of Crimea. A comparison between last year's G20 summit in Australia and this year's event in Turkey shows the magnitude of the change. Putin was practically persona non grata in Australia, and with Western leaders browbeating him about Ukraine, Putin fled the conference early to - as he put it - get some extra sleep. In Turkey, by contrast, Putin was on every Western leader's "must-see" list, and photos of Putin huddling over coffee with Obama became the defining images of the event.

While the Paris attacks are the proximate cause of this Western interest, Russia's military commitment in Syria positioned it to take advantage of the West's newfound focus on confronting Islamic State. France and Russia already coordinated joint strikes against Islamic State positions in Raqqa, and after speaking with French President François Hollande, Putin ordered the Russian Navy to make contact with the French aircraft carrier Charles de Gaulle heading toward the Persian Gulf, while also suggesting that the French and Russian navies develop joint sea and air strategies.

On the diplomatic front, after long demanding that "Assad must go," Obama now appears willing to compromise. Diplomatic meetings in Vienna between the United States, Russia and other nations produced an agreement on an 18-month plan to establish a new Syrian government based on democratic elections. The parties also agreed to develop a master list of all terrorist groups in Syria - a step Putin had long demanded.

Obama then dropped his generally hostile line towards Putin, praising him as a "constructive partner" in efforts to resolve the Syrian war. Obama even hinted at the possibility of direct American-Russian military coordination in Syria - a step previously rejected by the United States - stating that "more opportunities for coordination" had arisen.

Finally, cooperation in Syria may lead to Putin's ultimate geopolitical goal: an end to the European Union's Ukraine-related sanctions against Russia. The head of the French Senate just demanded an end to sanctions, echoing a number of EU leaders - including Greece and Slovenia - who had called for this previously.

We should not forget the Russian-Western rapprochement remains brand new. Existing Western rifts with Russia may still return to the fore if the two sides diverge on Syria or if the European Union extends sanctions against Russia in December - something which is still on course to occur.

In the short term, though, Putin's bold move into Syria has flipped the world's geopolitical script.

© (c) Copyright Thomson Reuters 2015.

©2022 GPlusMedia Inc.

12 Comments
Login to comment

Finally, cooperation in Syria may lead to Putin’s ultimate geopolitical goal: an end to the European Union’s Ukraine-related sanctions against Russia.

Mr. Cohen presents a reward for Putin's crimes in the Crimea is somehow a unification of the Middle East under the protection of the Russian Bear. Putin's game isn't yet played to conclusion, but Mr. Cohen makes out a coordinated international resolve was beyond the reach of the West Putin would have no part of.

Thanks Mr. Cohen. The Ukrainians are cheering your premonitions of peace and the world welcomes the crystal ball certainty of the beneficence of Vlad's gambit.

From another perspective, Mr. Cohen is cheering a Putin Europe Pan Middle East and the Ascension of a Communist domination from Brittany to Beijing. As long as Putin's Chinese masters agree.

Seen here, Mr. Cohen presents a tout compte fait without proof at the cost of Ukrainian submission to Russian expansionism, unverifiable Syrian poison gas stores and ethnic cleansing to "secure the peace".

Clearly the pile of assumptions and costs are so thinly examined Mr. Cohen might consider an application to the politburo marketing department of Communism.

As long as ISIS can continue their campaign of burying children alive Mr. Putin is the hero of the Middle East. If ISIS is stopped then the costs of that victory will be a steady stream of despotism for the fertile crescent. What war has Putin then won? A war where Russia dictates to Europe?

Thanks Mr. Cohen. A more garbled certainty can only be found in the rationale that makes the West guard dog and servant of Mr. Putin's Communism. Maybe that is a victory. A victory made possible the bungling of the GOP Shia-Tea and AWOL Bush who set the plan in motion and cleared the path for a Russian victory.

-3 ( +3 / -6 )

Can we stop removing dictators, please? Clearly it's better to have a strong dictator than a power vacuum and ISIS. We should have learned this in Yugoslavia.

3 ( +6 / -3 )

Putin is a "man among men" who worked his way up through the KGB, eventually making it to the top. He has twisted arms (or broken them) to get things done his way. He is not afraid to say or do anything which he thinks is in his or Russia's interest, and no cost is to heavy to pay.

Obama is a "community organizer among academics", a person who has never had to compete for anything, who has never even held a real job. Having never been a leader of any type before becoming president (god help us), he had never had to make tough decisions, and to see the results or consequences of such decisions.

Putin is a major league player, Obama can't even throw a baseball from the pitcher's mound over home plate. For all these reasons it is no surprise that Putin has gotten his way in every situation he has gotten into, and why Russia's influence is expanding, and America's is waning.

3 ( +7 / -4 )

kcjapan

I concur

-2 ( +3 / -5 )

Mr. Cohen presents a reward for Putin's crimes in the Crimea... @kcjapan

I'm not sure whether to laugh at this or cry for a drink of your Kool-Aid...

-1 ( +4 / -5 )

@kcjapan

rationale that makes the West guard dog and servant of Mr. Putin's Communism

Wow, somebody still bravely fighting evil Commies! Your name is not McCain?

-1 ( +3 / -4 )

Always interesting to read the fans of Putin's occupation of Ukraine, supply of poison gas to Assad (used on his own citizens) and Europe's potential cowering before Russian control of essential oil supplies.

Strange heroes for strange minds. Ignoring Putin's version of Communism is obviously easier than acknowledging the dictatorial basis of his power. Nice to read the admiration some here profess for Putin's tactics and expansionism at gun point. (and their longing for a Putin dictatorship)

That's no joke. It's dangerous. Maybe the joke is on Europe? Mr. Cohen obviously thinks little of Americans and less of Europeans.

-1 ( +3 / -4 )

Hey, your hero is Assad and Putin?

If you think the Syrian stock piles of Russian VX, Sarin, and Mustard Gas are an imaginary threat? That pretty much tells all anyone need know of your opinions.

But, it's not about opinion is it? Mr. Cohen thinks it's all a big joke. Maybe you do too.

Unsurprising confirmation of the political motivations behind these commentaries.

Mr. Cohen should be ashamed of himself, for others, that's not possible. They toy with too little mental firepower and too much prejudice.

Mr. Cohen thinks the deaths of hundreds, thousands, of innocent men, women and children is a joke.

Some commenters here think the same. Thanks for the confirmation on the grotesque motives behind these opinions. Maybe laughing at thousands of dead innocents is funny to Mr. Cohen and the Putin hero worshipers here.

Europe isn't laughing and the mindset that thinks dead children buried alive are a joke pretty much speaks for itself. Rage on hero worshipers. You have much to celebrate with your soulmates in ISIS.

-1 ( +2 / -3 )

kcjapan,

You are spot on

-1 ( +2 / -3 )

Jack, there's nothing more disgusting than reducing the deaths of innocent children to Mr. Cohen's "joke". Except maybe the comments that praise the theology of reduction. Bloody sickening.

-2 ( +1 / -3 )

Login to leave a comment

Facebook users

Use your Facebook account to login or register with JapanToday. By doing so, you will also receive an email inviting you to receive our news alerts.

Facebook Connect

Login with your JapanToday account

User registration

Articles, Offers & Useful Resources

A mix of what's trending on our other sites