The requested article has expired, and is no longer available. Any related articles, and user comments are shown below.
© 2018 AFPElderly Japanese pine for return to 'lost' northern islands
By Miwa Suzuki NEMURO©2024 GPlusMedia Inc.
The requested article has expired, and is no longer available. Any related articles, and user comments are shown below.
© 2018 AFP
33 Comments
Login to comment
Strangerland
Pretty grim perspective, but entirely correct.
Ex_Res
Many people in Japan do not seem to realise how lucky they are, in that Japan was not broken up after WW2.
Japan should be thanking the USA.
commanteer
So because you haven't read about it, it can't have happened? What you describe is what happens in wars everywhere. That's why it's so bad to nurse hatred and hang on to past grievances, as they lead to war, and war is like this.
stepoutsidethebox
Just a humble brag. I have an original map with these islands still part of Japan.
oyatoi
Russia’s intransigence on the matter of the northern territories has a lot to do with not wanting to set a precedent that might embolden German irredentist claims to the Kaliningrad enclave and other swathes of territory carved out of the dying Reich.
Strangerland
Which is exactly why every minute the US spends in the middle east is only going to lead to generations of bitterness towards the west.
Kabukilover
Whatever Stalin said, the Soviet Union had little fight left in it, with some 30 million dead and the infrastructure in shreds.
GyGene
I really think Russia should return all the islands to Japan. Using the same reasoning as Russia, the USA could actually own Okinawa. I'm so glad we didn't act like Russia, and properly returned Okinawa control to Japan in 1972. There are still bases there, but I think these bases in Okinawa are critical to help Japan's self defense. If Russia returned the islands, it would help Russia's international standing a lot!
Schopenhauer
I sometimes feel strange that Japanese people dislike Russia while in Okinawa, U.S. Forces appear disliked as much as we dislike Russian. It is not fair. When I was a child, elder people all said Japan was lucky losing a war to U.S. and occupied by them but not by Russia.
1glenn
If it had been necessary to invade the main islands of Japan to achieve a surrender, then the US would have probably welcomed Soviet cooperation, the way the allies cooperated in Europe. However, if the Soviets had assisted in an invasion, much more than Sakhalin and a few small islands would have been lost to Japan. Stalin wanted parts of Hokkaido and Honshu. He requested as much from Truman, but because of the atom bomb, Truman said no, and Stalin acquiesced.
Because of Imperial Japan's ambitions and brutality, Japan almost lost half of its home islands.
Wolfpack
It may seem harsh to the former island residents but as a nation Japan took a calculated risk in it’s expansionist military actions during the 1930s~40s. That risk resulted in a massive defeat. There is little chance that Russia would voluntarily give up a strategic waterway to the Pacific ocean. Hirohito and the Showa Emperor the two primary wartime leaders of Japan at the time are to blame for this.
Alistair Carnell
They can pine for it all they want, but they have as much chance of getting it back, as the dead parrot has, getting to the fiords.
smithinjapan
Abe and the right-wing nationalists have ensured that these islands will NEVER be Japanese land, ever again. They've had more than one chance to get at least two back, but gave those up because it might lead to disparity among the ultra-right voters. Russia laughs at them and says flat out "No" while Abe says, around voting time, "I vow to have the issue resolved!" Forget it, people, sad as that might be. You helped make your bed by voting in the people that have ensured it is not a possibility.
Ex_Res
I think Japan would appreciate a generous gesture by Russia.
Russia has made a generous gesture to Japan and offered a peace treaty. Japan refused.
BertieWooster
That's right. They belonged to the Ainu. And then the Wajin (Japanese) invaded. So, perhaps the Russians should give the islands back to the Ainu. Except there are hardly any left.
nandakandamanda
I think Japan would appreciate a generous gesture by Russia.
macv
At gunpoint, her father shielded his daughters at their home on an island north of Hokkaido.
"Only after you kill me!" he screamed at the soldiers, who left without harming the family.
This same scenario occurred all over Asia but with Japanese soldiers slaughtering every man women and child the encountered. I've never read of any instance where Japanese soldiers left without harming the family.
Samit Basu
@expat
The standard international protocol is that they gain citizenship of new sovereign state.
But this is Japan we are talking about, and Japan stripped the migrants from Korea and Taiwan of their citizenship after the surrender. So Japan will probably settle for a permanent green card, the one that cannot be stripped.
Takeshi Hasegawa
Japan officially abandoned the sovereignty about the bigger islands(Kunashiri and Etorofu).
But as for the smaller ones(Habomai and Shikotan), Japan still have a right to demand Russia to return it. Russia side does know it and they have ever talked with Japan side on the premise.
Some influential Japanese need to explain to the national that the option to get back all of the 4 islands does NOT exist and there are only 2 options left. Reclaiming pnly the smaller ones or abandon all of the islands.
Kenji Fujimori
Retired old folks have plenty of time to release hot air on their pension
sf2k
Pining for the fjords
shashank
Russia will never handover those islands
Jimi
exactly, wherever Japanese soldiers went they just slaughtered people, of course most people in Japan would never beleive this due to many decades of brainwashing into the 'we were the victims' mentality.
Jimi
yep, it could have become a North South Korea scenario, with the DMZ around Osaka area.
Vernon Watts
You wonder why America has stayed out of this dispute? Actually, its kind of a payback since the Japanese assembled its fleet to attack Pearl Harbor at Taikan Bay in the Kurils. The site was chosen since it was very foggy that time of year and would give the fleet a semblance of cover before setting sail on the mission...
Samit Basu
Wishing for the return of the Kurils is like wishing for the return of Taiwan, Korea, Manchuria, Saipan, etc.
These territories were never a part of Japan prior to the founding of Imperial Japan, and their return to their respective owners is the natural end to the dissolution of Imperial Japan and end of WW2. They are never combining back.