The requested article has expired, and is no longer available. Any related articles, and user comments are shown below.
© Copyright 2013 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.New judo rules favor Japan at world championships
By MARIA CHENG©2024 GPlusMedia Inc.
21 Comments
Login to comment
avigator
They probably cried about it like babies and got the attention they wanted.
skaizun
Bravo on the ruling: Judo is not wrestling.
nath
Good for the sport, the other countries will adjust and then Japan will appeal for more changes. Next rule changes will be the Sumo association.
Tessa
To be honest, I think they did just that. I got endless moaning and whining from my students about how foreigners had ruined judo, or even "judo is for Japanese." Got a lot of blank looks when I suggested that soccer should only be played by English people, in that case!
VicMOsaka
As Judo is a Japanese sport, it should be played out as it was originally intended. I have watched olympic judo bouts in the past which have been basterdised by other countries own versions of the sport. Add to that the obvious unfair judging by judges who are incompetent. They even refuse to review videos of the bouts in the case unfair verdicts, thereby robbing Japanese of their fairly won medals.
Why do they need blue Judo suits ? Can't the judges tell who is who on the mat ?
kwatt
Original style of Judo seems to be very good for Japanese Judoka. I think it should have been in the past. As to past international games, they looked like dancing game on mat. Good dancers used to win the game like wrestler. Judo game must be used "Ippon" or "20 second Newaza" technique more often to win the game. It will be a more beautiful game than ever.
Kazuaki Shimazaki
In soccer, the identifying characteristic is the ball. Different martial arts on the other hand are differentiated by their range of tactics since they use the same means (bodies, hands and feet). So there is a valid case for tightening up the rules if certain teams are using tactics of another martial art, whether it happens to favor Japan or not.
realdoll
Tessa, the blank looks you got were for some other reason because what you said made no sense. If soccer was changed by some international committee where you can run with the ball, then the English started loosing because they didn't do that, then you would be right. The "judo" they are using doesn't work when you are old or weak, they are using techniques that favor the big and strong, requiring less skill or at least strength and skill. It is moving back to the traditional way where someone doesn't go in there and jerk and pull with all his muscles then take someone to the mat.
JeffLee
@VicMOsaka
"As tennis is a French sport, it should be played out as it was originally intended. I have watched tennis tournaments in the past which have been basterdised by other countries own versions of the sport."
Sounds ridiculously chauvinistic, doesn't it?
The French invented tennis, a sport mentioned in Shakespeare with a much longer history than judo (created in the 1880s), but you don't see the French all miserable about losing to "bastardizing" foreigners, do you.
realdoll
Kwatt, it takes skill to make it look beautiful, however the dancing analogy implies cooperation which wouldn't require as much skill. To make it look beautiful without any cooperation by the opponent is very difficult due to the timing and sensitivity involved. Look at a clip on youtube of Mifune Judo and compare to Olympic Judo, no comparison.
cwhite
when martial arts become dependant on brute force from the big guys then it's not martial arts any more and just street fighting. I just love it when some small girl throws a huge black dude across the room.
therougou
I'm sure Japan complained, and rightfully so. They changed the rules to help out other countries in the first place, but in doing so they made it completely boring. Did you try watching Judo at the Olympics?
Francis Urquhart
They promote 'traditional' judo and tachiwaza, yet 'you are not allowed to attack the legs'? HUH?!!! So, that's just hip and shoulder throws then. It reminds me of that scene on Yip Man II when Yip is beating the British boxer using the techniques he (the boxer) deems to be inferior, so his side get kicking techniques banned from the contest.
TakahiroDomingo
the rule is the same for everybody, it does not favor any particular country. if you wanna change judo, try to get it legally acknowledged as a new (hahaha) sport, and call it something like rudo or putin-judo or whatever
kwatt
There is no new rules about Judo from the begging. Judo is Judo. The sport of Judo is simply going back to the original way when Judo as sport was accepted to Olympics in 1964. Today's Judo was completely different from one in 1964.
These are definitely needed to win or lose the game more often during the game, not dancing each other until time is up. That is original Judo.
taijing
Judo is practiced by millions of people around the world, and each school has more or less their own tricks to victory. Each time the rules are changed, such as in other disciplines, it is normal that they are going to be in favor of, or in the detriment of, part of the players/countries. Some countries with ruling status over one discipline will surely modify the rules so that they be in favor of their own players.
Onsen
New rules are:-
cwhite
When martial arts become dependant on brute force from the big guys then it's not martial arts any more and just street fighting. It's good to bring the rules back to traditional judo roots.
Frungy
I applaud the decision to stop turning judo into another wrestling event. And the Japanese have every right to complain when someone takes their national sport and starts messing with it. The line had to be drawn somewhere.
... next up I want naked wrestling back, Greco-Roman style!! And oil, lots and lots of olive oil....
WilliB
Good for the sport! Now re-introduce wrestling back into Olympics, instead of griping that Judo is too different from wrestling.
Knox Harrington
Mmm, natsukashii!!!