Kazume Nishidate comments

Christopher Glen You are wrong. see the link below.

========================================== Michael Yon Japan-Korea: Were Korean Men Cowards during World War II?

A vexing question

There are growing, unsubstantiated questions about whether the Japanese Imperial Army kidnapped 200,000 sex-slaves (Comfort Women) in World War II. Mostly from Korea.

A $30 million US Government Study specifically searched for evidence on Comfort Women allegations.

After nearly seven years with many dozens of staff pouring through US archives -- and 30 million dollars down the drain -- we found a grand total of nothing.

The final IWG report to Congress was issued in 2007. (Linked below.)

Nobody should be writing about Comfort Women issues without reading this report cover to cover.

Many of the unsubstantiated claims are coming from Korea. Korean allegations have led to unexpected twists.

At the time, Korea was actually part of Japan -- roughly in the way that Puerto Rico is part of the USA.

Many Koreans were members of the Japanese military. So any allegations that the Japanese military kidnapped 200,000 women implies that Koreans were involved in kidnapping Koreans. This is an uncomfortable reality. It gets even more uncomfortable.

So today, South Korean President Park Geun-hye constantly accuses Japan of kidnapping these shiploads of women.

Imagine how this boomerangs back. President Park is saying that Japan -- and her daddy was an officer in the Japanese Army at the time -- kidnapped uncounted tens of thousands of women from Korea as sex-slaves. Yet there is no evidence that Korean men fought back.

During the war, Korea had a population of about 23 million. Today, Texas has a population of about 26 million.

Imagine trying to kidnap 200,000 Texas women. There would be a bloodbath. The Army would lose thousands of soldiers, and thousands of civilians no doubt would have been slaughtered in return.

Evidence would be everywhere. Photos. Films. Battle sites. Texans would never allow 200,000 women to be stolen and raped without making a river of blood. So President Park is essentially saying Korean men during World War II were a bunch of cowards.

Also imagine this from the perspective of a Japanese military General or Admiral. He is at war with the USA, Australia, Britain, China, and more. His hands are full. The USA in particular is on the march with our Navy and Marines, and we are smashing Japan anywhere we can find Japanese.

All generals always want more troops and supplies. That is a fact of life. Just ask any General. Ask any business leader what he or she needs to expand or defend against competition: They always want more resources.

What kind of fool General would dedicate the resources to kidnap, guard, transport, and feed 200,000 women, knowing that he is creating yet another war to fight?

The Japanese were highly advanced military thinkers. They made their own submarines, airplanes, and aircraft carriers. These were serious people, and super smart.

There is no way that Generals would dedicate those resources to kidnapping women when the US military and allies were marching down their throats. They had a war to fight -- this was not Spring Break.

Any serious military or business person can see the folly in common sense of kidnapping 200,000 women. It does not make sense, and would have created a new war in Korea -- which was a base for Japanese recruitment. Koreans were fighting Americans. Koreans were our enemy.

And back to Korean men. It would be horrific to see the US Army try to kidnap 200,000 Texas women -- especially so considering that many US military members are Texans, just as many Koreans were Japanese Soldiers.

Texas would rise up and start smashing the Army. Bridges would blow up. Soldiers would be shot every day. Bases would burn. The Army would fight back and there would be total war.

So are we to believe that Korean men are such cowards that nobody lifted a hand to defend their women? Because if they allowed these many women to be kidnapped, they are cowards, and their sons today had cowards for fathers.

The reality is that we know that Koreans are no cowards. Koreans are a courageous people. So what really happened? It is clear from source documents, and the common sense that every water buffalo possesses, that there was no mass kidnapping.

It's all a lie, and no matter how much someone hates Japan, it will always be a lie.

Please read the IWG report that practically nobody seems to know exists. If you do not have time for the whole report, do a search inside the report for Comfort Women, and carefully read those parts:

http://www.archives.gov/iwg/reports/final-report-2007.pdf

========================================

Original link to the FB page

https://www.facebook.com/MichaelYonFanPage/photos/a.235978145664.135781.207730000664/10152528275045665/?type=1&pnref=story

Japanese translation by Kent Gilbert (FB page)

https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=722058237885039&set=a.607719835985547.1073741828.100002426074837&type=1&fref=nf&pnref=story

Robbie1985, It is a good point.

Here is the report 49. everyone can investigate it.

http://www.exordio.com/1939-1945/codex/Documentos/report-49-USA-orig.html

itsonlyrocknroll

You mentioned the article of Testimonies of "Comfort Women" of WW2... Maki Kimura Issue 8, April 2003. Look at the reference # 1 of the article. It is the “Asahi Shinbun (1991)”.

Asahi shinbun, a big newspaper company in Japan, recently admitted that they had falsely informed us the comfort woman issues. So the document you indicated was primary basing on the false information source.

They were recruited and became professional sex workers. They were the Chinese, Korean, and Japanese women. Some of them earned good salaries. It was regal at that time.

check the link.

https://www.facebook.com/MichaelYonFanPage/posts/10152532482920665

I leave here the link relating to the problem.

http://hassin.org/01/category/literature/comfortwomen

Please check the following sections.

Please check the following titles

A Guide to Understanding Comfort women Controversy

and

COMFORT WOMEN IN KOREA

where you can find the links for the PDF documents. Japanese as well as English versions are available.

Here is a classical document written by NISHIOKA Tsutomu in 2007:

BEHIND THE COMFORT WOMEN CONTROVERSY: HOW LIES BECAME TRUTH

He concluded the document with the statement of

We must expose the lies they have been spreading during the past 15 years. That is the only way we can defeat them. And we shall prevail, because truth is on our side.

http://www.sdh-fact.com/CL02_1/39_S4.pdf

A very thought-provoking comment of the Journalist Michael Yon.

https://www.facebook.com/MichaelYonFanPage/posts/10152528332430665:0

Hagino is a genuine athlete. There is something dignified in his reply comment.