The requested article has expired, and is no longer available. Any related articles, and user comments are shown below.
© 2022 AFPIran general says more than 300 dead in Amini unrest
TEHRAN©2024 GPlusMedia Inc.
The requested article has expired, and is no longer available. Any related articles, and user comments are shown below.
© 2022 AFP
6 Comments
Login to comment
virusrex
The video do not say she was not beaten, it only shows she was still able to walk and talk, anything other than that is just you making assumptions. The witness are not the only argument that says she was mishandled, the own government of Iran is the one giving contradictory stories to "explain" her death.
They can and do, not all injuries are incapacitating before death, a brain hemorrhage for example can have only mild symptoms before suddenly being able to put in risk the life of the victim. Without an authority looking at the body (something Iran is not letting happen) you have no argument except that you believe the video says something.
No, as it has happened since always, because sudden death is something that happens, specially for people that have been subjected to violence recently as the accusations say in her case.
Raw Beer
Yeah, you can either believe the eyewitness who said she was severely beaten on her way to the briefing class, or the video that clearly shows she was not severely beaten prior to her collapse. People with serious injuries usually don't walk as if nothing happened and then talk about their clothing. She looked perfectly fine until she suddenly collapsed, as has happened to many people for the past two years.
virusrex
All this under policy custody, and under accusations of being abused while in transport. This means her death comes in the best case scenario under the responsibility of the police, and if the testimony of witness believed as a direct consequence of abuse.
No evidence whatsoever for any of those things, specially no injection of any kind, much less of anything related to being in a coma for two days afterward, unless your argument is that she was poisoned by the police.
No, you can see she appears fine, which is something completely different. People can have serious injuries that will not be evident in a few seconds of video that could cost them their lives. The conficting evidence released by the Iranian government and the opposite declarations of witness and family of the victim point are the reasons why the population do not trust the official position.
Raw Beer
She was arrested and was apparently expected to undergo a "briefing class" and released an hour later. Unfortunately, she suddenly collapsed while waiting in the classroom, and remained in a coma for 2 days in hospital.
It seems she had a preexisting condition, or perhaps she got an injection prior to visiting Tehran...
If you actually look at the video, you'll see that she was fine prior to suddenly collapsing:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wku5TCIghDg
virusrex
Because she died under the responsibility of the police, custody comes with it.
Are you arguing that she had a congenital or preexisting condition that was completely unrelated to the treatment she got for 3 days under police custody (as the people in videos)? do you have any evidence to support this?
Raw Beer
Why are they protesting for this? Iran quickly released the video, where you can see her walk into a waiting room. She looked perfectly fine as she was chatting with two other women about her clothing, and then she suddenly collapsed. It looked very much like the many videos we can see online of certain people collapsing.