Helix comments

Posted in: New Zealand mosque killings spark debate over free speech See in context

If I were a Muslim living in NZ, I'd never want that to see the light of day again.

Perhaps after reading it, but not before. Logically, how could you ever arrive at such strong feelings about the manifesto if neither you nor anyone you know, nor any journalist, nor any domestic media outlet is legally allowed to download and read its contents because of the ban? This is the fundamental absurdity of censoring it.

I suspect 99% of those in favor of censoring the manifesto are already familiar with its contents. But imagine if this wasn't the case. Imagine if the authorities in NZ acted so quickly to take down and ban the manifesto that nobody outside of the NZ government knew the motives for the attack. Would you still support suppression of the manifesto? Would you be satisfied with the government's official story? Do you realise how much distrust and how many conspiracy theories this would generate? Calling for censorship of a publication that you've already read is too easy.

1 ( +2 / -1 )

Posted in: New Zealand mosque killings spark debate over free speech See in context

If I were a Muslim living in New Zealand I would want to download and read the manifesto just to better understand and gauge any threats that my family might be facing. This should really be a fundamental right.

Is there a single example of where censorship of ideas by the ruling political elite has ended well?

0 ( +1 / -1 )

Posted in: Want trillions of dollars injected into the economy? Pay women the same as men See in context

Increasing the female labor force to match that of Sweden - where 69 percent of women work - would add a further $6 trillion to countries in the OECD,

At what cost? Even Nordic countries which have the most generous benefits for working women are facing crisis levels of fertility, well below replacement rates. What's the purpose of boosting GDP by a few points over the short term if it only accelerates the precipitous population decline that all industrialized countries are facing? No western country has a fertility rate that reaches population replacement levels. This is the real crisis our societies are facing, so we would be much better off to stop this admiration of career women who enter the workforce and instead build a society that rewards and respects stay at home motherhood. The values and preferences that we've promoted over the past few decades have led to an unsustainable society.

1 ( +4 / -3 )

Posted in: Trump warns conservatives against 'socialist nightmare' in fiery 2-hour speech See in context

If I'm allowed to post a link, this is a table of social welfare spending my country. In 2013 Canada spent $7,506 per capita on its citizens. Japan $8,442. America $9,838 and Scandinavia between $12-14,000.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_social_welfare_spending

-6 ( +2 / -8 )

Posted in: Trump warns conservatives against 'socialist nightmare' in fiery 2-hour speech See in context

Then how do you explain Canada?

Canada is not a socialist country by any reasonable definition. The healthcare system has been socialised, but that's common in all developed countries. Canada's personal tax rates are not high compared to OECD averages, and their corporate taxes are even lower than the US. Canada ranks below the US on social spending as a percentage of GDP and on a per capita basis. Canada even spends less than Japan on a per capita basis. If you think Canada is socialist, which country isn't? How do the US and Japan fall short of your definition of socialism?

-7 ( +2 / -9 )

Posted in: Trump warns conservatives against 'socialist nightmare' in fiery 2-hour speech See in context

Scandinavia succeeds predominantly because it's full of Scandinavians, not because they've discovered some magic ratio of tax rates and welfare payments which allow socialism to work everywhere. These are high IQ, high trust, largely homogenous societies with low populations and pre-existing wealth. If you were to copy ever law on the books in Sweden and enact it wholesale in South America, Africa or the United States, you're unlikely to replicate Scandinavia.

-6 ( +3 / -9 )

Posted in: Warmbier's parents blame N Korea for son's death; Trump says his comments misinterpreted See in context

If you want an alternative hypothesis not involving North Korean torture, I would point you to an article written by the investigative journalist Doug Clark, published in GQ, July 23 2018.

1 ( +2 / -1 )

Posted in: Warmbier's parents blame N Korea for son's death; Trump says his comments misinterpreted See in context

Why would Kim order the death of an American prisoner who'd have been far more valuable alive? Why would North Korea scare off foreign tourists, which are now the regime's most important source of hard currency?

-18 ( +5 / -23 )

Posted in: Compulsory sex and LGBT+ education sparks religious backlash in UK See in context

The new education guidelines will also see children aged 11 and older being taught about the harm caused by female genital mutilation (FGM), as well as grooming, forced marriage, domestic abuse and "honor-based abuse".

So instead of investing more classroom time teaching maths and english, little Tommy and Sue will now be learning about about FGM, grooming gangs, forced marriages and honor killings? The absolute state of the UK in 2019.

-2 ( +6 / -8 )

Posted in: Chicago police release 2 men questioned in Smollett case See in context

When victimhood and racism become society's new currency, don't be surprised when people start minting their own hoax hate.

2 ( +4 / -2 )

Posted in: Democrat Warren kicks off 2020 run, hobbled by ancestry row See in context

CrazyJoe,

Are people so desperate for a female candidate that they're willing to support a liar and fraud? Her claims that she was Native American are as offensive or more as blackface - she is a racist pure and simple. Anyone who supports her supports racism and identify appropriation.

However only 8 days ago you defended Warren and wrote this about people criticising her for claiming to be Cherokee:

How ridiculous! Anyone is free to get their DNA tested if they so desire.

The orange dotard challenged Warren to prove she had native-American blood, and she did. (Btw, he reneged on his promise to pay $1million to charity – true to form.)

Her DNA is her DNA – she can't change it. She never claimed to be part of a tribe, so in what way did she undermine tribal interests?

https://japantoday.com/category/world/democrat-elizabeth-warren-apologizes-to-cherokee-nation-for-dna-test

What caused you to do a complete 180 on this issue over the past week? You seem to be deeply conflicted and confused.

3 ( +5 / -2 )

Posted in: Democrat Elizabeth Warren apologizes to Cherokee Nation for DNA test See in context

Her DNA is her DNA – she can't change it. She never claimed to be part of a tribe, so in what way did she undermine tribal interests?

Elizabeth Warren did make claims about having a 'Cherokee ancestor'. The Cherokee are a political entity, not a distinct ethnicity or racial group that can be ever be determined by any DNA test. To suggest otherwise creates confusion about the nature of their membership criteria, even if you acknowledge that you are not a member.

1 ( +3 / -2 )

Posted in: London mother guilty of mutilating daughter in landmark FGM trial See in context

Why is female genital mutilation of a child illegal while male genital mutilation is not?

5 ( +5 / -0 )

Posted in: Workspaces centered on women on the rise in #MeToo movement See in context

I think women, especially, are craving safe spaces where they can go and be inspired and do really important work without interruption

Sounds plausible from an evolutionary standpoint considering this is how women have worked for millenia, apart from the past few decades.

3 ( +3 / -0 )

Posted in: Balance of intelligence factors makes Japan the world’s smartest country, according to this list See in context

iQ tests have been proven to be inaccurate.

This is just not the case. No mainstream psychologist would agree with this statement. While there can be some debate about the extent to which any particular test of cognitive ability measures underlying intelligence, the test scores remain the best single predictor of job performance, educational success, relative poverty, and dozens of other life outcomes. In other words, even if you dispute that tests of cognitive ability measure underlying intelligence fully (or at all), you are left with the fact that whatever it is that they are measuring (assuming it's not intelligence) has tremendous predictive validity for life outcomes.

-1 ( +2 / -3 )

Posted in: Balance of intelligence factors makes Japan the world’s smartest country, according to this list See in context

China and Japan having high IQs makes sense to me because I think using kanji is inherently more difficult than Western writing systems

I think that could be one reason for a higher average IQ.*

Unfortunately learning to read has not been shown to increase underlying intelligence. IQ tests done on very young children demonstate the IQ advantage of Northeast Asians even before they are taught to read. Even if you take an evolutionary view and propose that people of higher intelligence who mastered Kanji had some reproductive edge over the illiterate in ancient times, Kanji and literacy itself are relatively new phenomena in Asian/human history. It's likely far too recent and limited to have any noticeable effects on average population intelligence.

The most widely accepted theory for explaining Northeast Asian intelligence is that they evolved in extremely harsh winter climates in Siberia where being more intelligent would ensure survival. Asians also have physically larger average brains compared to any other human population. Brain size correlates with IQ at around 0.3-0.4.

1 ( +3 / -2 )

Recent Comments

Popular

Articles, Offers & Useful Resources

A mix of what's trending on our other sites


©2019 GPlusMedia Inc.