The requested article has expired, and is no longer available. Any related articles, and user comments are shown below.
© Thomson Reuters 2021.Worshippers brave smoldering coals to pray for safety
TOKYO©2024 GPlusMedia Inc.
The requested article has expired, and is no longer available. Any related articles, and user comments are shown below.
© Thomson Reuters 2021.
31 Comments
Login to comment
Ricky Sanchez
Great Idea to carry a baby through smoke! Children die of smoke inhalation! This is Child abuse and this woman should be arrested.
Mr Kipling
Pray for safety or do nothing.... You will get the same result.
There are things you can do to help yourself before a disaster.... walking on cinders is not one of them.
Fighto!
Crazy people doing dangerous things. Really dumb.
InspectorGadget
"Praying I don't catch fire . . . . praying I rolled my trousers up high enough . . . . "
browny1
Masks should be mandatory for these events on any occasion when the smoke is so thick.
Talk about a PM2.5 bomb to the lungs.
Mocheake
Pray for safety by doing something unsafe and unnecessary. Sure.
Goodlucktoyou
@lamilly. I agree.
i have done this twice, but not for religious reasons. the first time it was painful and I burnt the skin. But the second time I was taught about empty mind philosophy. It is a very special place. I felt no pain, just calmness. It is a special place.
RareReason
No it doesn't.
No it doesn't.
Ricky Sanchez
@RareReason.
You pretty much said it all. This is a cult ritual, nothing more. I don't need to cause harm to my body or my childs lungs to send me into another world.
Hiro
From the comments i can see this is just a clash once again concerning culture and believes. Let them do what they want. Is their body and they can do whatever they want. Is not you who have to endure the pain anyway. Each person has their own view how to pray.
Mr Kipling
There is no magic involved. Just science. Walk fast, the ash insulates....
Leo
There is no salvation in Buddhism. Who or what are they worshipping I wonder.
Robert Cikki
They can do what they want, pray how they want, etc. But don't present it with false claims, like ""Passing your body through the flames cleanses your soul and delivers your prayers to Buddha," said Kosho Kamimura, a Buddhist monk from Takao Yakuouin Temple.". Because that turns it from a culture/belief into a cult.
Vinke
During normal times this is an interesting, fascinating historical/cultural act, and surely an important part of their heritage to some, but even offering something like this as a kind of ’alternative’ for any real measurements to fight the pandemic is near criminal imo.
No tests, no social distancing, but walk on hot coals and inhale some smoke... sure, that will take care of the virus for all of us.
kurisupisu
Yes, walking with a baby over hot coals and what if you slip?
Addfwyn
@Hiro
Yes, people can do what they want, but people can also call them idiots for doing it. People have every right to do both. Something doesn't get a pass simply by being cultural/traditional/religious.
Unfortunately, the ability to do what you want ceases to be relevant when you are bringing a baby into the situation. At the least you are risking tremendous amounts of smoke inhalation for the baby, and heaven forbid you fall while carrying them. I realise that may not be what most people here are doing, but shame on the monks for not stopping her.
Sven Asai
Only by reading about such stupid things I just feel much more enlightened now. lol
Mr Kipling
If you want to test the power of your prayers just stop walking and stand still.....
Google... the science of fire walking.
englisc aspyrgend
Magic thinking, a classic product of ignorance.
John Toomey
I walked on the fire Hi-Watari 火渡りthree times at Mt Takao's Yakuno-In 高尾山 役の院 when I was living in Japan for 16 years as an American citizen, teaching in the DODDS/DODEA American Schools. I walked along with teaching colleagues who also reported no pain and we smiled and waved happily to cheer each other on.
Yes, you can feel the heat rising up (there is almost no smoke in hot coals) and somehow you know you are walking on the hot coals which you can see, yet it never hurts; and I was watching to make sure I walked on the coals and not just the warm ash. An acolyte guides one first to step into a small mound of salt. It may be that the salt coating has some cooling effect. I did once step on a twig that pierced the sole of my foot and drew a little blood that hurt a little, but there was no burning at all and no serious damage from the hole the twig poked. I am an atheist, totally anti-religion, yet make friends easily with thinking Buddhist, Christian and Jewish believers and clergy; but I walked the fire for the sake of immersing myself in Japanese culture and there is nothing to compare with the happy, radiant smile of the purple-robed Buddhist priest who congratulates one at the end of the walk as he lovingly presses to your heart a bronze vajra (Sanskrit for thunderbolt= enlightenment) ritual implement, shaped like two crossed thunderbolts, used in the Shingon, literally "True Word" or "True Teaching", esoteric sect which is practiced at Mt. Takao. It's a great cultural experience that exemplifies the open, accepting and encouraging character of all my Japanese friends.
starpunk
In the United States, esp. in rural areas there are 'Christian churches' where the parishioners dip their hands into a tank and handle poisonous rattlesnakes as a 'test of faith'. Of course it's only a test of God and even some of their ministers get bit and die, showing that they're not 'good enough' or they're not 'in God's favor'. Yet the practice continues, strange and abhorrent but true.
Siddhartha Gautama lived and died over 2500 years ago. And I don't think he said anything about fire walking.