The United Auto Workers Union said on Tuesday it has filed charges with the National Labor Relations Board against Donald Trump and Tesla CEO Elon Musk over attempts to threaten and intimidate workers.
The action came after Musk and Trump held a two-hour conversation on social media platform X on Monday night, during which Trump complimented Musk's ability to cut costs by saying he would not tolerate workers going on strike.
"You're the greatest cutter," Trump said during the conversation. "I mean, I look at what you do. You walk in, you just say: 'You want to quit?' They go on strike - I won't mention the name of the company - but they go on strike. And you say: 'That's okay, you're all gone.'"
Musk chuckled but did not respond to Trump's comments, making it harder for the NLRB to find him liable for making illegal threats to workers at his companies, said Wilma Liebman, chair of the NLRB under former President Barack Obama.
Under federal law, workers cannot be fired for going on strike, and threatening to do so is illegal under the National Labor Relations Act, the UAW said in a statement.
It is unclear whether the NLRB would take action against Trump for his comments, but the UAW jumped on his remarks as it continues to rally behind Democratic presidential candidate and Vice President Kamala Harris and encourage its nearly 400,000 workers to vote for her over Trump, especially in battleground states like Michigan that could determine who wins the White House in November. The UAW is based in Michigan and has many members in that state.
The UAW endorsed Harris at the end of July. She met with union officials and workers last week near Detroit.
UAW President Shawn Fain and Trump have exchanged barbs in the past.
"Both Trump and Musk want working class people to sit down and shut up, and they laugh about it openly. It’s disgusting, illegal, and totally predictable from these two clowns," Fain said in a statement on Tuesday.
The Harris and Trump campaigns did not immediately respond to requests for comment. Musk also did not respond to a request for comment.
Trump has called for the union leader to be fired, saying he is responsible for U.S. auto manufacturing becoming weaker.
UAW members in Michigan tend to side with Democrats, but pro-Trump workers have organized their own rallies in recent weeks to show their support for the former president.
The NLRB has limited power to punish unlawful labor practices. In cases involving illegal threats, the board can order employers to cease and desist from such conduct and to post notices in the workplace informing workers of their rights. Unions can also use favorable rulings from the NLRB to engage workers they are trying to organize.
"It's trying to expose more than anything politically what Donald Trump is about in terms of workers, and Musk as well," former NLRB head Liebman said, referring to the UAW's action on Tuesday. "Everyone knows the NLRB remedies are toothless to start with, but it's not so much for the remedy as for sending both a political message and an organizing message."
Fain filed separate complaints against Musk and Trump with the NLRB, claiming both men had made statements suggesting they "would fire employees engaged in protected concerted activity, including striking." The complaints did not provide further detail.
The UAW led a six-week strike against Detroit's Big Three automakers last autumn, in which workers at Ford Motor, General Motors and Jeep maker Stellantis walked picket lines across the country.
The union won record contracts, which included a 25% general wage increase over the life of the agreement.
Musk, who has endorsed Trump for president, has had numerous run-ins with the labor board. His rocket company SpaceX is currently challenging the entire structure of the agency in a pair of pending lawsuits. Those cases stemmed from NLRB complaints accusing SpaceX of firing engineers who were critical of Musk and forcing employees to sign severance agreements with unlawful terms.
In March, a U.S. appeals court upheld an NLRB decision that said Musk illegally threatened Tesla employees by tweeting in 2018: "Nothing stopping Tesla team at our car plant from voting union ... But why pay union dues & give up stock options for nothing?"
Tesla is separately facing allegations from the board that it illegally discouraged unionizing at a Buffalo, New York, plant. Last year, an appeals court threw out a labor board decision that said Tesla broke the law by barring factory workers from wearing UAW T-shirts.
Lawyers at the labor board will investigate the union's claims and decide whether to issue formal complaints against Tesla and the Trump campaign. Those cases would be heard by administrative judges whose decisions can be reviewed by the five-member labor board and then federal appeals courts. The process often takes years.
© Thomson Reuters 2024.
52 Comments
PTownsend
Those two titans of corporatocracy want a country where workers have even fewer rights, and given the corrupt Supreme Court with its own corporatocracy bias, the US under Trump/Vance backed by the globe's wealthiest might shift even farther to the right to become a nation that looks like what Mussolini and the little Austrian corporal wanted in the 1930s. The US decided during the era of the robber barons that the Constitution should prevail and that the robber barons must not have complete control. Hopefully the US electorate, made up of lots of working people will see to it that the Musk/Thiel billionaire caste are reminded that workers want the few rights they have upheld and will vote against the GOP candidates.
TaiwanIsNotChina
Totally warranted. Make sure no union member votes for these losers.
Cards fan
The legality question aside, this was an incredibly stupid thing for Trump to say. Pro-labor my foot. Any laborers actually believe Trump and Musk care about them?
dagon
That any workers vote MAGA is a triumph of making the electorate vote against their economic interests in favor of fear-mongering, bigotry and religious fervor.
https://aflcio.org/press/releases/donald-trumps-catastrophic-and-devastating-anti-labor-track-record
And Musk should be ashamed since his professed inspiration, Iain Banks, was a strong supporter of Scottish Socialist Workers.
stormcrow
Evil people always support each other, that is their chief strength.
. . . Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn
Peter Neil
Cards fanToday 06:58 am JST
add it to the long list.
musk and trump act like robber barons of old.
PTownsend
I hope the cases do not make it to the Supreme Court, where justices appointed by Republicans have shown they are similar to Trump, who was just bought off by Elon X, and some justices have been for sale to the highest bidders. Given it's been the billionaire caste that has been buying off the justices, I fear the workers could get stiffed. Workers need to look out for their best interests, and that is rarely allowing the corporate bosses to get even richer, while the bosses want the workers to believe they will be trickled down on. Some corporatocracy extremists claim that it's the 'job creaters' that are paramount, forgetting the roles labor has always played in keeping economies going. But maybe some of the extremists have never had to actually work for a living, instead just lived off inheritance.
bass4funk
I think the problem is NOT with the union workers who are heavily Pro-Trump, but the Union leaders are the problem, so it is a bit misleading since they are more in the pockets of the Democrat party
Was, exactly. Anyone visiting Detroit should witness firsthand the impact of union demands on the domestic auto industry. The old Packard plant, in particular, is a stark example of the industry's decline, resembling a war-torn site. While the Big Three's downfall can be partly attributed to managerial arrogance, excessive union demands also played a significant role. Today, GM is often described more as a healthcare provider that happens to manufacture a few cars.
OssanAmerica
Harris' best weapon to garner votes is Trump's mouth.
Both Trump and Musk are not good for the country or the world.
bass4funk
Considering how the site blew up, I would disagree. This is one of the reasons why people cutting their cable and ditching their TV's for wanting to hear other voices, Youtube and X offers a variety of choices for obtaining information, we don't have to submit or be forced to listening to the one-sided partisan msm.
PTownsend
I would call it managerial and investor incompetence, and being out-competed by Japanese and German carmakers that understood what US car buyers wanted, and that was NOT the planned obsolesence of poorly engineered, gas guzzling US cars (called 'yank'' or 'septic tanks' by some) made by the Big 3. Face it the big 3 could not keep up with the times and were out-competed; reminder that Musk/Thiel and their billionare big tech brothers see 'competition as a negative, prefer monopolies instead.
bass4funk
Ok, so what does that have to do with what I said earlier about UAW Union leaders being beholden to the DNC?
Cards fan
They're not "beholden" to the DNC, but if they were you can hardly blame them when Trump (the GOP nominee) is openly cheering on the firing of striking workers.
burgers and beers
Gotta love that evil photo of Musk our good old unbiased Reuters came up with, LOL.
burgers and beers
Harris' best weapon to garner votes is Trump's mouth.
Fair point. Trump is not doing himself any favors with that.
dagon
This narrative that a MSM is controlled by lib leftists is peddled by corporate funded right-wing internet personalities peddling conspiracies.
The MSM is peddling a neo-liberal marketolatry and marginalizing real left wing voices like Sanders, as Noam Chomsky already explained in Manufacturing Consent.
https://chomsky.info/consent01/
Underworld
bass4funk
Meanwhile Musk’s Tesla salary is 56 billion. Don’t talk to me about excessive union demands.
Bob Fosse
So he’s lost the Black vote, the women’s vote, the young vote and now the blue collar worker.
How many angry white men are there? I don’t think it’s 80 million.
Bob Fosse
45 wants to take away your car and make you drive an ev. He’ll want you to stop eating red meat and give up your guns next. It’s a slippery slope.
bass4funk
The Union Leaders absolutely are.
Or when Biden lied to the coal miners and told them he would never close them down if they voted for him and what did he do on day one?
Doing better actually.
wallace
bass4funk
Remember when Trump made those big promises to the West Virginia coal miners in 2016? He told them he would protect their jobs, but he didn't follow through.
bass4funk
What insane liberal fantasy is this again? LOL
https://www.newsweek.com/heres-why-young-black-men-like-me-are-voting-trump-opinion-1936455
https://youtu.be/sD8CxDKjz4s?si=R_wmXlO_E8-t7ZBu
8% last time and 12% is just devastating for the DNC
Not really
If they come out and vote at all
What? No, not entirely for either side
https://rollcall.com/2024/02/05/lawmakers-see-blue-collar-voters-as-key-in-biden-trump-rematch/
Add to that, angry, Black and Latinos...
bass4funk
Ahh, the truth hurts and the left thought they were the smartest tool in the shed. Up the game.
That so many workers cringe of thinking about.
plasticmonkey
Right. And Biden didn't win in 2020, Harris' crowds are all AI generated, and Trump is waaaay ahead in the polls.
Tell me, you think workers should get less and Musk a lot more?
Sounds like it.
Cards fan
What does that have to do with Trump cheering on firing striking laborers? That's illegal, not that rightists care about breaking the law.
plasticmonkey
What a moron.
bass4funk
Yes, because he was bogged down by a hostile House that thwarted his agenda and the man was under a two-year investigation about a phony Russian collusion delusion hoax, how could we forget?
I'm not sure where you got that from, but if that doesn't seem like lib out of this galaxy telltale fantasy garbage, I don't know what is.
wallace
bass4funk
Remember when Trump made those big promises to the West Virginia coal miners in 2016? He told them he would protect their jobs, but he didn't follow through.
Trump's inability to multitask makes him unsuitable for the presidency. Following his election, he failed to address the concerns of coal miners.
u_s__reamer
Full speed ahead, Cap'n, to November's "Harris Iceberg" (unless Judge Merchan sinks him in September).
wallace
Remember when Trump made those big promises to the West Virginia coal miners in 2016? He told them he would protect their jobs, but he didn't follow through.
yes, just like bass4funk posted.
Bob Fosse
Republicans?
You don’t know, I see.
plasticmonkey
And yet he still had time to play 261 rounds of golf, tweet, and call in to his favorite tee-vee shows. What a multitasker!
bass4funk
Wrong he has been, it's like this, my kids can ask for anything they want, they can wish for anything they like, but if I don't give them any money they can't do squat, now they can find other ways to make it, but that involves more time and effort, same exact analogy. Trump did what he could given the circumstances.
Given what the Dems did, I understand and let's not forget, or should I say, the coal miners will never forget what Biden did, keep that in mind, they sure will this November.
Wichi
All leftists losing it, when , blinded by the democrats that don't even have any policies to share. KH stealing Trump's policies, Tim walz stolen valor, hiding the true about Biden issues, yeah , " cheap fakes", basing all their camping on identity politics..
Remember KH still the vice president,the border zar and she hasn't accomplished anything.
wallace
bass4funk
Trump's inability to multitask makes him unsuitable for the presidency.
You are comparing the Oval Office with the demands of your kids. You are the one posting Trump wasn't capable of multitasking.
Following his election, he failed to address the concerns of coal miners.
There are less than 40,000 coal miners left working. Will not affect the elections. Biden is no longer standing for election.
Wichi
MAGA- Trump 2024!
wallace
You cannot steal Trump's policies because he simply does not have any.
bass4funk
Yeah, the lazy diatribe is as effective as saying Hillary is a Republican. Lol!
That's the only comeback the left has? A bit old and worn out like everything else they keep throwing at the guy. Time for a new attack line, keep us posted.
bass4funk
Breaking down the analogy, yes.
No, I said, the opposite.
So screw them right? That comes out to 40,000 votes against Biden.
Then you don't know what you are talking about, even if it's 1/3 of that number, it could have devasting consequences for Harris in a general
Harris is, she is still aligned and attached to this admin. and he is still the current President, so it does play in.
wallace
bass4funk
You are comparing the Oval Office with the demands of your kids.
You are the one posting Trump wasn't capable of multitasking.
You didn't
"Yes, because he was bogged down by a hostile House that thwarted his agenda and the man was under a two-year investigation about a phony Russian collusion delusion hoax, how could we forget?"
There are less than 40,000 coal miners left working.
Did you get the memo Biden is not running?
Will not affect the elections.
I doubt 40,000 votes will decide the outcome of the election.
Biden is no longer standing for election.
bass4funk
As usual, you don't know, not surprised.
Tax Reform: Implemented the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017, which lowered corporate tax rates and provided tax cuts for individuals.
Deregulation: Focused on reducing federal regulations across various sectors, including environmental protections and financial regulations.
-Immigration:
Border Wall: Advocated for and began construction of a border wall between the U.S. and Mexico.
Travel Ban: Implemented travel restrictions on several predominantly Muslim countries.
Zero Tolerance Policy: Enforced strict measures on illegal immigration, including family separations.
-Trade Policy:
Tariffs: Imposed tariffs on various imports, particularly from China, as part of a broader trade war.
-USMCA: Renegotiated the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA), resulting in the United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement (USMCA).
-Foreign Policy:
"America First": Emphasized prioritizing American interests in foreign policy decisions.
-Withdrawal from Paris Agreement: Announced the U.S. would exit the international climate agreement.
-Healthcare:
Repeal and Replace: Sought to repeal the Affordable Care Act (Obamacare) and replace it with an alternative, though full repeal was not achieved.
-Judicial Appointments:
Appointed three Supreme Court Justices: Neil Gorsuch, Brett Kavanaugh, and Amy Coney Barrett.
-Criminal Justice Reform:
Signed the First Step Act, aimed at reforming the federal prison system and reducing recidivism.
-Military and Defense:
Increased defense spending and focused on modernizing the military.
-Economic Policies:
Promoted energy independence through deregulation of the oil and gas industry.
Emphasized job creation and economic growth through various policy initiatives.
bass4funk
I did
Harris is, Biden is still President, same ticket, same policies.
They absolutely will
1/3 can definitely have an impact and a large majority of these people will remember.
But Harris is
ClippetyClop
So his list of 'achievements' includes things that he didn't achieve? How very MAGA.
bass4funk
Yes, he got rid of that dreaded mandate, that was huge, thank you Mr. President.
ClippetyClop
Apparently not. Did you read what you posted?
"though full repeal was not achieved."
Try again, but do it better.
bass4funk
Yup! Sure did11
Always
https://www.brookings.edu/articles/six-ways-trump-has-sabotaged-the-affordable-care-act/
*Cut ACA subsidies to insurance companies offering coverage on the exchanges.** ACA proponents saw insurance company participation on the exchanges as central to fostering enrollee choice and to fueling competition that would lower premiums. The law therefore provided various subsidies to insurance companies to reduce their risks of losing money if they participated in the exchanges. The Trump administration joined congressional Republicans in reneging on these financial commitments.*
Thank God for that and that was without doubt the biggest problem. Why I need to pay for someone else's healthcare program.
John
This was a peak “Trump-stupid” thing to say to union workers.
Thanks for enough ad material for the rest of the campaign, “Sylvester”!
ClippetyClop
Because you live in Japan, therefore you have to.
Nice article though. As per usual, it disproves the thing that you were attempting to prove, because you didn't actually read it.
Trump failed to kill Obamacare because it was popular with the majority of states, as was Trump's firing in 2020.
Try again, but do it better.
wallace
bass4funk
I doubt 40,000 votes will decide the outcome of the election.
In 2020, Trump lost by 7 million votes in that historical Biden win.
ROFL
BINGO
bass4funk
Huh? How did Japan get into the conversation? You ok???
I did.
But he got rid of the subsidies mandate, don't need to try, the man did a service to the nation for that. Kudos.
bass4funk
1/3 can definitely have an impact and a large majority of these people will remember.
ROFL, funny!!!