Here
and
Now

opinions

Philippines spat plays into China's hands

4 Comments

If you're a historic U.S. ally under mounting pressure from an emerging superpower like China, it's probably not a good idea to use a crude sexual epithet to describe the American president. Filipino leader Rodrigo Duterte, though, is far from a normal president. And his behavior - and that of his government - is increasingly posing a serious challenge to Washington on an ever-growing variety of levels.

Washington's relations with the Philippines have always been complex. The Philippines were one of the very few U.S. colonies overseas before they were granted independence in 1946, although the United States retained several sovereign bases. With the rise of China and growing confrontation in the South China Sea, most experts believed links would become notably stronger - indeed, that assumption was one of the linchpins of U.S. thinking, particularly after the Obama administration announced its "Asia pivot" in 2012.

The election of President Duterte in May this year, however, has made that relationship increasingly difficult, if not outright impossible. So far, the geostrategic implications of that move have been limited. But the longer he stays in office - and the worse his relations become with the United States in particular and the broader international community in general - the starker they will become.

In some ways, the White House may have been relieved that in calling Obama a "son of a bitch" - or in some translations, "whore" - Duterte finally pushed things too far. The comments, recorded in a conversation with mostly Filipino journalists, prompted the White House to cancel a planned bilateral meeting due to take place in an Asian security conference in Laos. Prior to the announcement, it was already shaping up to be a diplomatic disaster.

At the heart of the problem is Duterte's "war on drugs". In his election campaign, the Filipino president bluntly pledged to reduce crime by killing drug dealers, making it clear that during his tenure law enforcement agencies would be unencumbered by anything approaching legal process.

It was, essentially, an unapologetic pledge to enforce resource a campaign of extrajudicial murder. His government has been as good as its word. Around 900 people have been killed in police operations since July 1, with a further 1500 unsolved murders described officially as "under investigation" but which rights groups say in many cases appear to be government-sanctioned extrajudicial contract killings.

The human consequences have been deeply unpleasant. In August, the BBC profiled one of a growing number of female contract killers who said she had been paid by the government to kill several drug dealers, usually in cold blood. Unsurprisingly, public criticism of the campaign is relatively rare - not least because of rumors that political and personal scores may be being settled amid the crackdown.

Unsavory activities by America's allies are hardly new. U.S.-backed Latin American governments often ran a variety of death squads, particularly during the 1980s. Duterte, however, has made a point of boasting of the killings while demonstrating ever less tolerance for criticism. That has included threatening to leave the United Nations after condemnation from UN agencies and officials.

The outburst against Obama followed news reports that the U.S. president was aiming to be similarly critical.

The geopolitical implications make this remarkably messy. The United States cannot endorse - or even deal closely with - a leader who revels quite so clearly in tearing up the internationally accepted norms of law and order. America's entire Asian strategy, meanwhile, is dependent on building closer ties to countries like the Philippines and, ironically, stressing the importance of following internationally accepted rules on a wide range of other issues.

That's particularly true when it comes to Beijing's increasingly assertive posture in the South China Sea. Earlier this year, the Filipino government won a landmark ruling at the international U.N. maritime court in The Hague, declaring Beijing's grandiose claims of offshore territory unlawful.

Washington has been particularly critical of China's program of building military outposts on often disputed reefs, including those also claimed by the Philippines. Military collaboration with the United States has been increasing. In 2014, the two countries signed what they described as a landmark security accord giving the United States renewed access to bases. That deal had only just cleared its last legal hurdles, being declared constitutional by the highest Filipino court in July.

The Filipino government and China have some of the tensest territorial disputes in Asia, particularly over a chain of rocky outcrops known as Scarborough Shoal. What happens over them will help set the tone for the rest of the region, including other potential flashpoints with Japan, Taiwan, Vietnam and elsewhere. Officials in Beijing, one suspects, must barely be able to believe their luck.

© (c) Copyright Thomson Reuters 2016.

©2019 GPlusMedia Inc.

4 Comments
Login to comment

I think the author is over estimating the effect of the actions of the Philippine president. Half of america call obama worse names than this because he has been 8 years of an unmitigated disaster, including Obama effectively turning himself and the presidency into keystone cop show. Obama has no standing or respect from world leaders which is why this Philippine loud mouth felt perfectly ok bashing the US president, that is all on Obama.

The exaggeration is this belief China somehow was lucky and will benefit from some sort of rift created between America and the phillippines. This wont happen. Obama is NOT america, nor is the government America. America is still its people and the people of America like the Philippines far far more than China. Any other president, and maybe Amercians would be a bit upset from the comments, with Obama, most americans are likely thinking to themselves, Obama deserved to lay in the bed he made for himself and suffer the consequences. There will be no diminishing of Philippine and American cooperation or as allies. Worse case is people might wonder why a crazy loud uncouth guy is president of the Philippines,

-3 ( +2 / -5 )

Duerte was overwhelmingly elected - you know, democracy, that thing the West used to stand for.

-1 ( +2 / -3 )

thing is after this policy, i understand that drug dealers have been turning themselves in in droves....

2 ( +2 / -0 )

Well, finally we have someone in the World that has taken a stance against "drug trafficing". The Wotld has to take their hats off to the new President of the Phillipines. Maybe the group running Chicago, illinois should follow the President of the Phillipines who has illuminated many, many drug people. In Chicago where they have had, 100, 200, 300, 400 or how many Murders related to drugs.

-1 ( +0 / -1 )

Login to leave a comment

Facebook users

Use your Facebook account to login or register with JapanToday. By doing so, you will also receive an email inviting you to receive our news alerts.

Facebook Connect

Login with your JapanToday account

User registration

Articles, Offers & Useful Resources

A mix of what's trending on our other sites