The requested article has expired, and is no longer available. Any related articles, and user comments are shown below.
© (c) Copyright Thomson Reuters 2019.Public hearings in Trump impeachment probe set to begin
By James Oliphant and Susan Heavey WASHINGTON©2024 GPlusMedia Inc.
84 Comments
Strangerland
He's a one-trick pony. He just keeps doing and repeating the same things over and over. The system has caught up to him, and he isn't smart enough to figure out how to adjust his game to stay ahead of the system.
He'll be impeached, the impeachment hearings will expose everything about him, and the Republicans will then put themselves on record as excusing his actions. Then the people will vote.
That will be the true telling of whether America is beyond the point of no return. If they still elect the representatives who protected Trump, even after all the evidence is out there for all to see, it will mean that there is no hope left for the country.
Chip Star
This is a weird characterization of the Dems engaging in oversight and ensuring Donny's corruption doesn't go unchecked. But, if it helps you sleep at night . . .
No, I don't think Dems know this. Again, if it helps you feel better about slavishly supporting an incompetent, corrupt twitter addict . . .
plasticmonkey
When hearings were held behind closed doors, Trumpsters whined.
When hearings are held in public, Trumpsters whine.
Some people just can't handle the truth. You people voted for a crook.
PTownsend
So he's going to release his tax info?
Chip Star
Excellent. Now everyone gets to hear firsthand about Donny soliciting campaign assistance from a foreign government. We also get to witness republicans demonstrating that they care far more about staying in power than the rule of law.
Toasted Heretic
Of course he's coming out with nonsense like this. He's desperate and terrified.
Expect more of the same from his zealots as the hearings progress.
Strangerland
Its interesting that the left has left Hillary behind. We never talk about her, don’t care about her, and frankly would prefer she just go away. The only purpose she serves now is as an example of right-wing hypocrisy.
These people are so stupid they claim that the reason we dislike Trump is because Hillary lost.
Yeah guys. The world is so simplistic you can boil the dislike of trump down to one single issue, and somehow there is such a massive conspiracy going on that they’ve convinced 99% of left to stop talking about her anymore while secretly plotting to remove trump and put Hillary up in his place. Somehow though you guys haven’t found any existence of said conspiracy even though the notes must have gone out to 100s of millions of trump haters world wide.
You people who keep on with this trope that the left cares about Hillary are just exposing yourselves for being too stupid to see how stupid such a claim appears to anyone with half a brain.
Toasted Heretic
Doesn't matter.
Trump corruption and the continuous contempt for the people must be brought to an end.
Lock him up and deprogram his disciples.
CrazyJoe
Trump: "The hearings should be public!"
Dems: "Ok, we'll make the hearings public."
Trump: "The hearings should not be public!!"
On this Veterans Day, remember that Trump took money from his foundation, which was supposed to go the veterans, and spent it on a portrait of himself and illegal contributions to folks like Pam Bondi.
Chip Star
We should also expect the weaponized Justice Department to open investigations into Schiff and the whistleblower.
Ah_so
A pretty incoherent argument.
Ah_so
While the Senate will never convict him, it is good to see the president's criminal behaviour explored in public. At least then the people who vote for him will have to do so in three knowledge that they are voting for a crook.
And I think the nation is also going to be interested in the state of his tax returns. It may give a clue as to why Donny feels the nees to steal from charity.
SuperLib
Trump was so worried about running against Biden he had to extort favors from Ukraine to help himself.
Trump is, was, and always will be a born rich loser.
Strangerland
Trumpers supporting bonespurs while criticizing purple hearts.
stormcrow
When Clinton lied about oral sex, from a Republican perspective you'd think that it was the end of the world.
In Trump we have a president who's endangered U.S. national security and the survival of a fragile democracy (Ukraine) by affecting its ability to defend itself against a far larger and aggressive bully.
In other words, . . .
Bill Clinton lying about having received oral sex . . . BAD! BAD!
Trump using vital American assistance to extort information from a foreign country on a political opponent in a domestic election. . . . Hmmmm. Well, that's not so bad.
What a bunch of hypocrites!
PTownsend
Given how many billions the global elite pour into Trump's campaign, given the global alt right's powerful media, it might be difficult to defeat Trump. The global elite have got even richer and more powerful since Trump's been in office and will do all it takes to keep him there. They want him to continue to undermine the principles the republic was built on to establish corporatist authoritarianism - for their benefit.
The global alt right sure seem to be afraid of women, especially women of color. Having said that, Michelle, who's ethical, honest, articulate and intelligent would be a welcome change from a man who's her opposite.
plasticmonkey
= everything was above board, the phone call was "perfect", but we the Trump faithful refuse to offer you evidence.
It's also interesting that the Trump administration cared so much about corruption in Ukraine that they tried to get funding for anti-corruption programs reduced, and they relied on the president's personal lawyer, Giuliani, rather than professionals in the diplomatic corps, to handle this concern.
lincolnman
More fact-less chest beating and false bravado from the Trumpers - nothing that addressed the mountain of evidence that Donnie orchestrated an extortion and shakedown of Ukraine on at least three occasions; one last Spring when he told the former President that no Oval Office meeting unless they investigated the Bidens, then the same bribery for the newly elected President in the summer, then an additional QPQ on the frozen military aid.
Donnie admitted it, Mulvaney admitted it, Crazy Rudy admitted it, Sondland admitted it (after lying first), Taylor confirmed it, and LTC Vindman heard it first hand on the phone call, plus all the others than confirmed it.
While not needed, it would be great to have John Bolton tell us all about Rudy the "Hand Grenade", the Ukraine "drug deal" and the meetings and info he stated "have yet to come out"...
Trumpers avoid the facts because they haven't any to reply with - so they sink to weak "Trump 2020" exhortations to ease their conflicted minds.
Nothing but Trumper Ambien...
They really need to load up when the open hearings start...
SuperLib
The Repubs will always have their media trial to fall back on to keep them entertained and outraged while the legitimate investigation against Trump makes it through the actual legal system.
Strangerland
Unfortunately they are undermining the legal system by attempting to subvert the court of public opinion. Their hope is that the people will take to the streets and rebel even though everything is done legally and by the book. They would rather have violence in the streets than have their democratically removed president removed from office. These same people scream how the rules must be followed for the electoral college, while at the same time screaming th4 rules must not be followed for impeachment.
Toasted Heretic
This is how the craven right treat their patriots and those who have served. Question loyalties and belittle their service.
The craven right are happy to insinuate all kinds of everything and wish to endanger lives.
What's the term their leader uses? Ah yes, human scum.
Strangerland
So? Who cares?
Strangerland
So? Why should you?
Strangerland
The dems are playing by the rules of the game as set out by the pubs. Boo hoo to you.
takeda.shingen.1991@gmail.com
Not a fact. Not even true. He was fired for investigating corruption. Look up Shokin.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Viktor_Shokin
Toasted Heretic
I thought you were against name-calling?
takeda.shingen.1991@gmail.com
For not investigating corruption*
starpunk
The Clinton impeachment scandal was stupid beyond measure. Most people in America acted like juveniles reading those idiotic little white porn books during study hall, and the Starr report basically was such a book - without the profanity.
The sex offenses that Trump is guilty of are much worse, let alone illegal. Just like everything else he's doing now. Dumpster is a bigger criminal than any previous WH occupant, and all of them together.
u_s__reamer
The bizarro claims and half-baked statements (of fake "facts") emanating from Trump's mouth and the twisted, illogical rage-tweets he's been shooting off since he realized the "I" word would become reality clearly show that the cornered POTUS is frightened and rapidly losing it . Ttump's pre-impeachment behavior alone should be sufficient to make him the poster boy for the 25th. And just in case his conduct gets even worse, I hope a presidential straight-jacket has been readied for him, too.
Sneezy
It isn't, actually.
Chip Star
Polls? Everyone knows pills can't be trusted unless you are using them to support your position. Smooth, Bass; real smooth.
lincolnman
Note no facts....
False outrage with no facts....
More spin, no facts...
They've got nothing, and they know it...they try to insert the so-called Whistle Blower but that person's been by-passed by Trump's own hand-picked team mates who have all testified it was a bribe and extortion...
And more about the process - yet when they get what they've whined about, they whine some more...
Nothing, nada, empty...
Toasted Heretic
Er, she criticized Trump as well. Quite vocally.
There is treason, yes. It's where your leader commits by sharing classified info, using foreign powers to help meddle in the elections etc.
Will there be war because of it? Well, there are alt right types claiming that a civil war is approaching, but let's hope that's all just hyperbole. At the most, I think what's happening now is that there is a "cold" civil war, in the struggle to save America from the regime.
SimondB
Why do you think that might be? Russian involvement? Ukraine? Paying off prostitutes? Siding with Putin against his own country? Fine people on both sides? I could go on if you like.
Strangerland
For once this is entirely on topic:
LOCK HIM UP! LOCK HIM UP!
Blacklabel
Vindman is active duty military and the likely leaker to the whistleblower.
Veterans Day is not for active duty members. seems you would know this. Next you will be trying to tell me Hunter Biden is a military veteran.
you know who IS a decorated veteran? Mike Flynn. 33 years honorable service.
Blacklabel
You better get Trump impeached or get a few more candidates. Your front runner saying dumb stuff again on the 1 day a week they let him out in public.
Strangerland
Are people who dodged military service by using their money to make up fake bone spurs considered veterans?
Blacklabel
When was he convicted exactly? Your Ukraine ambassador lied under oath. As did Comey, Clapper, Brennan, McCabe....on and on. I didnt know you considered that a bad thing anymore.
lincolnman
Today, back in the US, is Veterans Day - there are ceremonies all over the country honoring our brave military members who gave and sacrificed. That is except Trumpers, who ridicule and insult them.
It shows they're lack of common decency, integrity, and patriotism.
On the very day we thank and honor them, they choose to smear them.
It's just absolutely disgraceful...
Peter Neil
This constant Trump show is tedious.
lincolnman
Likely...as in maybe....as in could be....as in possible....as in we only hope and pray... Trumpers have no facts, just conspiracy theories....
Veterans Day: A celebration to honor America's veterans for their patriotism, love of country, and willingness to serve and sacrifice for the common good.
Veterans Day honors all those who have worn the uniform. We understand Trumpers wouldn't know that, given their disdain and hate for our military...
And a convicted felon who lied under oath about meeting with America's enemies; Russians...
Strangerland
You know who’s not? Bone spurs himself.
But you’d call the Purple Heart treasonous.
Ah_so
And you know who isn't? Draft dodger Trump.
Blacklabel
have worn, not currently wearing.
Are active duty members considered veterans?
A veteran is a former member of the Armed Forces of the United States (Army, Navy, Air Force, Marine Corps, and Coast Guard) who served on active duty and was discharged under conditions, which were other than dishonorable. ...
Blacklabel
no relation between getting shot and being truthful. Y
You guys gave Mike Flynn NO love or benefit of the doubt. I think most of you think he was actually convicted and is in jail. as he makes all your lists of supposed Mueller successes.
Blacklabel
Of course not, obviously. No one is claiming anyone like that is.
Strangerland
You mean the guy who lied under oath for dealing with the enemy?
Duh. Of course he gets no love nor the benefit of any doubt.
And after you guys demonize everything and anything why should anyone on your team ever get the benefit of any doubt? You act as if you haven’t entirely made parodies of yourselves.
Blacklabel
Ah ok, I thought we were on a military lovefest or something. as much as you guys love Vindman and he is above any questions whatsoever just because he put on his kinda tight uniform once this year.
Blacklabel
Its not made up.
IG report said so, you might want to go back and read that one. From your liberal favorite WaPo article from April 20, 2018.
"The referral to the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the District of Columbia occurred some time ago, after the inspector general concluded McCabe had lied to investigators or his boss, then-FBI Director James B. Comey, on four occasions, three of them under oath."
tada!
Strangerland
Deep state globalist fake news.
Strangerland
Electoral college. Theme the rules as your team says. Boo boo to you.
Blacklabel
To at least pretend to be fair. If you don’t, public opinion will boomerang on you very quickly.
Blacklabel
You wont even let him testify in public. so how would you know he is worthy of such? You just like the words coming out of his mouth so you dont want to bother to check. Anyway, good luck with impeachment you will need it.
Whatsnext
Strangerland
I was only responding to ptownsend s comment about campaign financing. And you go on this Hillary tangent. The Dems lost because the super delegate s disenfranchised the Democratic voter and chose unwisely. And this year your choices are very weak. You can't run on hate trump with no policy points. It didn't work here for the hate Abe strategy either. This is why this impeachment is going on. It was going on from seating the delegates to purging any pro trump policy maker to supporters to the muller thing. It's like you never stops screaming since you lost.
arrestpaul
A Presidential impeachment is held in the court of public opinion. Elected representatives are very much aware of this. If they get it wrong, the voters will unelect them at the earliest opportunity.
There is very little established legal precedent regarding Presidential impeachments. Both political parties are feeling their way along as they go. If U.S. voters perceive the process as being unfair, elected Congressmen, and Senators, will pay a price. It's already been established that the U.S. news media outlets can not be trusted to provide unbiased news. The news media outlets profess disbelief, or confusion, about why the voters won't vote the way the news media outlets demand that they do. Most people simply don't care what the news media outlets have to say anymore, and it's the news media's own fault. Elected representatives do not want to find themselves in the same position as the news media outlets.
Serrano
In Trump we have a president who's endangered U.S. national security and the survival of a fragile democracy (Ukraine) by affecting its ability to defend itself against a far larger and aggressive bully.
Sure stormcrow, just make up stuff and post it, why don't you? Obama gave blankets to Ukraine. They're now getting lethal military hardware to defend themselves.
Wolfpack
Actually it gets even better. Now the next time Republicans investigate a Dem president they don't need to give a fair hearing like they did for Bill. Schiff is not even pretending to be even handed after the Mueller coup attempt blew up in his face.
bass4funk
Well, if you look at the polls, the country is divided that’s for sure. People have already made up their minds. People that hate Trump will continue to hate him, the ones that love Trump will continue to love him, nothing to change really, but the Republicans are justifiably fighting these allegations and if they don’t or won’t get it from the Dems, they should resist.
Who said that? Come on now....
Ok, now we’re falling into that Unicornverse again....the Dems wouldn’t remove Clinton and the Republicans won’t move Trump. Why would either party in an impeachment inquiry yield to the other party especially when their was no real crime committed.
My, my, my what are Dems going to do when Trump wins a second term....impeach him again?
Blacklabel
Did we get even 1 witness yet? Nope. Are all private people testifying publicly? Nope. So what is this “when we get what we whined about”? We haven’t gotten anything and you know this.
arrestpaul
The "resist" movement started right after it became apparent that ol' Hillary had lost her 2nd attempt to become POTUS. The left-wing calls for Trumps impeachment began right after it became apparent that ol' Hillary had lost her 2nd attempt to become POTUS. Congresswoman wacky Maxine Waters has been calling for Trumps impeachment since his inauguration. The Mueller witch hunt was supposed to lead Trumps impeachment, but failed to provide the evidence to prove the Democrats preconceived guilty verdict. Even the whistleblowers lawyer was calling for Trumps impeachment in 2017, and claimed that CNN would be leading the way. At least he was correct about CNNs involvement.
Whatsnext
Fact:
Joe Biden threatened to withhold US funding if the Ukraine government didn't fire the prosecutor that was investigating his son. The prosecutor was fired
Fact:
Joe bidens son, Hunter biden never attended a board meeting once when head of the ukraining energy company though he received thousands of dollars.
bass4funk
Wait a minute, House Democrats are doing everything to stay in power..
ROFL!
Like Flynn, Petraeus and Kelly...that is until he left the WH and now he’s a hero to liberals.
Bloomberg just jumped in the Presidential race a billionaire, they welcome him, then the progressive socialists cry foul because he is trying to buy his way to an election, meanwhile, Warren talks about taking everyone’s money and lies to people and the middle class their taxes won’t go up (as if we can’t use a calculator) Harris and Booker are crying racism that the process is rigged and all of them and Hillary on the sidelines are trying to sabotage Tulsi Gabbard because she wants to pull our Troops out of the ME and agrees with Trump on that, now she’s working for the Russians. But yeah, the Democrats are a peaceful and cohesive party. ROFL!
Serrano
Fact:
Joe Biden threatened to withhold US funding if the Ukraine government didn't fire the prosecutor that was investigating his son. The prosecutor was fired
And he bragged about it.
Fact:
Joe bidens son, Hunter biden never attended a board meeting once when head of the ukraining energy company though he received thousands of dollars.
$83,000 a month sure would buy a lot of crack, wouldn’t it, Hunter?
Blacklabel
Where’s Vindman? Maybe he can squeeze into that uniform one more time and tell us how he leaked classified into to his brother and possibly the whistleblower.
Blacklabel
same day in WaPo and next day on TV. “Impeachment”. There hasn’t been a day go by in 3 years that some effort wasn’t underway to remove Trump.
now when Kelly and Tillerson outed by Nikki Haley for undermining the elected President, CNN just says it’s shocking they felt they had to do that. Ummm that’s treason, by the war.
Blacklabel
So why is it not a problem that almost everyone who testified in private and whose testimony helped build this “narrative” won’t be heard in public?
Blacklabel
Somebody got the new talking points. The dems and media overlords just agreed yesterday to change the wording to “extortion”. It’s still not as Ukraine gave nothing and did nothing to get the money.
Blacklabel
It’s so sad Dems had to pull out both Bloomberg and a guy Obama will endorse, (Patrick) unlike his supposed best friend Joe.
this impeachment really is the last gasp effort, can’t win the election is very clear now.
Blacklabel
It is a fact that only 3 of 15 people who testified in private are testifying in public.
fact.
bass4funk
Ahhh, that’s what the liberal networks keep telling you guys?
To liberals, that is true.
No Business
All of this is great. Just makes a Trump victory in 2020 more likely! Awesome!
bass4funk
This is going to blow back so hard in their faces, I’m just a struck at how the Democrats are making it too easy for Trump to slide into a second term. Maybe, just maybe in 4 years they’ll look back and reflect on how their wicked ways took the, out of another Presidential election cycle.
bass4funk
What facts? Accusations from Ciaramilla don’t count.
While Democrat candidates continue to sink....
Serrano
Democrats continue to dig themselves a deeper hole with this shameful latest attempt to take down the president. They know they can't win the 2020 election even if Michelle jumps in.
Blacklabel
15 people testified and we have 3 public witnesses? And no Republican witnesses at all. This will be a total disaster for Dems.
non party
Finally Demos are ready for a open hearing. But funny things is that Adam Shitff is not allowing the republicans to call the witness and to ask questions to the witnesses. Such a shame on Adam Shitff. Why they are afraid of that?? In fact it is a cue by the rich and corrupt DEMOCRAT politicians to remove a president who fight against corruption. Democrats congress man and senators are millionaires and billionaires. They are in the Washington for over 30 years making millions through black deals, and through favor to favor. Trump wants to expose the 50 years old corruption. He will drain the swamp. And millionaire democrats are against and afraid of the most successful president in the American History. The left reporters and left media never tell the truth to people. But Trump will have super land slide in 2020..Watch ..
Serrano
He'll be impeached
We'll see if the Democrats actually have the votes to impeach him. Even if they do, it's DOA in the Senate.
Trump train coming through! Choo Choo!
arrestpaul
Hohoho. Schiff, along with his fellow Democrats, "resist" goons, and CNN-types have been attacking Trump since they embarrassed each other by assuming Hillary would never lose a 2nd attempt to become POTUS. Democrats, and Hillary worshippers, appear to feel really bad about themselves whenever Trump counterpunches the elected Democrat's attempts to overturn/overthrow the results of the last Presidential election.
Personally, I can't wait to find out how long team Schiff had been colluding with either whistleblower before Schiff made the whistleblowing claims public.