The requested article has expired, and is no longer available. Any related articles, and user comments are shown below.
© Copyright 2023 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed without permission.McCarthy's last-ditch plan to keep U.S. government open collapses, making a shutdown almost certain
By LISA MASCARO, KEVIN FREKING and STEPHEN GROVES WASHINGTON©2024 GPlusMedia Inc.
92 Comments
Superlib
They need to pass a separate bill immediately to make sure our soldiers will be paid. They cannot be sacrificed.
Kurumazaka 2
Blah blah Libs. Blah blah establishment. Blah blah swamp.
its everyone’s fault except noble flawless MAGA patriots who are utterly blameless in their mission to punish normal people on behalf of their lord and master in Mar a Lago.
a pox on your house
EFD
The Cult Reps in the GQP caucus saying that “It’s no big deal. Everyone will get back pay.”
No, not everyone. Service workers on hourly contracts will not get back pay (they tend to be “less well-off”).
In addition student loans will not get processed. Govt subsidized day care will close. (I guess all those women should have thought about that before the got pregnant, eh?)
There are a whole host of other effects that will not be mitigated by back pay IN ADDITION to the fundamental callousness of saying to career civil servants, soldiers, ATC, etc. “Just work like an indentured servant.”
The GQP fundamentally sucks at govt.
Next election cycle, the voters are going to put the adults back in charge.
ok1517
Those hard-headed Repubs / MAGAs should get their act straight!
This is once again sabotaging - all they're so good at.
I'm glad to see that at least some of the Republicans know what they're doing!
https://bipartisanreport.com/2023/09/29/340-house-members-vote-down-marjorie-taylor-greene-back-ukraine/
Peter Neil
A government shut down about nothing, except ensuring the defeat of Republicans at the polls.
Yubaru
Looks like the "word of the day" for the writers here is "flank"! Oh and it's incorrectly being used here as if they truly were on his "flank" they would be working in conjunction with him, and not against him!
It's more like they have broken off and decided to do things on their own!
EFD
And in the end, the Ukrainian defense funding bill passed with overwhelming bipartisan support.
So the goobers don’t get their scalp, Kevin is about to become the biggest ninny ever to sit in the chair, even briefly, the GQP takes it in the shirts, and America normalizes dysfunction as government policy because a few goobers just want to watch the country burn.
bass4funk
Now the left cares?? Funny?
That is the service industry for sure.
Hopefully.
They are already doing that, I’m surprised liberals are so adamant about the well-being of civil servants when the very people push for more money to be sent to Ukraine and other countries overseas.
They suck had holding the line, some are, but others need to join in.
Doubt it. They may hate a shutdown, but they know of Dems control the purse, spending will further drive the nation into unrecoverable debt. The rest of the nation doesn’t want to look like California or NYC.
wallace
It will be the second time the GOP shut down the government recently.
Cards fan
Who could have imagined electing rightwing nutjobs who hate the government to run said government would turn out so bad?
dagon
Gaetz, MTG and other Republicans do not mind gorging at the public trough like their proverbial entitlement welfare queens with subsidies and loan forgiveness when the opportunity presents itself, for example during the pandemic.
https://www.statesman.com/story/news/politics/politifact/2022/09/06/fact-check-ppp-loans-forgiven-republicans-matt-gaetz-marjorie-taylor-greene/65470173007/
But become tight-fists when it comes to the public taking part in government welfare.
Their whole position is a sham to give a boost to Trump.
gkamburoff
Republicans: Absolute incompetence.
Strangerland
And Trump lost after he shut it down last time.
Not that they even actually agree he lost.
gkamburoff
Real clowns work together.
These are phonies.
bass4funk
In the Senate, Not by the majority of Americans that want funding of Ukraine to stop.
https://edition.cnn.com/2023/08/09/politics/white-house-responds-cnn-poll/index.html
Neither the rest of the nation that wants this spending to stop.
I disagree, I think Kevin will go down as the man who desperately tried to keep his promise to his constituents and that is a good and noble thing. I applaud him for trying. He’s definitely and thankfully not a Ryan or Boehner, thank God!
bass4funk
It has been for years.
Strangerland
The majority of Americans don't want funding to stop.
lincolnman
So once again, we have the Freedom Caucus VOTING WITH Nancy, Schiff, Nadler, Swalwell, etc., to defeat and humiliate their fellow Repubs and Speaker...
So by praising the Freedom Caucus "for standing up", our MAGA-friends here are praising all these "Libs" also...
Team Blue thanks you...
Having been in the military during these various shut-downs, I can tell you first-hand it has a major impact on the young troops, especially those with a family, who live paycheck to paycheck. It's inexcusable what these Repubs are doing to these heroes...
Like taking a page from Boehner and Ryan...and quitting...
Google "impotent" and "emasculated" and a picture of McCarthy pops up...
Ben P. Dosanko
Good. Shut it down.
EFD
Not everyone who recognizes goober stupidity is “Left” and yes, because they’re actual human beings suffering actual tangible effects from GQP incompetence and I difference.
The MAGA cult “Screw those lazy government bureaucrats “ sure as hell doesn’t. Because MAGA doesn’t care about anything beyond their narrow self-interests.
EFD
Again as demonstrably incorrect as you are wrong.
Passed the House at about midnight JST 320 something to less than 200.
And the majority of Americans stand with Ukraine it’s just the majority of the cult you call a part that doesn’t
Superlib
You're about to get your shutdown. Own it and cheer for the harm you will do to hard working Americans.
Remember, your ideology is more important than their mortgage payments and child care.
bass4funk
True, but the majority who think so are though.
Gosh man, I wish you felt like that when the Dems were spending our money as if it came out of Niagara Falls.
No, stop the Dems from out of control frivolous spending and stop sending our money overseas, we have enough people that need it and rightfully deserve it.
Chico3
Of course he's going to try to keep it open. His job is on the line and he's walking a tight rope.
wallace
The Republicans made an agreement back in May and now because of a small group of right-wingers.
Chico3
Man! It's just been one big circus on the US taxpayers' dime. Those who can vote, remember this. It's not what a Party says. It's what it does.
Bob Fosse
Hard to believe some here were excited about the new dawn of Kevin and his pursestrings. “We’ve got the House”. Must be such a disappointment.
EFD
Matt and his fellow loonies are mad that the country didn’t default in the summer and that a bipartisan agreement was reached with top line numbers established.
They’re trying to renege on the deal.
They’re going to fail.
lincolnman
And these Repubs who joined with Nancy, Schiff, Nadler and Swalwell were;
Rep. Andy Biggs, R-Ariz., Rep. Dan Bishop, R- N.C., Rep. Lauren Boebert, R-Colo., Rep. Ken Buck, R-Colo., Rep. Tim Burchett, R-Tenn., Rep. Eric Burlison, R-Mo., Rep. Michael Cloud, R-Texas., Rep. Eli Crane, R-Ariz., Rep. Matt Gaetz, R-Fla., Rep. Paul Gosar, R-Ariz., Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene, R-Ga., Rep. Wesley Hunt, R-Texas., Rep. Nancy Mace, R-S.C., Rep. Mary Miller, R-Ill., Rep. Cory Mills, R-Fla., Rep. Alex Mooney, R-W.V., Rep. Barry Moore, R-Ala., Rep. Troy Nehls, R-Texas., Rep. Andy Ogles, R-Tenn., Rep. Matt Rosendale, R-Mont., Rep. Keith Self, R-Texas.
So MAGA-heroes Gaetz, MTG, Boebert, Gosar, ei al, all chose to vote WITH Nancy and Schiff and all the other "Libs" instead of their own fellow Repubs - and voted with the Dems to sink a bill sponsored and indorsed by their own Repub Leader....
Bass: This is the second time your MAGA-heroes have sided with the Libs over their own party....
What do you think about that? You agree with them siding WITH Nancy AGAINST Kevin? Or are they traitors to their own party?
wallace
Tick tock.
plasticmonkey
MAGA world does not care one ounce for the nation’s wellbeing. It is a nihilistic cult that lives for petty urges toward grievance and retribution. As for the cult leader Himself, he cares about himself only.
virusrex
Sad to see the US becoming more and more an example of the negative aspects of having a democracy, unfortunately this government is only a symptom of the deep problems of the society that elected it.
bass4funk
That’s ok, I just did
They’re mad at Democrats, not the country.
They should
Not really, at least if it doesn’t go well people will see he was serious about cuts. That goes a long way for any Republican.
We do, this administration and the DNC do not and have not for decades. Look at the cities that they run, not one single Democrat would live in any of these areas where thugs run around robbing and looting and defying the rule of law.
Probably and justifiably
If that were true then he wouldn’t run. Got enough money and doesn’t need the grief and headaches.
Peter Neil
I don’t know about you, but I’m sick and tired of theatrics.
The US needs term limits now. Go to Washington DC to serve for a few years, doing the best for the nation and people, not to fulfill your ego and bank account.
lincolnman
As bad as this shutdown is for MAGA-world and the Repubs, there was even worse news today;
Scott Hall, one of 19 defendants charged in the 2020 election interference case in Georgia, reached a plea agreement with prosecutors Friday, making him the first defendant in the case to do so.
Media outlets report that Hall pleaded guilty before Judge Scott McAfee to five misdemeanor counts of conspiracy to commit intentional interference with the performance of election duties.
https://www.yahoo.com/news/trump-co-defendant-agrees-plea-202005586.html
Hall is one of the culprits who were going to break into the election office in Coffee County Georgia to tamper with voting machines....and he is now a cooperating witness for the prosecution...
So Fani Willis just got her first "win" - and a witness to testify that Trump and his cabal of kooks planned to plant fake evidence of fraud on voting machines....
Now that he has flipped, who is next? Powell? Rudy who can't pay his current lawyers? Meadows?
Just as in every other Trump criminal case, his own rats are turning on him...
GBR48
If this barnpot way of running the country is how it is, pass a succession of individual funding bills well in advance. Don't have an all-or-nothing, handbags-at-dawn squabble at the last minute. It's embarrassing. Putin and Xi must be having a good laugh over this.
dagon
https://www.statesman.com/story/news/politics/politifact/2022/09/06/fact-check-ppp-loans-forgiven-republicans-matt-gaetz-marjorie-taylor-greene/65470173007/
Who paid for MTG and Gaetz' forgiven loans?
Scroll up MAGA mind.
lincolnman
*So MAGA-heroes Gaetz, MTG, Boebert, Gosar, ei al, all chose to vote WITH Nancy and Schiff and all the other "Libs" instead of their own fellow Repubs - and voted with the Dems to sink a bill sponsored and indorsed by their own Repub Leader....*
Bass: This is the second time your MAGA-heroes have sided with the Libs over their own party....
*What do you think about that? You agree with them siding WITH Nancy AGAINST Kevin? Or are they traitors to their own party?*
Bass, still waiting...
TaiwanIsNotChina
We need to focus on the important question: what will the shutdown be called? I'm torn between the "MAGA Mischief Meltdown" and the "Crazy Time Cop-out".
Asiaman7
@Strangerland
The data doesn’t support your skewed view — once again.
—
CNN Poll: Majority of Americans oppose more US aid for Ukraine in war with Russia
August 4, 2023
Most Americans oppose Congress authorizing additional funding to support Ukraine in its war with Russia, according to a new CNN poll conducted by SSRS.
Overall, 55% say the US Congress should not authorize additional funding to support Ukraine vs. 45% who say Congress should authorize such funding. And 51% say that the US has already done enough to help Ukraine while 48% say it should do more.
EFD
The “I got mine. Screw everyone else” Caucus is driving this. They’ll rightly be blamed, first by their unfortunate fellow GQP reps, then by the general electorate.
EFD
It’s not “playing” dumb.
bass4funk
No and No.
Desert Tortoise
Until 2008 it required a 2/3 majority in each house of the California State Legislature to pass the annual appropriations bill. While Democrats held majorities in both houses they didn't hold supermajorities. This allowed a minority of Republicans to make demands for legislation that would never get considered otherwise. Funding reductions to Programs despised by Republicans and anti-immigrant measures featured heavily in these demands. The resulting stalemates led to annual government shut downs, some lasting a month or more. This went on for years until a ballot initiative in 2006 or 2008 changed the State Constitution to allow appropriations bills to pass on a simple majority. There was another piece of legislation that prevented legislators from being paid if the appropriations bills were late. From 2008 onward California had on time budget bills with surpluses.
A corollary effect was the disgust most Californians had for the Republicans and their annual budget blackmail led to their political demise in the state. Now both houses of the State Legislature have Democratic supermajorities and there hasn't been a Republican holding any statewide office since Arnold Schwarzenegger. Credit Republican intransigence and their my way or the highway attitude in the Legislature. The did it to themselves. It may be that the Republicans do it to themselves on a national level. This sort of thing seems to be in their blood. No tolerance for compromise. That doesn't work in an elected representative government.
Simon Foston
Oh for goodness sake. If there's a funding package that a majority of legislators can get behind then they should put aside party affilation and vote for it. Then the hard-core diehards on either side of the political spectrum would be irrelevant.
konjo4u
This will cause even more borrowing to pay down debt. The bills do not stop just because the congress shuts down the workforce. There are still rent payments, contractual obligations over many years already requiring monthly installments, etc. Except this time the interest will be higher.
The former guy's airplane is on the ground in Los Angeles while he sleeps soundly with the libs. He did not do that with his supporters in Michigan earlier this week or with his supporters in Iowa earlier this month. Nope, he was in and out. But this weekend he sleeps in LA.
Desert Tortoise
The Executive Vice President of the Chamber of Commerce Charlie Sykes is calling it the "Seinfeld Shutdown because it's a shutdown about nothing".
Desert Tortoise
How so? Taxes will still be remitted. The Fed is off budget, financed from deposits by the banks it regulates and operates independently. Other than a possible downgrade in the nation's credit rating leading to higher interest rates on future bonds I don't see the effect you describe.
EFD
First it was “fund the border wall or we’ll shut the government down!”
Now it’s “Give up Ukraine and MAYBE we will keep the lights on.”
Nah, the bipartisan sanity caucus isn’t giving into the goobers.
And they don’t get to use one program as a fig leaf for their utter incompetence at basic governance.
Desert Tortoise
My concern is that there is a move to end Mr. McCarthy's speakership by Matt Gaetz or one of his cohorts but nobody emerges from the maelstrom of Republican House politics who can command enough votes to replace Mr. McCarthy. Absent a speaker nothing else can be accomplished. I worry this may happen. IT seems to me a vote on the Senate CR is the obvious solution but Mr. McCarthy won't allow it, knowing House Democrats would vote in favor of it and nothing that is likely to come out of the Republican House caucus is likely to pass in the Senate much less be signed into law by the President. I think the situation is worse than most realize. I have seen stalemates like this in the California Legislature last more than a month with state employees furloughed, Highway Patrol and courts working without pay and various vendors and contractors going unpaid. State employees and even contractors were begging stores to accept IOUs until the state passed a budget and they could get paid.
lincolnman
In almost every post Bass accuses the "Dems" of free spending like a "Tony Montana Coke Addict"....
Yet 25 of his MAGA heroes in the Freedom Caucus VOTED WITH THE FREE SPENDING DEMS to defeat a Repub-sponsored bill...
One thing Bass is very clear on - he hates Pelosi, Schiff, Nadler, Swalwell, et al, for impeaching his Ultra MAGA King - twice...
Yet his MAGA-heroes colluded with these hated Dems to stiff and humiliate their fellow Repubs...
Bass, so what do you think of your heroes siding with your "Lib" enemies and Team Blue over Team Red?
EFD
I vote for “Asinine Arsonists shutdown” because some sociopaths just want to watch things burn.
Simon Foston
Desert TortoiseToday 10:11 am JST
Is it absolutely impossible for a speaker to be elected with bipartisan support? It seems to me that in other countries that's what coalitions are for.
Simon Foston
lincolnmanToday 10:11 am JST
I suppose the excuse will be is that they're representing their constituents and that's a good thing. I daresay the fact that Democrats also voted against the bill is just neither here nor there.
But he was acquitted twice by the GOP Senate majorities. Hooray for politicised justice!
Except deflection, obfuscation, waffle or "I already answered that."
stormcrow
What do you call a bunch of pinheads that can’t find their way out of a paper bag?
The Republican Party.
plasticmonkey
Let me guess. “Scroll up. I already answered that.”
EFD
I like the part where Manu Raju asked him back in the beginning “Do you have the votes to be elected speaker?” Yes. “How do you know?”
My Kevin stops and does his best Mussolini tough guy pose and says, “Because I can count.” and walks on.
LOL. Apparently he don’t count so good.
Simon Foston
plasticmonkeyToday 10:27 am JST
I wonder how many hours of scrolling it would take to find the answer. I have better things to do with my day, personally. Spending several hours staring at wallpaper springs to mind.
EFD
There may be a side issue at stake under the radar.
The Ethics Committee has re-opened the Matt Faetz child sex-trafficking investigation (Under GOP leadership no less!)
Venmo-boi maybe angling for an end to that as a price for his vote.
Even in the alternate reality known as the “Great” state of Florida, being a kiddie-diddling sex-trafficker isn’t a good look, especially when the kiddie diddler wants to run for Governor.
Jimizo
The GOP are completely dysfunctional.
EFD
I disagree. They’d have to make significant improvements to be merely “dysfunctional.”
This is “Bi-polar and off meds”-level incompetence.
plasticmonkey
@bass
Care to explain why you’re looking forward to government subsidized day care getting shut down?
bass4funk
No matter how many times you asked me that question, I already gave you an answer to that.
What is it with you guys today? Lol
As I told you before, people are getting tired of our money, going everywhere, else except back into the nation, and to take care of the nations problems, if the Dems would be taken care of the homelessness that they have created as well as the open borders they push for and cut more of the lavish entitlements and reckless spending, I would definitely be more persuadable to push for not shutting down the government, but I have never met a liberal that didn’t love attacks, so I don’t think that’s going to happen, but as I always say it’s not their money, so why would they care?
bass4funk
Not nearly as incompetent or ethically and morally dysfunctional as the DNC or this administration.
Gaetz, that’s his name, no need for confusion.
And?
Doubt it.
The real world. Save haven from the liberal Lunacy that has engulfed and partially destroyed the West and East Coast states
So far they weren’t able to prove anything, unlike another politician that carried gold bars in his jacket. Probably trying for another witch hunt.
EFD
Noise and deflection from a nihilistic cult. Nothing more.
dagon
Yes, he was mentioned with his opposition to "entitlements and reckless spending and student loan forgiveness.
While having PPP loans forgiven.
https://www.businessinsider.com/white-house-rips-republicans-over-ppp-loans-student-loan-forgiveness-2022-8
Same with MTG.
Regurgitating Tea Party boilerplate does not mask these contradictions.
bass4funk
Yes, always keep your promise.
Also they voted against spending cuts. Again, not their money, so….
Yup!!!!
No, you’re just angry, because you got tongue tied, and in the worst of the famous Funkmaster, Bootsy Collins, “if you fake the funk, your nose will grow.”
EFD
Indeed. The GQP caucus reached a bipartisan deal on the debt ceiling with the Administration on top-line numbers. Now they’re trying to renege on the deal.
Bob Fosse
Are they rinos?
plasticmonkey
Government subsidized day care is domestic spending. To “take care of the nation’s problems”.
Again, why are you against that?
(Since you haven’t answered yet.)
theFu
It takes two sides to fail in negotiations. If they won't govern, they aren't fit for office. Hold them all accountable at the polls. Never vote for the incumbent. When they are all gone, finally, they will get the message - Dem/Rep - doesn't matter. DC smells bad and always does.
Simon Foston
bass4funkToday 11:09 am JST
Well wasn't that predictable.
So neither here nor there.
So you'd be cool with a Democrat Senate majority acquitting Biden of things he was actually 100% guilty of, right?
plasticmonkey
Since the MAGA fringe is against govt subsidized day care, why should it care about child sex trafficking?
Superlib
Current FoxNews.com headline:
"Biden administration issues restrictions on gas furnaces in latest war on appliances"
Busby
Oh come on - that poor excuse died days ago.
Your MAGA-heroes in the Freedom Caucus have thrown-in with the "Libs" against their own party.
MTG, Gaetz, Boebert, Gosar all sided and voted with Nancy and Schiff rather than your own Repubs...they stood with the Libs in shooting down a Repub bill.
Why did they turn on their own party and clasp hands with the Libs?
They are voting with the Libs helping make your fellow Repubs look weak and defeated - and McCarthy impotent. Why?
bass4funk
If the shoe fits…
You really wouldn’t know, really
Well, of course they would. Just like they did with Bill Clinton, so I wouldn’t expect any different if it were a Republican President with the charges were valid or political.
Superlib
All excellent reasons why out troops shouldn't get paid.
bass4funk
Scroll up, I belabored the reason
I think you’re overdoing and embellishing the issue a tad, not like that, but I get why they are doing it even if I don’t agree with it.
bass4funk
Now the left care about the troops, wish they did so 2 years ago, a lot of lives wouldn’t have been lost.
EFD
It has not clue one as to the components of GDP.
It doesn’t care.
Busby
It seems that our Freedom Caucus friends not only vote with the Libs, they collude and conspire with them against their own party as well.
*With the clock ticking down toward a government shutdown, Republican Rep. Matt Gaetz approached a Democratic lawmaker on the House floor this week with a surprising pitch.*
Gaetz, who has been threatening Speaker Kevin Mcarthy’s speakership almost daily, explained that his rebellion is motivated by a desire to find new leadership that keeps their word, tells the truth, and adheres to regular order – a message that this Democrat described to CNN as “utterly reasonable.”
*Gaetz then floated veteran Republican Rep. Tom Cole of Oklahoma and House GOP Whip Tom Emmer of Minnesota as two alternative examples he had in mind, and *then attempted to gauge whether this member would be open to supporting an effort to oust McCarthy.
https://www.yahoo.com/news/gaetz-war-against-mccarthy-could-215700209.html
I wonder what our MAGA-posters here think of that - inviting and teaming with the Libs to kick out their own Repub Speaker.
Isn't that called "conspiring with the enemy"?
Busby
Where? Which post? Be specific pls.
Really? What do you call your heroes voting with your hated Libs against your own party? And if you "get it", then explain it to the rest of us.
bass4funk
Same here
I want them to get paid, but more important, I want to Democrats to cut spending.
TaiwanIsNotChina
There are going to be a lot more lives lost if Russia touches the Baltics or China touches Taiwan thanks to your eagerness to surrender.
bass4funk
For the record of civil discourse, please refer to me as “he or him” not “it” I’m not an in adamant object.
Thanks
TaiwanIsNotChina
So extorting the American people is more important than the troops getting paid. I can see how Republicans keep lowering our country's credit rating.
wallace
bass4funk
Shame you didn't believe that during the Trump term who outspent Biden so far.
Jimizo
You excused out of control spending under Trump as necessary.
Just to be clear, you don’t disagree with out of control spending in principle.
It’s not a fiscal conservatism thing, right?
dagon
There is nothing adamantine about you or the Freedom Caucus.
They have government loans forgiven costing the taxpayer, yet oppose the same for students and the working class.
Their values of fiscal responsibility are gelatinous in fact.
bass4funk
So whatever happened to Europe? I’m sorry, let them deal with it, then in the end, if they do need our help, it should be very, very limited, then no problem.
I already told you specifically.
Republicans
Again, scroll up.
And now Biden has surpassed that. $3 trillion last year and by the end of next year $4.8 trillion, as a total we are already at $31 trillion that this guy added. So yeah, Joe takes the cake on that one.
bass4funk
Hmmm
We usually pay ours. I feel like this if you can’t afford to go to college, then get a job and pay your own way or get a loan, but only do that if you know you can pay it back.
To the Dems?
After Obama, failed and depleted our military, yes, because I didn’t want a beefed up military
I do, especially in this situation, to be clear
Actually, it is.
Jimizo
Can you back this up?