Judicial reforms on the horizon causing much anxiety

By David T Johnson

In May 2009, Japan will introduce a new trial system in which six lay persons will sit with three professional judges to determine guilt and sentence in serious criminal cases. This change will inject a meaningful dose of lay participation into Japanese criminal trials for the first time in 66 years (Japan had a jury system of sorts from 1928 to 1943). Each year, at least 20,000 Japanese citizens will participate in a jury-like institution that Tocqueville regarded as a “school for democracy.”

But if there are high hopes for Japan’s new lay judge system, there are also serious concerns. Consider three of the most salient.

The first anxiety is what ordinary citizens will do when they are required to decide matters of life and death in capital cases. Japan is, with the United States, one of only two developed democracies in the world that continue to carry out executions on a regular basis. But unlike the U.S., where death sentences and executions have decreased in recent years, the volume of both in Japan has climbed considerably. In the 18 months since Christmas Day in 2006, when four convicted murderers were hanged, Japan carried out more executions — 23 — than it performed in the previous nine years. Japan is, with Pakistan, one of only two Asian nations where executions are increasing.

Among supporters of capital punishment — around 80% of Japanese citizens — there is concern that the more that lay judges learn about the particular circumstances of a capital case, the more reluctant they will become to impose a sentence of death. And among death penalty opponents, there is a strong desire to stop the ongoing surge in executions. These two constituencies have come together in the Diet to propose the creation of a “life without parole” sentence, which would reduce the gap between the death penalty and the next most severe sanction, and in so doing would make the lay judge role a little easier to perform.

The second anxiety precipitated by the advent of lay judge trials concerns how Japanese lawyers will organize their work schedules under the new system and whether they will be able to deliver effective legal services to the defendants they represent. At present, criminal trials proceed discontinuously, with court sessions held once every month or two until a verdict is reached. It is not unusual for trials to last a year or more in the current system. But starting next year, serious criminal trials will be concentrated in a much shorter period, thus requiring defense teams to be continuously available for however long a trial takes: a day or two in simple cases, two weeks or longer in more complicated ones. For at least some attorneys in a society that hardly has a surplus of lawyers, the new system may create incentives to avoid criminal defense work altogether.

Although these are important issues, I believe the third concern is the most critical: will Japan’s new trial procedures stimulate sorely needed reforms in the pre-trial processes that have long been dominated by police and prosecutors? Here the central issues concern power and accountability in the interrogation room, where the main work of Japanese criminal justice tends to be done. Many of the most disturbing events in Japanese criminal justice stem from two related facts: the system’s over-dependence on confessions, and the absence of checks on police and prosecutor power in the interrogation room.

Since lay judges won’t be able to read long written reports, the new system could make criminal trials less reliant on the paper dossiers that police and prosecutors now produce during their investigations, and more reliant on oral arguments made in open court. If so, then the over-reliance on confessions might be curtailed.

But a more direct and effective safeguard against problems with interrogations would be requiring police to record the questioning of criminal suspects. Recording of this kind is rapidly spreading in the U.S., South Korea, Taiwan and many other nations, and there is no good reason for a rich, technologically sophisticated democracy like Japan to resist it. Yet there is in fact much resistance, especially from the police and prosecutors who have long determined the version of reality that emerges from the interrogation room — one of the most closed and secretive spaces in Japanese society.

Japan will eventually adopt recording reforms because they serve the core values that are supposed to animate Japanese criminal justice — and because recording is the trend of the times. But sooner is better than later for Japan’s recording reform. My hope is that Japan’s new trial system will cause the dominoes to fall in a way that nudges open a door that has been tightly closed for too long.

David T Johnson is a professor of sociology at the University of Hawaii. This commentary originally appeared in Metropolis magazine (

© Japan Today

©2022 GPlusMedia Inc.

Login to comment

I wonder if Japanese people have the confidence to make decisions and voice thier opinions in this context. Or if there is one strong peronality that everyone will crumble and just go along with whatever they say. Or for that matter go along with what some officer of the law/ court tells them to think and do. Will it be free from interferance from outside? We all know that Japanese people dislike rocking boats, and tend to just do what everyone else does, or what they thiink everyone else wants them to do. Japanese education needs to encourage more free thought and open discussion, for a long time, before Japanese people are even ready for this unfortunately. Although I hope my opinion is wrong, and that these changes are for the better. You would think they have to be for the better, but this is Japan...

0 ( +0 / -0 )

Half the old geezers and babas in my old neighborhood in Osaka would hang shoplifters and castrate teens for perusing the bikini pages of Young Jump. Look out Japan, these senile delinquents will have half the country on death row for double parking. Run away! Ya can't make a bad situation better by adding Alzheimer patients as supervisors!

0 ( +0 / -0 )

A Japanese lawyer friend of mine told me that most Japanese lawyers can not speak in easy to understand terms and do not know how to be concise. He also said most Japanese jurors will not know how to use logic or think independently.

He also added although there will be growing pains the first few years, this is a good move for Japans legal system.

0 ( +0 / -0 )

So basicly Japanese Judges are out of touch. They need to be reined by common folk. Lets hope this makes things fair, and faster for the Judical system. Will the Judges have final say on a case, or will they use the laymen as a vote system?

How is the laymen picked/hired? Cream of society? Would the ruling political party be able to stack the deck? That has happen alot in the U.S.

0 ( +0 / -0 )

It amounts to trial by chonaikai - and thus, it is very scary indeed. Something needs to be done about the Japanese legal system, yes, definately, but I have grave doubts about this. Japan and America should join the civilized world and abolish the death penalty. The taking of human life in this way is just State-sponsored murder.

0 ( +0 / -0 )

I always wondered what is so great about a bunch of common folks, who are so easily (mis)guided by a well-prepared emotional speech by a tricky lawyer judging about the outcome of a trial at court?

This will just open the doors to prejudice-motivated randomness in the juidicial system in Japan. Why on earth should Japan parrot one of the most screwed law systems in the world anyway?

0 ( +0 / -0 )

How are you suppose to teach individualism to the Jury? An alpha male in a Japanese group will sway the group to anything they choose.

0 ( +0 / -0 )

Why on earth should Japan parrot one of the most screwed law systems in the world anyway?

Because the US system doesnt have a 99% conviction rate.

0 ( +0 / -0 )

Login to leave a comment

Facebook users

Use your Facebook account to login or register with JapanToday. By doing so, you will also receive an email inviting you to receive our news alerts.

Facebook Connect

Login with your JapanToday account

User registration

Articles, Offers & Useful Resources

A mix of what's trending on our other sites