The requested article has expired, and is no longer available. Any related articles, and user comments are shown below.
© 2022 AFPU.S. orders non-essential staff to leave Shanghai as virus surges
SHANGHAI©2024 GPlusMedia Inc.
The requested article has expired, and is no longer available. Any related articles, and user comments are shown below.
© 2022 AFP
23 Comments
Login to comment
Pukey2
And head back to the States where the virus is constantly on the surge. You might get sick or even die, but at least you'll have your freedom like the one million.
Aly Rustom
Generally, i am in favor of lockdowns to get the virus under control but what China is doing is just plain crazy
Addfwyn
If they want to leave, sure. But if they are truly concerned about their staff's well-being they wouldn't ask them to return to the country most heavily affected by the virus. Literally any other country on the planet would be better.
PerformingMonkey
Out of the frying pan, into the fire.
Wakarimasen
Lockdowns have so clearly worked around the world. And China is doing them with a vengeance. So we expect to see the virus disappear in China any day now.
GenHXZ
The US are very close to hitting 1,000,000 covid related fatalities. China is by no means perfect but it's a shame the US choose to use this situation for political theatrics.
PTownsend
No question the USA is dealing with serious problems. But re 'any other country', could You show results from Russia, or could Russia even allow results to be shown? Or does the Kremlin have to first approve the number to ensure they are appropriate for more propaganda. It would be good for the world to see whether Sputnik or whatever Putin's calling his vaccine has been effective. It would be good for Russia to admit it's part of the world, not just another gas station.
Happy Day
Pukey, no one's dying from Omicron. China's just doing its part to keep the fear alive.
PTownsend
Authoritarian states have rarely ever cared for their 'own' people. Authoritarians seem to think they 'own' people, and that seems to be what many people in those states want. And now many people even some living living in democracies are pushing for their nations to become more authoritarian, for example some are even supporting Russia's invasion of Ukraine, hoping for further Russian expansion.
Kumagaijin
Depends on what your definition of "worked" is. Do they help flatten the curve? Yes. Do they reduce the spread of Covid-19 in the long term? No! From the Guardian...
“We did serious harm to our children and young adults who were robbed of their education, jobs and normal existence, as well as suffering damage to their future prospects, while they were left to inherit a record-breaking mountain of public debt,” he argues. “All this to protect the NHS from a disease that is a far, far greater threat to the elderly, frail and infirm than to the young and healthy."
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2022/jan/02/britain-got-it-wrong-on-covid-long-lockdown-did-more-harm-than-good-says-scientist
Addfwyn
All of that information is publicly available, yes. Russia has had about 18M cases and 370,000 deaths. Pretty bad, one of the worst in the world actually. Their approach has not been particularly effective. Still better than the US, which was my point.
The only place we really don't have many details on is North Korea. Maybe they have the highest per capita rate of deaths in the world, we don't really know. It'd be surprising given how much more they have limited contact, even moreso than usual.
Happy Day
Lockdowns don't preserve health, but they do destroy economies and kids development. Here's proof from the U.S., showing lockdown States like New York and California faring poorly on COVID response: https://committeetounleashprosperity.com/final-report-card-on-state-responses-to-covid-19/
Addfwyn
@Happy Day
Your source is a hyper-free market pro capitalist think tank. They’d promote literally anything to increase income for the richest of the rich, regardless of human suffering.
Desert Tortoise
Your information is wrong. Europe is experiencing a major surge in Covid-19 cases.
https://www.msn.com/en-in/news/trendingtopics/we-are-seeing-as-much-as-15-million-cases-a-day-says-un-chief-amid-covid-19-spike-in-europe/ar-AAW2dWt
https://www.cnbc.com/2022/03/23/omicrons-subvariant-bapoint2-could-spread-wildly-in-europe-epidemiologist.html
We are starting to see the beginnings of one in the US too.
https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/philadelphia-restore-indoor-mask-mandate-case-surge-rcna23921
William Bjornson
"U.S. orders non-essential staff to leave Shanghai as virus surges"
"Shanghai Has Recorded More Than 130,000 Covid Cases—and No Deaths" -- WSJ, 10April2022
Other than in Hubei, where the virus is claimed to emerged and early on in the pandemic, deaths attributed to COVID infection in China have been amazingly low. Albeit much reason to doubt American statistics, certainly we will hear from same how "untrustworthy" China is and how we cannot depend upon their honest reporting and America, with the most expensive system almost inaccessible to millions of people, with the highest COVID death count of all, ranking from between 18th and 39th, depending on the data source, in overall quality of care, risk of death, and favorable outcomes, and "Capitalist Healthcare" known to be responsible for ~250,000 deaths by medical error per year...my advice to these 'staff' by all available data: IF YOU VALUE YOUR HEALTH AND SAFETY, STAY IN SHANGHAI!
Desert Tortoise
You have bad information. Of the 50 US states, California had the 15th lowest infection rate when measured by cases per 100,000 residents. For the most populous state in the US by a large margin it is a credible accomplishment.
https://www.statista.com/statistics/1109004/coronavirus-covid19-cases-rate-us-americans-by-state/
Desert Tortoise
Sigh. Half my family lives in Shanghai. When Mama is in the hospital the brothers their wives have to bring her food, change the sheets and such. We have to buy her medications no available to her in China and ship them there. It is often a struggle to get Mama health care. But this will frost your cookies. A couple of times I have been sick there and needed to use clinics and a hospital. Even in China, cash talks and no matter how full the waiting room was (there are no appointments for health care in China, everything is first come first served), if I had cash I went to the head of the line and was the doctor's next patient.
Btw, my sack still gets tight every time I replay the mental image of the children at the big Childrens Hospital of Fudan University having their blood drawn .... from their necks. Yeah, hold a toddler down and shove a needle in their neck while the child writhes and screams. I will never forget it.
ian
normal, as you said