The requested article has expired, and is no longer available. Any related articles, and user comments are shown below.
© Copyright 2023 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed without permission.India lands spacecraft near moon's south pole
By ASHOK SHARMA and KRUTIKA PATHI NEW DELHI©2024 GPlusMedia Inc.
29 Comments
Login to comment
Asiaman7
Geez! The live video was like a bad CGI version of the 1979 Atari arcade game Lunar Lander.
Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1FAe7sFGBEI
TaiwanIsNotChina
Good on India showing Russia how it is done.
UChosePoorly
Congrats India!
wallace
An amazing achievement by India.
EvilBuddha
In Buddhism, India is known as the 'land of the moon' and Japan is the 'land of the sun'.
So it had to happen that one day an Indian spacecraft would land on the moon.
As for the comments that 'India being a poor third world country should get its priorities right' that will soon come along, the mission cost only 75 million USD, less than the budget of a Hollywood movie.
2020hindsights
So India is more technologically advanced than Russia. No surprise there.
theFu
2nd attempt worked! Nice. Congratulations.
The live video was just of moon craters. The part showing the lander was for engineering purposes, with a 2-second latency for when the attitude control engines fired. It was for engineering visual representation.
Compared to the way India did launches a few years ago, the graphics was great. I wasn't worried that the raw data was lying. Loved the way they hovered for 10 sec at ~150m. That was impressive and showed good control.
TokyoLiving
Good for India..
Good for BRICS..
TokyoLiving
Russia will do it too, no need to whine..
EvilBuddha
Modi has just won a third term for himself.
But good that he did not steal all the limelight like he usually does and gave credit to the ISRO scientists and pioneers who made it possible.
And also thanks to NASA and ESA for providing tracking support to ISRO.
EvilBuddha
The mission shows both the strengths and weaknesses of India's space program.
Strengths being that India can do things cheaply, and no doubt its also an attempt to win business for any future planned unmanned missions to the moon by private entities or other countries.
Weakness being that Indian rockets are not powerful enough to carry heavy or super heavy payloads so ISRO has to employ some 'jugaad' by placing payloads in orbit and then gradually raising orbit to slingshot the payloads towards the moon.
2020hindsights
TokyoLiving
Good on India showing Russia how it is done.
I doubt it. Russia hasn't been a near peer for years.
Desert Tortoise
Good job India. A tip o' the hat.
puregaijin
yinyang128
Bravo India. Great achievement.
starpunk
Yes, congrats are in order.
It was inevitrable. They've been sending robot probes to impact the Moon just others before have done since the early - mid '60s. The next step is 'soft landings; by robot landers. Now India has thrown their hat into the lunar exploration ring and they've joined the community. Welcome to the club, India!
opheliajadefeldt
I do not know if this was a great achievement or what, I don't really care that much. But what is mans fascination with landing on the moon, am I missing something here? ps.....did anyone else notice that in the bottom picture it was all men cheering. Perhaps other women like me around the world are of my thoughts.
Strangerland
It was. It's extremely hard to break free of the gravity of earth, particularly with living things on board, and then to additionally land on an extraterrestrial mass... it's an amazing achievement of humanity.
Maybe the fact that it's been up there being looked at by humanity since... humanity? Have you never seen something and wondered what it was like up close? Are you in Japan - how did you end up there without this curiosity?
Jijitsu
Geez! The live video was like a bad CGI version of the 1979 Atari arcade game Lunar Lander.
..And what were you expecting to watch??? A visually graphic sci-fi??? Welcome to the reality..this is how real stuff looks.
I do not know if this was a great achievement or what, I don't really care that much. But what is mans fascination with landing on the moon, am I missing something here? ps.....did anyone else notice that in the bottom picture it was all men cheering. Perhaps other women like me around the world are of my thoughts.
Elon Musk is fascinated with colonizing Mars. The moon could be a better option.. since it has water. If not an option, it could give a lot of answers, which mankind would need when they move somewhere else, when Earth is no longer inhabitable
As for the men cheering.. if you look at their live video, you can see a lot of women scientists at ISRO. Scroll through this video and you will see a pretty good number of them.
https://www.youtube.com/live/VNvU37jqiWM?si=35gzZ7Bzko7hc9S4
mynihon23
Geez! The live video was like a bad CGI version of the 1979 Atari arcade game Lunar Lander.
Get a life. Embrace reality over virtuality.
mynihon23
Congratulations India. Your mission will definitely help NASA scientists working on Artemis moon mission. Its a win for entire humanity and betterment of world space program. Also wish Russia to learn from its shortcomings and achieve success in next attempt just like India.
TaiwanIsNotChina
When? All of their scientists have left and they need the parts to commit warcrimes in Ukraine.
Strangerland
As I understand it, India has a middle class larger than the population of America.
EvilBuddha
Well done India, now get people living in proper conditions.
Yeah more Indians coming to the US to live in 'proper' conditions.
Better vote Trump if you don't want it to happen.
Dr.Cajetan Coelho
Hearty congratulations. Indian scientists and their allies are doing fine.