Here
and
Now

opinions

Yukio Mishima – 'The Lost Samurai'

10 Comments

Jan 14 will mark the anniversary of the birth of one of modern Japan’s most famous, controversial, and mysterious personalities. Yukio Mishima (1925-1970) is regarded as one of 20th-century Japan’s most prolific writers, and was the first postwar Japanese writer to achieve international fame. Nominated on three occasions for the Nobel Prize for Literature, and author of no less than forty novels, essays, poems, and traditional Japanese kabuki and noh dramas, Mishima’s contribution to Japanese literature was indeed profound.

His samurai-inspired ritual suicide by hara-kiri (literally stomach cutting, or disembowelment) and beheading on Nov 25, 1970, at the young age of 45 marked the end of a life that represented for some, a protest against a post-war Japan that seemed to have lost its traditional identity and values under the tide of mass consumerism, and cultural and political Westernization.

The sharp contrasts between the country he grew up in and the Japan he died in were defining influences in his life, shaping his writings, which often questioned the new Japan and harked for a return to days of old. Born Kimitaka Hiraoka in Tokyo on Jan 14, 1925, he assumed the nom de plume "Yukio Mishima," cryptically interpreted as "He who chronicles reason,", so that his disapproving anti-literary father would not know he was a writer. It was however his paternal grandmother, Natsuko Hiraoka, who was to have the most lasting impact on his life. A mere 29 days after his birth until his 12th year, Mishima was separated from his family and raised by his sophisticated yet capricious grandmother whose own background and personality shaped his character.

The young protégé was forced to live a very sheltered life in which sports, playing with other boys, and even going out in the sun were off limits. She was the illegitimate daughter of a Meiji era daimyo with familial links to the all powerful Tokugawas and was reared in a princely household, a samurai-influenced upbringing which she did not let others forget and which instilled in her, and by consequence her grandson, a reverence for Japan’s past, and the samurai fascination with beauty, purity and death. Her noble past and yet not so noble marriage to a successful bureaucrat arguably contributed to her frustrations, characterized by violent outbursts and morbid fixations. Her character had a lasting yet undeclared effect on Mishima’s later works and personality, particularly the insatiable desire for perfection in the mind and body, and the terrible beauty of death at the moment of perfection exemplified by the honored cherry blossom.

Mishima’s complexities were not only confined to his writings. A fluent speaker of English, Mishima wore Western clothes and lived in a Western style house while espousing a return to his country’s past values and practices. Much mystery also surrounds the exact nature of his sexuality, and his frequenting of gay bars such as the now defunct Brunswick bar in Ginza despite a rushed marriage at 33 which produced two children. Mishima’s interest in homosexuality is clearly illustrated in one of his seminal books, "Confessions of a Mask" (1948) where he tells of a man who conceals his true self and sexuality behind a mask of lies and pretense. This book is regarded by many as a semi-autobiographical account of the author’s own life.

According to his biographers, he had also considered a marriage proposal to Michiko Shoda, the current empress and wife of Emperor Akihito. Biographers such as close friend John Nathan contend that the tragic writer married not for love but for respectability. The Japan of the 1950s was one in which a person who remained unmarried beyond the age of 30 was treated with a certain degree of suspicion and doubt. Mishima’s mother had also been diagnosed with cancer a few months earlier. The writer therefore would have seen marriage as a way to please his mother and also to gain acceptance for an otherwise eccentric figure, who held respectability in high regard. The pre-nuptial demands made by Mishima to his new wife were also telling. She was to respect his privacy, not to interfere with his writing or bodybuilding, and had to be shorter than him. Mishima himself was a mere 152 cms tall.

At the earlier age of 30, conscious of the inevitability of aging, and desiring bodily "perfection," he embarked on a strict bodybuilding regime that lasted for the rest of his life. His longing for a return to a spiritual Japan which respected the bushido (way of the warrior) code inspired his expertise in karate and kendo, martial arts that he contended allowed one to experience the border between life and death. His extreme nationalist credentials were most notably illustrated in his founding of the Tatenokai (Shield Society) in 1968, a small private army of mostly university students dedicated to the bushido code and the protection of the emperor and the martial discipline of pre-Meiji era Japan. This dedication was not to Hirohito per se, whom he had criticized for "dishonoring" the war dead by surrendering, and for renouncing his divinity after World War II, but rather to the symbolism of the emperor system for traditional Japan.

On Nov 25, 1970, carrying with him a longing for a return to lost samurai values, and an obsession with a purifying and beautiful death, Mishima and four of his Tatenokai followers, entered the Japanese Self-Defense Forces (JSDF) headquarters in Ichigaya and attempted a coup d’etat which they hoped would awaken the Japanese from their spiritual and political slumber. Stepping out onto a nearby balcony, Mishima was ridiculed and jeered as he attempted in vain to rouse the present JSDF members below him to his cause. Realizing the hopelessness of his efforts, the "Lost Samurai" went back inside for his final act of drama.

Positioning himself in traditional Japanese manner on the floor of the office which they had seized, Mishima proceeded to ritually disembowel himself with a "tanto" (a small sword), exclaiming “Long live the emperor” just before a pre-ordained "kaishakunin" (the one chosen to decapitate Mishima) and later one other, made an initially botched but ultimately effective attempt at beheading the famed author.

Debate surrounds Mishima’s motivations. Attempting a coup d’etat with only four other people was almost certainly going to be a failure. Comments made to Western journalists about hara-kiri in his writings some years earlier might be more insightful. At that time, the author claimed that “spiritually, I wanted to revive some samurai spirit. I did not want to revive hara-kiri itself but through the vision of such a very strong vision of hara-kiri, I wanted to inspire and stimulate younger people.”

Thus, Mishima’s longing for a samurai-style ritual suicide that would somehow atone for the "misdirection" of modern post-war Japan, and inspire future generations while satisfying his own fixation with death, would seem a more plausible explanation for his actions on that day. The failed coup provided Mishima with such an opportunity. His dramatic death has been seen as a final yet futile stand against the direction of post-war Japan.

Whatever one’s thoughts on Mishima may be, no one can deny the symbolic significance of his life and death for Japan’s post-war cultural identity. More than anything, his life’s beginning and end represented a quest for identity in a rapidly changing Japan where Mishima seemed to embody the ultimate "lost samurai." Like the samurai of old, he succeeded in achieving the perfect death where like the venerated cherry blossom he fell at the moment of perfection. He once said that “Dying for a great cause was considered the most glorious, heroic, and brilliant ways of dying”. Looking around us today nearly forty years later, the question of whether or not Mishima’s controversial death positively inspired a future generation of young Japanese people is open to debate.

© Japan Today

©2019 GPlusMedia Inc.

10 Comments
Login to comment

His ritual death must have been a great shock, (and, perversely, perhaps an influence), on some of the attending members of the JSDF.)

1 ( +1 / -0 )

A lot of reading to re-learn the fact that nationalists and rightists are not quite sane.

...dedicated to the bushido code and the protection of the emperor and the martial discipline of pre-Meiji era Japan. This dedication was not to Hirohito per se, whom he had criticized for “dishonoring” the war dead by surrendering, and for renouncing his divinity after World War II, but rather to the symbolism of the emperor system for traditional Japan.

Do any of you understand how you can respect and revere the symbolism of tenno while disrespecting the actual tenno? I could understand if it were a president, but we are talking about someone who is supposed to be divine here, by the symbolism.

Like I said, a lot of reading to re-learn that nationalists and rightist are not quite right in the head.

2 ( +5 / -3 )

Back in those days, most gays got married and had kids. It is just how things were done. Marriage wasn't about love, but were arranged, and about inheritance of wealth by the next generation (we still have a special word for love marriage even now: 恋愛結婚). That is why there was the flourishing mistrss custom (remember PM Uno's mistress giving an interview when he became PM, as if it was a perfectly respectable thing to do?) Even the editor Adon, of one of Japan's leading gay magazines, Minami Teishiro, was married and had a kid. He divorced when he started his magazine. He is still alive and you can talk to him. Why has Mishima's descendents forbidden the movie made about Mishima's life to be shown in Japan? It is the gay theme. Is that why all the nationalists do not claim Mishima as one of their own and try to revive him as an expression of their ideals?

2 ( +2 / -0 )

Back in those days, most gays got married and had kids. It is just how things were done.

Its not remotely that simple. Gays want kids too, and they cannot do that with a same sex partner.

as if it was a perfectly respectable thing to do?

It was and still is. Having "love marriages" has not sparked more eternally happy marriages. Divorce rates are not low. Affairs were a way of making marriages tolerable, and truly, nothing has actually changed in the need to make marriages tolerable. Marriage was and still is an union and partnership to grant stability for society, the people and involved and for the raising of children. The point is not sex. Kudos to those lucky ones who are eternally happy despite or even through fidelity, but not all us can do that, particularly if we happen to be gay but still want a family.

0 ( +2 / -2 )

His death ritual was for the sake of aesthetics, not politics. That's why his politics don't make a lot of sense, as Funnycar points out.

1 ( +3 / -2 )

Funny car, gays can adopt kids in many countries of the world, but unfortunately, not Japan. I was only repeating what I was told by older Japanese gays. I'm totally gay myself, so don't think I'm down on gays. I have a long term partner, but I don't think I'll ever want kids. That is just me.

5 ( +5 / -0 )

Alright summation, I guess, until the last paragraph,

no one can deny the symbolic significance of his life and death for Japan’s post-war cultural identity.

I'll go ahead and do it; I don't think anyone really remembers him. Sure he was famous, and his books are still in print. But I don't think anyone really cares or thinks about him very much. And I think he was only famous in a big way in that generation and the one right after. I don't think recent generations have much knowledge nor affinity with him.

As for me, I find what he did to have a suspicious scent of narcissism to it. the 2.5 books I read of his, and the movie version of another two I saw, were also very narcissistic, tho I am willing to give that a pass, as maybe he just wanted to write about narcissistic people. But taken with what I can see of his life, and the biopic, he just doesn't impress me that much.

THe body stuff- ya training's great for you, ok, hard training can lead to various insights about character and other things too, but when you get in to really serous training and looking at your body, you can also get really narcissistic really easily. It's perfectly natural and all, and anybody can get like that, but,

ergo I don't feel he has so much to say that is relevant to me, or modern J peeps.

-1 ( +0 / -1 )

Go ahead, Lowly. Miss the point entirely.

0 ( +0 / -0 )

Yet another self-absorbed right-wing ego maniac... even his ritual suicide had to be public. Japan is better without people like that. The samurai are gone - consigned to history. They had their place and time - even in 1970 the age of the samurai was long gone.

0 ( +0 / -0 )

Lost samurai?? Lost individual more like

0 ( +0 / -0 )

Login to leave a comment

Facebook users

Use your Facebook account to login or register with JapanToday. By doing so, you will also receive an email inviting you to receive our news alerts.

Facebook Connect

Login with your JapanToday account

User registration

Articles, Offers & Useful Resources

A mix of what's trending on our other sites