world

Video of small boy saved from Aleppo rubble sparks social media storm

47 Comments

The requested article has expired, and is no longer available. Any related articles, and user comments are shown below.

© (c) Copyright Thomson Reuters 2016.

©2024 GPlusMedia Inc.

47 Comments
Login to comment

" Many are claiming the video was staged."

Joe, Bush, et al: Please define who is "Many". As is the Russian tradition, it's always a Western conspiracy when it doesn't look good, eh?

3 ( +6 / -3 )

Many are claiming the video was staged."

Last year, international sympathy for victims of Syria’s war was heightened by a photo of a drowned 3-year-old refugee from Syria, Aylan Kurdi, who washed up on a Turkish tourist beach

They said the same thing about Aylan too. He is very much dead. People just can't stomach these images. It makes the Russians and Assad look like murderers (which they are) and kills the west's right wingers' arugments which say we should ban refugees.

-3 ( +4 / -7 )

Poor kid. Life is just so monumentally cruel and unfair. I have a grandson about the same age, and this just rips my soul apart.

5 ( +5 / -0 )

How many children were killed in US air strikes in Afghanistan, Iraq and Libya and then they photos "spark social media storm" in the West? Zero, I think. Mainstream Western media? Zero. May be paulinusa et al can explain us this wonderful Western tradition.

-8 ( +0 / -8 )

How many children were killed in US air strikes in Afghanistan, Iraq and Libya and then they photos "spark social media storm" in the West? Zero, I think. Mainstream Western media? Zero.

Which photos? Those NEVER came out. The western media never showed them. But then again remember: during the Afghan and Iraq war, we didn't have social media. There was no youtube, twitter, or facebook, so it was easier to hide the images then. Not so today.

-1 ( +2 / -3 )

Arguing over bodycounts is never a position I've been in thankfully.

Shame on those of you have cheered on this miserable conflict. You know who you are...

2 ( +4 / -2 )

Those NEVER came out. The western media never showed them

Exactly. This is the point. It does not matter that in the last decade dozens (if not hundreds, who count them??) of thousands of people were killed by US / NATO military, a lot of them children, but the fact was not covered by the Western mainstream media, complete silence. But if there is even one smallest fact that just can be used in the propaganda war against Russia, then the Western media machine roars into action, supported by little helpers like paulinusa.

-8 ( +2 / -10 )

in the last decade dozens (if not hundreds, who count them??) of thousands of people were killed by US / NATO military, a lot of them children, but the fact was not covered by the Western mainstream media, complete silence. But if there is even one smallest fact that just can be used in the propaganda war against Russia, then the Western media machine roars into action,

wrong. The western media did not roar into action- social media did. That's why these 2 poor boys' stories got told. Not because of western, but because of social media.

Funny we didn't get any pictures from Fallujah.

Because there was no social media back then.

Poor kid. Life is just so monumentally cruel and unfair. I have a grandson about the same age, and this just rips my soul apart

Joe, I feel the exact same way. I myself am half syrian. my father was from Aleppo. My son is 10 months old and quite big for his age, and when he sleeps on his little tummy he reminds me of little Aylan. So this hits home really hard for me.

3 ( +6 / -3 )

The western media did not roar into action- social media did

Are you serious? Then who translated the stories of the victims into English and retell them so they can find their way into world stage, even to the Japan Today? This time it was Reuters. You call Reuters not Western media? And why stories of victims of US air strikes never got translated and retold?

-6 ( +3 / -9 )

Then who translated the stories of the victims into English and retell them so they can find their way into world stage, even to the Japan Today?

We're not talking about stories. What sparked the outrage were the images and videos of these 2 boys.

a picture speaks a thousand words. That's what happened. What do you need to translate about a little syrian boy drowned and washed up on a beach?

2 ( +4 / -2 )

Please note this phrase from the article:

The hashtag #Syrianboy was one of the top trending topics in the United States and Britain

And how this happened, who and why propelled the topic in the US and UK sosial media? I don't think usual social media users in US and UK follow Syrian news so closely.

-5 ( +2 / -7 )

And how this happened, who and why propelled the topic in the US and UK sosial media? I don't think usual social media users in US and UK follow Syrian news so closely.

Sure they do. Especially if they happen to be of Syrian dissent themselves. I follow Syrian news very closely and I live in Japan.

2 ( +5 / -3 )

Asakze : And how this happened, who and why propelled the topic in the US and UK sosial media? I don't think usual social media users in US and UK follow Syrian news so closely.

Shocking pictures of distressed and injured children tend to upset us in the West. Just like any Russian parent. Surely even you and your hopelessly one-sided patriotic agenda should be able to grasp this.

Talking about the Americans to hide your own atrocities simply isn't cutting it for the rest of us. This is your conflict. Like I said before, enjoy the blowback for this horrific conflict. Strategically that lone naval base is the prize, and Russia is willing to burn every Syrian to the last baby in order to keep it. Don't expect the rest of the world not to hold you accountable.

3 ( +6 / -3 )

Asakaze, I agree completely. The western/liberal media is extremely biased in what it reports and shows. Its amusing reading all the disingenuous apologetics from the so called progressives on this site.

-5 ( +2 / -7 )

Madverts- very very well said! Couldn't agree with you more! The Russians and the Syrian regime have a lot of blood on their hands

-1 ( +4 / -5 )

Asakaze, I completely agree with you on this.

-2 ( +3 / -5 )

Aly Rustom

Sure they do. Especially if they happen to be of Syrian dissent themselves

No, they do not. Most people in the West never heard about Aleppo and they won't be able to find Syria on the map. Only people of Syrian origin like you are really interested in the conflict. But the matter is that such people are a minority, and they can not make the subject a "top trending topic" as the Western propaganda machine is trying to do with it now.

Madverts

Shocking pictures of distressed and injured children tend to upset us in the West

Really?? Never noticed such sensitivity of the West during wars in Afghanistan, Iraq, Libya, or drone attacks in Pakistan. Seriously, how many shocking pictures of child victims of US / UK air strikes you've seen? "Surely even you and your hopelessly one-sided patriotic agenda should be able to grasp this".

Outrider,

I agree completely

Thanks! It's really regrettable that many media outlets became one-sided propaganda tools.

-2 ( +4 / -6 )

Asakaze : Really?? Never noticed such sensitivity of the West during wars in Afghanistan, Iraq, Libya, or drone attacks in Pakistan.

Then you have been living in a cave. But that isn't the case is it? I think you're willfully ignoring something that is easily proven. To say the USA has not been criticized by others in the West (fairly or unfairly) is the height of intellectual dishonesty. I thank you for that.

Like I said. Talking about other people's atrocities to hide your own is morally bankrupt. You Russians own this conflict and the bodycount. Enjoy your Iraq moment - no hurry though, you're going to be bogged down in Syria for quite some time.

0 ( +5 / -5 )

Madverts, Obama owns this conflict and hillary with him. They supported from the start and continue to support the radical Islamist insurgency intent on toppling the secular Assad government. Thank God for Putin and Russian support fro Assad against ISIS, Al Qaeda and the rest of the "freedom fighters".

0 ( +5 / -5 )

Madverts

I think you're willfully ignoring something that is easily proven.

The subject we're discussing is the role of (social) media in coverage of victims of war. My point: Western propaganda deliberately stresses the victims of war in Syria while completely ignoring the victims of war, waged by the West. Want to prove me wrong? Tell me how Western media cried for victims of US / UK air strikes, everything else is empty words. Or may be you want to say there were no children killed by US / UK bombs? "Then you have been living in a cave".

-2 ( +4 / -6 )

Rubbish.

Try reading The Guardian. Or any balanced news outlet for that matter. Your accusations are insane.

Screaming "look over there!!" isn't working. The only reason you're crying foul is because you're in Denial about the blood on Russian hands. Sorry about that.

0 ( +4 / -4 )

Madverts

Rubbish

Wow, very gentlemanly language! I presume you're out of arguments.

you're in Denial about the blood on Russian hands

And who you are to judge? After all the agressions during the last two decades the West not only has blood on its hands, you can swim in the blood of people it killed.

0 ( +4 / -4 )

Please keep the discussion civil.

0 ( +0 / -0 )

But if there is even one smallest fact that just can be used in the propaganda war against Russia, then the Western media machine roars into action

I think first target of Western media bashing is usually China, then second is Russia, followed by North Korea & Iran. Sometimes throw in the occasional gang rapes & open defecation issues in India for good measure.

-3 ( +0 / -3 )

No, they do not. Most people in the West never heard about Aleppo and they won't be able to find Syria on the map. Only people of Syrian origin like you are really interested in the conflict. But the matter is that such people are a minority, and they can not make the subject a "top trending topic" as the Western propaganda machine is trying to do with it now.

and why is there such an outrage over the pictures of the dead and the shellshocked boy? Your western hatred is starting to show. But it doesn't hide the fact that Russia has blood on its hands. I have some sad news for you: everybody knows where Aleppo is and everybody knows where Syria is. To think that after five years of one of the worst conflicts since World War II that people still don't know where Syria is is ridiculous

Talking about other people's atrocities to hide your own is morally bankrupt. You Russians own this conflict and the bodycount. Enjoy your Iraq moment - no hurry though, you're going to be bogged down in Syria for quite some time.

100% spot on

-2 ( +3 / -5 )

Aly Rustom

and why is there such an outrage over the pictures of the dead and the shellshocked boy

And why there were no outrage over the video where "moderate rebels" beheaded a boy simply because he was pro-Assad? The boy you're so worried about at least alive, and the boy on video is not. And the people who, as you claim, know well were Syria is, did nothing and said nothing on their social media. Why such selective compassion?

Madverts

You've yet to even present an argument

You're amusing. All my previous posts on the thread are my arguments. May I suppose you read them more carefully?

Some math for you. In Yugoslavia NATO bombs killed several hundred civilians, but that only for starters. In Afghanistan NATO killed dozens of thousands of civilians, several just for fun:

<https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maywand_District_murders >

And of course Iraq. According to WHO, just in three years, 2003-06, in Iraq were killed 150 thousands of civilians. Blood of all these people is on US / NATO. And after all these crimes that even Hitler can be proud of you try to judge other countries? Seriuosly?

My final argument: a convict from Pentonville may not play cop. NATO countries, until they atone they crimes, may not even critisize other countries. Period.

0 ( +4 / -4 )

Asakaze,

*>and why is there such an outrage over the pictures of the dead and the shellshocked boy

And why there were no outrage over the video where "moderate rebels" beheaded a boy simply because he was pro-Assad? The boy you're so worried about at least alive, and the boy on video is not. And the people who, as you claim, know well were Syria is, did nothing and said nothing on their social media. Why such selective compassion?*

Asakaze, You are speaking the truth. The so-called progressives on this site are in serious denial.

-1 ( +3 / -4 )

Same as the boy on the beach sadly it will ruffle some emotional feathers and everybody will have forgotten in a few weeks when the next kardashian photo comes out or Trump will say something stupid.

3 ( +3 / -0 )

And why there were no outrage over the video where "moderate rebels" beheaded a boy simply because he was pro-Assad? The boy you're so worried about at least alive, and the boy on video is not.

Aylan Kurdi drowned thanks to Russia and Assad. Who told you there isn't outrage? There is. But we are not going to deny that Russia is still a monster. That does not excuse their actions either.

The so-called progressives on this site are in serious denial.

Nope. You are just an apologist for a bloodthirsty regime. Congratulations

-1 ( +3 / -4 )

People really are in denial here. I'm an American, and Asakaze is the only one making any sense here. Sad that the others are so easily manipulated.

War is evil. Get it? Children suffer worse that anyone. And sawing off a child's head to a cheering crowd as the rebels did is infinitely worse than killing a child by bomb, if only in intent.

Everybody has innocent blood on their hands, the rebels, Assad, the Russians and the USA. If people think the answer is more war, then there will be more child victims. It's horrible. It's beyond horrible. Which is why emotions need to be kept in check when thinking what we can do to help (if anything). If emotions take hold, it's just more dead children.

There is blood on everybody's hands. Until one can admit that, they are just adding to the problem, not helping.

4 ( +4 / -0 )

There is blood on everybody's hands

That is true.

-3 ( +0 / -3 )

I suppose that because the Syria carnage is because of obamas and hillarys support and encouragement to the islamic "rebels" the progressives have to buy into it.

-1 ( +1 / -2 )

Nobody is buying into it. But remember who started the war. The situation would not be where it is today had not Assad decided to fire on unarmed protesters who were initially chanting silmeya silmeya peaceful, peaceful. The radicalization occured due to the brutality of the Assad regime. The protests started peaceful, turned into a secular uprising, and then morphed into a radical jihad. You cannot exclude the context in which these things occurred. Something caused the situation to morph into the brutality we see. That something was Assad. He didn't have to go down that route; but that's what he chose. And what neither he nor the Russians understand is that this civil war will not end until he is deposed. My prediction: we are looking at another 5 to 10 years of civil war in syria.

-3 ( +1 / -4 )

It's really sickening. Just look at "Before and After" pictures from Syria. All because a "leader" thought he should use heavy-handed "enforcement" against protestors. Thanks Assad... you idiot. Not that the US and other countries acted stupid in the follow up though. The idiocy that helped cause this mess is astounding.

0 ( +1 / -1 )

HD-couldn't have put it better myself.

-5 ( +0 / -5 )

Aly Rustom

The indiffirence with wich you reacted to the death of the boy, killed by "moderate terrorists" simply because he was pro-Assad, obviously demonstrates that your attitude towards opponents no softer then Assad's.

Russia intervened in the conflict in November 2015. Before that Assad had fought for five years, and despite all the help from US, Turkey, Saudi Arabia, Qatar etc to terrorists of all colors he kept fighting. Why? Because the majority of Syrian people, who stayed in the country and fought for it, don't want Assad to go, just like the killed kid.

I have a bad news for you: Assad will not be deposed. Most Syrians want him to stay.

HonestDictator

All because a "leader" thought he should use heavy-handed "enforcement" against protestors

I have another example of heavy-handed "enforcement" against protesters, it happened in Ferguson, USA. And who was the wonderful leader who ordered this?

-2 ( +2 / -4 )

The indiffirence with wich you reacted to the death of the boy, killed by "moderate terrorists" simply because he was pro-Assad, obviously demonstrates that your attitude towards opponents no softer then Assad's.

How do you know how I reacted to that boy's death? I reacted a lot more passionately than you did for Aylan al Kurdi. You just didn't care.

Russia intervened in the conflict in November 2015

A russian lie. Russia intervened in 2012 after the bombing of assads assembly where his brother in law was killed. Up until then, there was no foreign intervention on either side.

Before that Assad had fought for five years, and despite all the help from US, Turkey, Saudi Arabia, Qatar etc to terrorists of all colors he kept fighting. Why?

Because like all dictators, he has a thirst for power- just like putin.

Because the majority of Syrian people, who stayed in the country and fought for it, don't want Assad to go, just like the killed kid.

You are not syrian. don't tell us what the syrian people think. I'll tell you since I am still in contact with relatives in Aleppo. All syrians hate him. those who love him are russians and iraninans. That is all.

I have another example of heavy-handed "enforcement" against protesters, it happened in Ferguson, USA. And who was the wonderful leader who ordered this?

So now you want to equate the syrian civil war with ferguson??? really?? that just goes to show just how ridiculous the russian narrative has become. absolutely desperate. sad.

I have a bad news for you: Assad will not be deposed.

yes he will. And when he does, Russia and Iran will be deposed with him. sorry for that reality check.

Most Syrians want him to stay.

again, unless you are one of us, please don't tell me what my countrymen want. we want assad out and we want the vampire vlad putin out with him- and we will. Syria is going to be Afganistan 2 for the Russians. This will be the conflict that tears russia apart.

-4 ( +0 / -4 )

That's why neither his army or the Russians have ever bombed them.

Just to clarify, Russia bombing the crap out of the ISIS control of the oil installations, there transportation routes and trucks, putting a huge dent in their money supply is to keep them at a level of desperation, but not to eliminate them?

-1 ( +1 / -2 )

The Russians are bombing the other opposition groups. They haven't touched IS.

-3 ( +0 / -3 )

@Aly Rustom "we want assad out and we want the vampire vlad putin out with him- and we will. Syria is going to be Afganistan 2 for the Russians. This will be the conflict that tears russia apart."

Keep dreaming and beware speedy cruise missiles.Lol.

0 ( +1 / -1 )

Keep dreaming and beware speedy cruise missiles.Lol.

The Russians tried that in Afghanistan and the Americans tried that in Iraq. Both powers got their butts kicked pretty hard. Russians will get their butts kicked again. So you can keep dreaming LOL.

-3 ( +0 / -3 )

Aly Rustom

All syrians hate him. those who love him are russians and iraninans

And those who fight for Assad are also all Russians and Iranians? Seriously? All dozens of thosands of soldiers of the Syrian army are all Russians and Iranians? Wow, somebody badly needs reality check. If you knew history even a bit, particularly military and political history, you would knew that no amount of foreign support could help a government that lost support of its people. And the fact that Assad still in power, despite all efforts by mercenaries of Saudi Arabia, Turkey and Qatar, tells clearly that the majority of Syrian people support him.

The Russians are bombing the other opposition groups. They haven't touched IS

Usual lie from "moderate terrorists". On youtube there are a lot of videos of Russian bombers striking ISIS targets, such like oil trucks etc. Somebody in serious denial here.

we want assad out and we want the vampire vlad putin out with him- and we will

You claimed you live in Japan. So how you going to do it? Pushing buttons of your keyboard more desperately?

This will be the conflict that tears russia apart

Keep dreaming. Or better read a book about history. End of discussion with you.

-2 ( +1 / -3 )

And those who fight for Assad are also all Russians and Iranians? Seriously? All dozens of thosands of soldiers of the Syrian army are all Russians and Iranians?

No genius. They are Shiites who have pledged allegiance to Iran and so has Assad

Wow, somebody badly needs reality check.

Yes that's right you really do.

If you knew history even a bit, particularly military and political history, you would knew that no amount of foreign support could help a government that lost support of its people.

Really? What about Batista in Cuba? The military supported him but the people didn't that's why Castro was able to overthrow him. That comment right there shows that you know nothing of history; political, military, or otherwise.

And the fact that Assad still in power, despite all efforts by mercenaries of Saudi Arabia, Turkey and Qatar, tells clearly that the majority of Syrian people support him.

No it doesn't. The only reason he is still in power is because he has the backing of Iran and Russia. And even then he's having a hard time. That fact alone should tell you that the people of Syria don't like him. Of course you probably already know that but are just repeating Russian propaganda.

Usual lie from "moderate terrorists". On youtube there are a lot of videos of Russian bombers striking ISIS targets, such like oil trucks etc. Somebody in serious denial here.

Usual lie from Vlad the Invader's RT News pundits. We are not fooled by those lies. . The only people bombing IS are the Americans. The Russians want them there because they are terrorists just like them.

we want assad out and we want the vampire vlad putin out with him- and we will You claimed you live in Japan. So how you going to do it? Pushing buttons of your keyboard more desperately?

Look who's pushing the buttons so desperately. We don't have to do anything. The Syrian people will throw him out. Personally I think they will hang by him and Putin by their anklesfrom a gas station like Mussolini was.

Keep dreaming. Or better read a book about history.

Want to talk about history? Let's talk about the 1980s Russia in Afghanistan. Or we can talk about the Americans in Vietnam. I think if you knew anything about history which you obviously don't, you would understand that super powers which invade smaller weaker countries always get beaten.

End of discussion with you.

You gave up. Good. So will Assad and Putin.

-4 ( +0 / -4 )

You're writing such funny nonsense I can't resist to write one last short post.

They are Shiites

So,genius, Shiites are not Syrians? And after that you claim to have some relation to Syria? For your information, Shiites, Sunni, Christians, Kurds and others they are all Syrians. Definitely your way of thinking is no better then ISIS's.

What about Batista in Cuba?

Can you comprehend even simple phrases? Read again, genius, my previous post. I said that no amount of foreign support could help a government that lost support of its people. The case of Batista just confirms my thesis - no amount of foreign (US) support could save Batista. And no amount of foreign (US, Saudi, Qatar) support can save the "moderate terrorists". Wow, it's too early for you to read history books, you should finish school first. And let me use your phrase "That comment right there shows that you know nothing of history; political, military, or otherwise", you fully deserve such description.

You gave up

No, you are just not worth my time.

Keep fighting with keyboard, Assad is trembling lol

0 ( +1 / -1 )

Login to leave a comment

Facebook users

Use your Facebook account to login or register with JapanToday. By doing so, you will also receive an email inviting you to receive our news alerts.

Facebook Connect

Login with your JapanToday account

User registration

Articles, Offers & Useful Resources

A mix of what's trending on our other sites